Audience

Saturday, 26 September 2020

 

Letting Go of an Old Belief:

Psychoanalysis is what we learn and train in IPA and IPA like institutes. Outside that set up we will likely encounter deviations from ‘true’ psychoanalysis.

One Consciousness not two:

I just received a personal email from a senior and very insightful colleague regarding the interest of young psychologist-in academia- in psychoanalysis. My colleague expressed the wish to be excluded from any possible open discussion of that matter on the member’s listserv. Therefore, I will mention two of his new and valuable ideas without mentioning his name.

He stated that the interest of young psychologists in psychoanalysis is due to the on-going deterioration of the condition of teaching psychology (post cognitive psychology) in departments of psychology. I do not have first hand knowledge of that but from past experience I can see the correctness and weight of such idea.  The second is the best characterization I encountered of the psychoanalysis we presently train young analysis in (I wish to get the sentence and the permission to publish it). In summary, psychologists are studying a dying science because there is nothing that could be new or different in studying psychological cognitive functions now (memory, conflict solving, etc.) than what was there to study twenty years ago. His description of contemporary psychoanalysis underlines the troubling issue of the use and abuse of the vocabulary of “psychoanalytic” observation as its theoretical foundation. His characterization of psychoanalysis and the observation about the psychology of conscious function is the best understating of the need of psychology for learning about the intrapsychical dynamics, and psychoanalysts’ need to change the substance and the method of learning psychoanalysis. Psychologists have to open up their science to the unconscious processes that shapes the intrapsychical dynamics, and analysts have to know that personal analysis was and still is the only way to experience how psychoanalysis is done, therefore make clear the link between what is done in analyzing and what is taught about it. There is no literature or scientific material that could teach how analysis is clinically done. This ‘fact’ should make learning and training in  psychoanalysis centered on what we work on changing in therapy, and how its done through psychoanalysis not via correcting cognitive failings.

      The significance of my colleague’s two remarks, which unfortunately will not be properly presented by me, is in making us see that psychology without learning about the unconscious dynamics is a dead science. He also makes it clear that psychoanalysts without a clear and good definition of consciousness will be without a subject matter. The human subject deals with his psychological life in two ways at the same time:  one conscious and the other is unconscious. The issue is that we deal with our life both consciously and unconsciously at the same time.  There is only one consciousness in each human subject, but aspects of that consciousness are not always within the fields of the subject’s awareness. There is no consciousness without its own unconscious counterpart.  The unconscious is one of the different conditions in consciousness. I need to emphasize a point: unconsciousness does not suddenly jump into the patient or the analyst consciousness but reveals itself through, within, or by the distortion it creates in consciousness.

Therefore, we should approach the new wave of interest in psychoanalysis as the natural and healthy awareness of psychologists to the fact that any cognitive, emotional, mental event is subject to the influence and the contribution of unconscious aspects that we are unaware of, and we need to uncover to make our consciousness meaningful. Most importantly, we should consider the psychologists recent interest in psychoanalysis not an invitation to participate in the academic world of psychology, but a call for unifying the conscious\unconscious duality in one psychology that envelops the subjects’ psychological life (from sickness to ingeniousness). We should work on modifying our conception of the unconscious to meet the psychologist expected effort to acknowledge their need to advance their understanding of the human subject. Psychologists still have some good work to do in regard of the cognitive, emotional and mental phenomena that require different understanding with adding the unconscious as vital constituent of psychologic life.

Accepting that there is only one consciousness that in some conditions escapes attention is the way to free psychoanalysis from its isolation from any meaningful status. The notion of one consciousness that encompasses several dualities will make the idea of uniting psychology and psychoanalysis a logical and a natural thing. However, this notion is a big pill for psychoanalysts-medical and none medical- to swallow. Psychoanalysis has been a practice that several professions could seek training in it.  The creation of the new science of psychoanalysis will reverse this situation: instead of different professions getting training in psychoanalysis, psychoanalysis will create different professions that need solid basis in psychoanalysis.

It is useful and very important to note that the push to change psychology to become more than a science of the conscious psychological functions, and psychoanalysis’s to be more than a discipline of psychotherapy, happened in a natural way: unconsciously. It is not happening because of individual calls but as the outcome a need for change. It is rewarding to wait for normal change get rid of the declining old.


Saturday, 12 September 2020

 

The Link Between the Social and the Individual:

 In the previous part of this posting I postulated that the social precedes the existence of the individual and the psychological is a product of the social. My basic argument is that a gathering of individuals in some sort of a group changes their individual psychology, strongly implying that every group of people has its psychology, which goes beyond the psychology of each of its members separately. The other point is that the individual psychology of a member could undergoes changes while social psychology is not affected by the psychology of the individual, except when we deal with issues pertaining to leadership.

The recent predicaments the USA society is facing brings to attention a gradual closeness happening between whites and blacks, radicals and conservatives, higher and lower classes; even Republicans and Democrats. This is major change. Thus, the link between the social and the individual is the main issue in the phenomenon of change, as such. Change is always that gradual narrowing or widening of gaps between opposites in the society. In other terms, when we look closer to social change, we could notice a tendency to turning the social into psychological or separating the psychological from the social: at the present time whites are psychologically prone and inclined to condemn what was -maybe- accepted or ignored a few years or months ago. The point is that psychoanalysts reject to give social changes the deserved attention because they do not know how to fit that change in a psychological formulation of problems. As an example, dealing with racial discrimination from the narcissistic point of view is something recently accepted and integrated in the analysts view of the return of the repressed. Yet, if we introduce the notion that Blacks too have narcissistic issues that needs to be considered part of understanding the contemporary picture of racial discrimination, psychoanalysts get flustered because they thought only of a situation that their basic analytic training could make them deals with. (I can vouch for that from the responses I get to suggesting addressing Blacks’ narcissism in our thinking. The main objection is a wrong understanding of narcissism as self-love, and anything else would complicate of dealing with social narcissism and dividual narcissism (of blacks).

The move from the social to the psychological is a movement that most psychoanalysts neglect that it is happening all the time, even in the psychoanalytic organizations. As neglecting this fact in a society leads to social unrest and missing good chances to move ahead. My thought about that is coming from being an analyst and having experiences with my colleagues’ resistance to notice the forces of social change and the reluctant of the ‘individuals’ give up their dissections. Not being classical (or what one has learned in his training) is a common resistance to change in psychoanalysis.

Coming back to the main issue: the gradual and unavoidable social change changes the methods of rearing the young, male-female relations, and moral and familial concepts among many other things related to daily life. Social change creates new “human subjects”. Analysts, particularly in the USA are unable to look at psychoanalysis from the point of view that they can acknowledge change and still remain devoted to their traditional ways of thinking. Because what changes in the society is the individual and in the psychoanalytic society is the analyst then we could say that the subject matter of both ‘socials’ maintain their inner cores: a contemporary subject will be as moral or immoral as his ancestors but according to a new system of morality. In psychoanalysis, a modern analyst will remain advocate of psychoanalysis but with a better understanding of its discoveries about the subject. An example, a modern analyst will not understand narcissism as withdrawal of libidinal investment to the self, but as a disturbance in the sense of identity. The subject of the twentieth century deals with sexuality differently but guilt about sexuality would  still remain present in modernity.

We come now to the third point: is there a psychoanalytic theory of the society? Psychoanalysis is a theory of the subject. Any changes to the subject that is resulting from social change will require psychoanalysts to look closely at the psychodynamics of that new subject. It is expected that the psychodynamics will remain the same (defense mechanism or the usage of metaphors as the means of expressing the unconscious. The changes in the Oedipal triangle will be different and expressing the difference in new patterns of attachments will be the contemporary analyst’s job.  This change will dictate changes in the meaning of love, aggression, loyalty, etc. That might need reformulating aspects of the ‘social’ according to those changes but  the permanency of the psychical will not be affected by the social in a manner that will turn the subject into a human object with no psychological life.

 In a broader conception we could say that psychoanalysis will have a new theory of the subject of the ‘social’ of the time. The subject of the twenty first century will be replaced by contemporary issues that pertain to modernity. Although the ‘social’ is a multifaceted topic (economics, familial rules and structuring, morality and spirituality, etc.,) all those facets get internally organised in a way that permits the sociologist to have new social theories, but psychoanalysis will be limited in what has to be changed.

Sunday, 6 September 2020





Psychoanalysis and Social Events (USA).

The psychoanalysts’ contributions to evaluating and understanding social phenomena is not a simple matter, because it requires moving from the field of the psyche to another field of phenomena that they have little or no experience with, i.e., the social. This shift is like shifting from medicine to epidemiology. Talking about a medical problem in clinical practice is not like talking about the same medical problem in socio-epidemic phenomenon. The main point is that we cannot apply the same understanding of the individual (criminal mind) on a society that is suffering from an increase in criminality. The social is made of hundreds and thousands of different individuals. Even a small group of individuals who are alike (psychoanalysts !!) act differently as a group; their psychology as individuals change and a different spirit takes over.
This point of view has to deal-I think-with three issues: 1. what creates the other, the social or the psychological, 2. what could be the link between a social theory and theories of the individual,3. Is there or could there be a psychoanalytic theory of society?
I believe knowing more about those three issues will ultimately allow dealing with another perplexing question: do people create their leaders or is it the leaders who influences people? Is it Alexander the great who encouraged the Greeks to invade the world or was it the Greeks who were eager to go beyond their group of islands and created Alexander to actualize their desire? 

1.    The Social and its Psychological Counterpart:

The late events of unrest, demonstrations, obvious political conflicts, and raising the issues of race discriminations in the USA could be explained by clear and blatant police racial bigotries. Putting the issue in this way proves that there are other factors that are not considered: police bigotries is not a new matter and was evident- in the same manner-for a long time before. The percentage of black incarcerations compared to whites is another evidence that what happened lately has been happening before too.  It seems that nothing new is recently started to change. Yet, the rise of the white people in solidarity with blacks and their adoption of the spirit of objecting to police behaviour is something new. It is new because that change is not response to changes in the circumstances; it is change in people white they are or black. It is a change in the American society not just its black minority. Moreover, this change is not in the ‘material’ conditions of people (income, education, class structure, etc.). The change that happened lately is a change in the psychological characteristics and attributes of both blacks and whites.  As a foreigner, who is observing from a distance, black Americans have produced a strong evidence that they are as capable as the whites, when they find the stance, and they serve the country as well as whites do with the same dedication and skill (federal and local governments, media, etc.).

However, some Americans, and not just a few, could no longer build their narcissism on the old conviction that blacks are inferior people. They also could not ameliorate deep rooted hatred and aggression toward blacks to be simple despise and disregard. Psychologically, the whites who still do not accept equality of the blacks are preserving old means of maintaining a narcissistic feeling of distinction, and transmitting it from generation to generation. The unobvious but proof to the still existence of those resistant attributes is their sudden and sporadic displays in social relations. They come out like the return of the unconscious in individual cases.  To say it briefly “the social pre-exists the individual but uses its tools of expression as the means to make a statement”.

2.    The Suddenness of Social Change:

Social changes that create new individual awareness (counterparts) look like a sudden turning point in a regular stream of affairs. As an example, the gradual industrialisation of the North in the United State gradually created few businesses and businessmen (Carnegie, Roosevelt, Morgan, …)  which and who wanted to expand in the south and modernize that part of the US. Notwithstanding their progressive intentions and the leadership of Lincoln, they also realised that they will benefit from the war itself (W. Scheidel), 2018). The minds of the northern Americans and the new emigrants made the civil war a possibility, a fact and an act. At the same period of time, the no change (fixation) in the south maintained the notion of farming and slavery unchanged, therefore they denied the change in the balks around them. All big historical events happen in the same way because they surprise the people themselves who unconsciously changed. The equivalent to that in the individual is the impact of an interpretation on a patient while he is preconscious of what he was relaying to the analyst.

Therefore, it is important when we try to understand what is happening now is to listen to what those acts are saying to us preconsciously. They are not saying that they believe in slavery but they say we still believe in racial discrimination: Why, and why more policemen than expected of law enforcing people? More than that: the events are saying (preconsciously): they are not like us. The events happening now in the streets of cities and town in the USA talks about unusuality in one of its forms. This is not a racial matter. Racial discrimination is ‘used’(preconsciously) to object to other inequalities. The dream of Americans was always equal opportunity. The present-day dream is looking for the value that supported that dream till now.

3.    Thank God that very few people listen to psychoanalysts when it comes to social matters; or they would have lost trust in us as therapists too. As a preparation for the point I want to make I would like to mention a short exchange with a colleague, many years ago, about ‘socialising’ psychoanalysis? He claimed that we know all what it needs to understand human phenomena, whatever,
I asked why Wars? He said it the natural aggressive endowment in us. Why aggression in us is a natural thing he replied because introjection persecutory object that we need to keep getting rid of. I stopped the discussion there because Klein’s vocabulary will keep him going uselessly.  Sadly, analysts in American association jumped on a term-otherness- as the key to riddle of racial dis crimination.
In reality, in child psychology, the child recognises his mother’s image in mirror few weeks before showing any sign of know who is the other child who sits on his mother’s lab. We know ourselves as others and we remain otherness to ourselves for ever. We say I and one as exchangeable pronoun. This approach to explaining racial discrimination stop sat the point of departure. It is not otherness but the rejection of separateness is the problem. A British is otherness but a black American is an I that I hate. Let’s look at that closer because white persecutors could be diverting their self hate away from themselves.
I do not believe there is psychoanalytic theory of the social, as there is no sociological theory of the psychical. That does not answer the question that is the core of the next part of this posting: since there is a link between the social and the individual could there be a theory about that link; could we have some guiding principals to examine the link between racial discrimination and the evident need for social changes in the American ……..etc.?