Audience

Tuesday, 27 April 2021

 

Evolution, Change, and Training in Psychoanalysis

In recent exchanges among members of the American Psychoanalytic Associations there is soul searching about matters related to training and its discontents. They are coming in different forms of memories, hesitations, conflicts about maintaining the old and the necessity of giving it up. It also shows that we all have a difficult time for another more serious reason: recently we discovered that some of the ‘unquestionable’ fundamentals of psychoanalysis- as we knew it and practiced for mor than a century- are dogma that we did not know the logic behind them. We adopted the psychoanalytic protocols regarding practice (# of sessions, the couch, silence, distance, etc.), training (Eitington’s model), and some theoretical dogma (free association) without any rational effort to-at least- know what decided their import in the first place. Eitington’s model of training was firstly decided because the practice of analysis at that time had to be learned in a modality of apprenticeship (there was little to teach and more to learn). The number of sessions was also dictated by the need for quick training and more trainers who were to return to their countries to create training facilities. All that had to be done in a short period of time as a result of the novelty of psychoanalysis and its fast expansion. Free association was and still is a cognitive impossibility (transcendence of consciousness and consciousness of consciousness). I do not have to say more; just try free associating and see what will come out of it. But, if we go back to the immediate phase after abandoning hypnotism, we could clearly see that Freud meant by free association just talking freely or talk first and then see what you wanted to say (talk to know not about what you know). Free association is not what Carl Young attempted in his ‘word test’.  

The tripartite protocol was a very intuitive clinical gesture, like the intuition about Wild Analysis, (Freud, 1910). It was a stroke of ‘genius’ in which Freud condensed in that protocol the whole gamut of the distinctions that latter made ‘psychoanalyzing’ different from any current or future psychotherapies. However, there is very little, in the literature, that explains their significance (as far as I know in English and French literature). Psychoanalysis was an identifiable entity till the early fifties of last century.  The ‘controversies’ in the British Society, and the troubles between Nacht and the rebels in France around the same time, revealed that psychoanalysis is not one definable matter, but a field of an evolving and developing epistemology that could give birth to conflicting points of view. Furthermore, psychoanalysis could not stop its own evolution, and its natural process of changing, thus it is unsettled on one stable, definable connotation, especially in the area of its practice. Therefore, the term psychoanalysis does not mean the same to all of us. Our loyalty to psychoanalysis (adhering to tradition) should be to it as a term and symbol not as a fixed connotation of somethings analytical, because it is clear and obvious that most of us use the terminology of psychoanalysis as the tool to explain psychical matters, while they are- as fact- issues that require explanations based on what we understand now, which is better than the ones who coined that vocabulary. 

What was there before the controversies of the British Society was not psychoanalysis but a new understanding of us (humans) that was called ‘psychoanalysis’. However, that understanding was an understanding that initiated further understandings and different ones.  The controversies revealed that the field of understanding, and misunderstanding is open for points of view, which revealed diversities and many personal conflicts.  In other words psychoanalysis stopped being psychoanalysis from the time the controversies created two groups, then one more, declaring the opening of the gates. It was never one psychoanalysis since then. As such, any assertion of something about psychoanalysis that is not relative to what is relevant to furthering its discoveries is a false loyalty. In a more comprehensive sentence: the discovery of the person in his psychical condition started a theory that is in continually progressing and evolving, and also facing relentless resistance to those necessary changes, which result from its evolution. A good example to this sentence is the emergence of the schools of psychoanalysis in the eighties and nineties of last century: they were not new discoveries in the theory of man or in the field of the tripartite protocol of practice; they were attempts at replacing psychoanalysis without any substantive evidence of its inadequacy, or of a substantive evidence to the adequacy of the new proposed protocols.

The Evolution of Psychoanalysts and the Stagnating Training:

I will discuss three issues concerning training because all the training institutions of psychoanalysis irrespectively share the interest in those three issues: The Training Analyst, the Psychoanalytic Setup, Personal Analysis.

1.The Training Analyst:

 After over a hundred years since the establishment of the first training institute of psychoanalysis in Berlin we find ourselves, still stuck with the apprenticeship modality of training: knowledge owned by someone (or more), and one can only acquire it by personal contact with that person or persons. Regardless of all what happened to psychoanalysis and the psychoanalysts over those hundred years, the IPA -as the legitimate voice of psychoanalysis- still does not acknowledge that we have gained a wealth of knowledge about the human subject that exists independently of the training analyst, and beyond the capacity of one ‘training’ analyst to deliver. Worse, creating the status of “training analyst”, which suited apprenticeship training, ignored that the contemporary psychoanalyst needs to learn more than the limited literature of psychoanalysis, which training analysts do not have. For an example, the disappearance of the diagnosis of hysteria, nowadays, is a result of basic changes in the sexual attitudes of societies, the place of metaphor\metonymy in everyday life speech, the evolution of the identity of females. Training analysts are not expert enough to lecture or train in those areas, which are vital to keep psychoanalysis a viable theory and stop its stagnation. Previously, the training analyst knew more about what the candidate needed to know, but now what the candidate needs to know is the functions of a whole educational system and institution. Furthermore, previously training was limited to practicing psychoanalysis in psychotherapy. This is not possible anymore, if not because limiting training to that task would not appeal to the eager candidate, it will be because it limits training to dealing with problem that do not exist anymore.

Candidates do not need someone to train them in psychoanalysis; they can learn it directly and from each other. A good syllabus and a god academic team of thinkers could do a much better job than few training analysts put together. The reason is that psychoanalysis is in continuous process of evolving while analyst seem to prefer stagnation. Thus, eliminating the status of the training analyst is long overdue and should be replaced by ‘educationists’ in certain areas of the humanities because as the human subject is changing the theory about him must have changed also. Yet, there is an aspect in the “formation” of the analyst that requires the input of a good well informed and skilled psychoanalyst, not necessarily a training analyst. It is personal analysis.

2. Personal Analysis:

Eitington’s model of training reflected the situation of psychoanalysis at that time, a hundred years ago: new and simplistic, theoretically very tentative, and provisional, and lacking clear guidance to how it is done. It was in demand by unorganized groups of people of different backgrounds and inclinations. Personal analysis- the third requirement in training- was an important way of qualifying the new commers, because there were no tested ideas about the method or the theory of practice to present to the new seekers of psychoanalysi. The candidate had to go through the experience of analysis as a patient to learn how to do it with patients. Naturally and unfortunately the objective and meaning of that part of training got distorted and confusing: is it therapeutic or didactic? Is it therapeutic because analysts are expected to be psychologically healthy, or is it didactic, which means that going through the process is a learning experience that could not be properly explained to teach and learn from the literature? Although we now have a clearer idea of the workings of the psychoanalytic processes, we still do not agree on most of their connotations, because we do not know the logic behind them. We obviously prefer the familiar because it is safe and looks sure. That is why we want to stay with a psychoanalysis that is outdated, and out of synchrony.

Another serious matter in training is what and when to interpret, and what and when to reconstruct the material interpreted? Why not answer a question by the patient when he is clearly expecting a response etc.? Maybe, this should be left to the personal skill of the analyst. Nevertheless, the difficulty in that issue sheds light on the issue of a training analyst. Only in personal analysis do we encounter those situations and witness the analyst style in dealing with them (style but not reason). This point leads directly to the issue of the didactic analyst (not the training analyst) and his ways of conducting the personal analysis of candidates. There is no way, method, or teaching guide that could introduce a candidate to the practice of psychoanalysis but going through it personally. But this statement has to be qualified. The analyst has to know what he is doing and not doing, not just intuited in his doings, i.e. able to explain verbally what he does. The analyst has to also have in mind how his work is effecting in the patient, thus has a responsibility of knowing beforehand what to be said decide how to say it. Better, personal analysis is the cornerstone of training if done by a special kind of analyst that has nothing to do with whether he is Training Analyst or not.  It is obvious that this part of personal analysis has a therapeutic value in addition to its didactic value, and the analyst who does that is de facto a training analyst (his analytic work teaches the candidate\patient something). Nevertheless, selecting the proper candidates for training should not be linked to the issue of personal analysis.

I hope that my emphasis on the lack of need for training analysts and our dependency on good analysts highlights the gap between formal and informal training.

3.The Analytic Setup.

The basis of Freud’s ingenious intuition in the psychoanalytic protocol, particularly regarding transference extended to the setup of practicing the psychoanalytic act itself. He proffered a setup to be applied with all patients; thus the differences in outcome could be referred to the patients and not considered reactions to the circumstance but of practice.

When I gained confidence in my understanding and my practice of psychoanalysis (26 years) I decided to actively use that change ((three more years). I put to the patients the issue of selecting what suit them best in terms of the setup of their analysis, with the understanding that there will be no changes at a later time, or as they wish. The choices were the couch or the seat, three or four sessions per week, vacations, cancellations, payments, termination, length of sessions (mine were 45 minutes). My view was to eliminate using projection, at a later time, as means to manipulate the analytic setup. I did not emulate my two previous analysts in doing that, and I was also aware that I was breaking what seemed like an absolute tenets of psychoanalysis, when there were actually none (Freud improvised the couch position because He felt less stressed when the patients were not looking at him sitting during the sessions).

This point requires some elucidation because it will likely be misconceived by most. Since the original setup of the analytic situation was not decided based on any psychoanalytical principles or requirements, thus the analyst along with the patient should decide and stick to their decision about what is more convenient for both. This could be done with the proviso that there are requirement, limitations, consistency, and mutual understanding that the analytic set up and observing it is part of the process itself. Requesting changes to the original setup was subjected to analyzing and material for examination and analysis. The other aspect in the managing of the setup was what the protocol of practice is emphasizing. The analyst’s neutrality, anonymity, and abstinence, if strictly observed in his reactions to the patient’s attempt to use them in his relationship with him he would be preserving the place of transference in interpreting the patient’s material. If the patient has a factual issue about the analyst and the analyst does not confirm it or deny it the transference material will eventually reveal itself.

Evolution of Psychoanalysis and Training Change:

The endeavor to carrying on with leftovers of old psychoanalysis (vocabulary) is useless, if not detrimental. The most it could do is giving a skeleton for a poor system of psychotherapy. In other terms, the vocabulary of psychoanalysis that is currently used, and in most cases considered the theory of psychoanalysis, is just terminology of no specificities. Therefore, most of the leftover vocabulary of the old psychoanalysis was-or should be- a stop gap until we understand what things are. As an example: identification, in the original usage of the term, meant a process of self-definition based on assuming an identity that goes beyond the subject’s own authenticity: “identified with his father or the aggressor”. However, after decades of dealing with the subject in more than one capacity, we amassed a vast knowledge about identification that could (should) clarify that psychical process in a different and clear way. We learned few things about narcissism, projection, love\hate relations, interpersonal and intrapsychic structures. We cannot or should not understand identification in the same old meaning because it is not a simple process of introjection. We would be doing ourselves a great favor if we examine the human subject’s Grief reaction to loosing an object of identification.

Psychoanalysis has evolved to get closer to understanding its subject matter; the human being, but that is not clear to the naked eye because its training is stagnant at a backward point. Its training has to match that progress and not keep recycling the old. It has to because the humanities are modernized and have commensurate systems of learning and training, and we need to join them. We still in owe of our forefathers… or are we?! A possible answer to that question: no we are not. It is just that we have no analyst with vision to see, prepare, and work on moving forward to let our forefather rest in peace.    

Thursday, 15 April 2021

 

 

A Way Out of Stagnation

Toward A Contemporary Psychoanalysis

I am quite sure this posting will not go well with the majority of old and contemporary psychoanalysts and candidates. It is not on psychoanalysis, but about it. I am going back to my choice of Freud’s four intuitions briefly, to demonstrate how the academic approach to psychoanalysis differs from the clinical one or the customary way we learn it and teach it to candidates in IPA institutes. I strongly advocate making the academic approach an additional requirement if we are proposing to open up and allow making radical changes to the way we understand psychoanalysis. This approach will gain the attention and inquisitiveness of a new generation of analysts, more than the mere repetition of the old terminology and vocabulary of psychoanalysis as if they are a theory of psychoanalysis.

The most compelling argument regarding making a ‘radical’ shift in the direction psychoanalysis has to take now, or close to now, is the stubbornness of the IPA, as the custodian of psychoanalysis, to acknowledge that the dropping of numbers of its membership is not because of a drop in the interest in psychoanalysis among young mental health professionals, or a general dwindling of interest in psychoanalysis in society, but because of the quality of psychoanalysis it is advocating and offering in its training institutes. It is pretty archaic and inadequate. The IPA has forgotten, and maybe ignores that originally and for six- or seven-decades candidates were seeking IPA’s membership everywhere in the world because it was the best and the only place to learn and train in psychoanalysis. The beginning of the IPA was founded on the birth of psychoanalysis; its continuation paralleled the changes and improvement Freud and the early analysts in psychoanalysis kept generating. Psychoanalysis was a novelty worth the membership of the IPA, and its membership meant that the member masters the knowledge and technique of that “fascinating” new understanding of human psyche. Today, any IPA member, whatever his level of mastering the theory or the art of its practice, would not have anything new or meaningful to say something new to a colleague. Even a lay educated person knows about psychoanalysis as much as the trained analyst. Only thinkers and phosphorus seem to know more and better that the best training analysts.

It was psychoanalysis that created and sustained the IPA not the other way around, as the IPA custodians still insist. I am quite aware of how difficult for the remainder of my generation of analysts to accept that what they learned and trained few decades ago in is no longer viable. I am also quite cognizant of the difficulty of engaging the new generation in a process of originating and establishing another psychoanalysis that fits their age. However, time and psychoanalytic experience make me firmly believe that psychoanalysis, the theory of us humans, will find the means for its continuation despite the IPA’s effort to make the past continue in the present and stay for the future. It happened before and will happen again.

A Very V. Brief Account of the Evolution of Psychoanalysis.

Freud’s psychoanalysis went through three or four stages (revisions) in its development during his own life.  After graduating from medicine he spent several years searching for some field of interest to make it his professional future. His experience in psychiatry with Meynert and his relationships with Breuer got him away from his undirected endeavours in the field of neurological research and got him in touch with psychoneurotic patients. However, his short encounter with Charcot and Bernheim had taken him by surprise because he never hesitated after that in what he wanted to do. His first insight about the wish came when he rejected that what is wrong with patients is not a ‘happening’ but something to understand. The evidence to that awareness is what he stated in Studies on Hysteria that patients suffer from reminiscences (things that happened to them in the past and when retrieved they make sense of their sufferings). The radical shift was making the disease and the patient one entity instead what was tried before to find a cause outside the psychical life of the patient. The patient became a human who has a psychical life which has entities to be analyzed (in Medicine the disease is external or a separate entity of dysfunctionality of an internal organ).

He extended his explorations of the newly discovered psychical entity to the world of dreams, which was not logical but an intuitive shift of focus. His view was that dreams do not happen to the person, but he makes them. There he states the foundation of all his work till 1939, and hopefully our work too. He says: “We see that the psychical mechanism employed by the neuroses is not created through there having been first a morbid disturbance affecting the mind, but is already present in the normal structure of the mental apparatus. The two psychical systems, the transitional censorship between them, the way in which one activity inhibits and becomes super imposed on the other show us one of the ways leading to knowledge of that structure”. (Cited in E. Jones, Vl. I, p. 297). What followed this insight was the Dream Book, then Psychopathology of Everyday Life, followed by the Book on Jokes and The Three Contributions to Theory of Sex. We could realize that Freud’s foundational insights were unconscious conceptions, vaguely mentioned before they took their verbal form and became functional concepts, i.e., become operational and working hypotheses.

For a first time the human subject was looked at as something that has meaning, and the meaning is implicit in his psyche, and could be sorted out by analyzing it. The riddle of the sphinx was solved [ Who walks on four, then on two and ends up walking on three. [The human person].

Freud’s intuition proved that the unconscious aspect of an intuition remains unconsciously active even after it mainly gets a verbal conscious format. He was unconscious that he has brought down the wall that kept the human subject a riddle till he saw the meaning of the human phenomena dormant within itself (the meaning of the dream is dormant in its visual scene and expresses ‘the dreamer’s personal wish). We laugh at jokes because the irony in them says something we refrained from acknowledging and verbalizing. A slip of the togue is not a happening, but a process in the mind of the person that he is not conscious of. As obvious as it is now it was noticed and ‘unconsciously’ understood by many before Freud. But he revealed it as a product of a psychical mechanism. Freud looked at dreams, parapraxis, symptoms, and other human manifestations as psychical mechanisms. Because he previously-in the phase of hypnosis- encountered regression and preconscious guilt especially in regard to sexuality he identified those mechanisms as defense mechanisms (Vol. III of the SE). The first phase in the history of psychoanalysis was spent by Freud and his disciples identifying and explicating the psychical mechanisms that created the symptoms. Thus, the wish was the first step toward the subject as the subject-matter of psychoanalysis.

The second phase in the history of psychoanalysis came when Freud revised the role of sexuality in the psychical life of the patient. Sexuality was the most prominent issue in early psychopathology and was considered the main cause of psychoneuroses. However, when Freud’s clinical practice expanded (SE Vol. nine and ten) to included other psychoneuroses than hysteria, he noticed that it is the psychoneuroses that distorts the patients’ sexuality and talked about other defense mechanisms that are not as the simplistic repression. His Three Contributions to the theory of Sexuality underlined that sexuality exists in the human subject since childhood, that it is not an instinct or a simple urge, but a Trieb (a complex integration of several bodily areas in reacting to their stimulations and are shaped by the subject’s own experiences through his childhood development. The most radical and shifting result of Freud’s analysis of sexuality was that sexuality is not the cause of psychoneuroses, but it is one of the main targets of the neurosis. Sexuality gets sick and does not cause sickness.

A third phase started when Freud shifted his attention from “mechanisms” and “things psychological” to psychical processes. In that period of expansion, change and new horizon for psychoanalysis, Freud became aware that what is unconscious is not so because some defense mechanism but because the unconscious is a psychical entity that has its own nature, which differentiates it from the conscious and cognitive functions. The unconscious is a distinct state in psychical life that it has a different system of functioning. Although his work on that subject (1905) was interesting particularly at that time, it revealed a new insight about the psyche and the development of psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysts (Freud and his colleagues) realized that they should not be distracted and deceived by the logical links between causes and effects, but they have to be aware that the unconsciousness is more than ‘just not being conscious’.

Between 1912 and 1920 Freud published two sets of papers that marked the period as the most inspiring and important in the history of psychoanalysis. The first is the papers on technique, the second is called the metapsychological papers. Those papers are seldom mentioned anymore, and my recent limited inquiry in a very small number of institutes shows that very rarely do the curricula of the institutes give them the deserved attention. The two sets of papers should be recognized as products of genuine and significant evolution in the history of psychoanalysis. The papers on technique put us face to face with the process of analyzing and the issues that emerge in the “office” not just in our minds. The second group called metapsychological dealt with the dual nature of psychical phenomena like repression, narcissism, and the changes to psychical due to fixations and maturation. The primary and the secondary of the same phenomenon revealed the significance of anxiety as a reaction to conflict and the existence of latent psychodynamics.

 Freud’s paper on the unconscious (1915) is quite intriguing. For none academic psychoanalysts it means very little. The clinical and theoretical implications of the three types of unconsciousness Freud that mentioned in the paper do not seem to foretell- in a clear way- what major changes in psychoanalysis could be predicted from the impact of that explication of unconsciousness. We will see, when we get to the protocol of practicing psychoanalysis that the tripartite meaning of the unconscious, especially the systemic unconscious, was actually the core of understanding the phenomenon of Transference. This might sound to the trained analyst to practice excessive theoretical sophistication. Yet, I did not find in the regular literature on the subject of transference mush dealing with the inevitability of a degree of unconscious transference in any relationship, healthy and unhealthy. The clinical trio of neutrality, anonymity, and abstinence has to be strictly observed so the analyst’s engagement in the process of analysis is limited to allow it to be more transferential than actual.  

 A forth phase-started quietly and slowly after 1923 (The Ego and the Id)- in which Freud did not come up with anything genuinely new, except his work “Inhibition, Symptoms, and Anxiety” (1926). Freuds slowed down in discovering new psychoanalytic finds and worked on consolidating his findings and some of his disciples’ insights. That forth stage had and still has a detrimental effect on the evolution of psychoanalysis. We, second and third generations of psychoanalysts, assimilated Freud’s endeavor to stabilize psychoanalysis and just kept polishing what is achieved till now. There are two negative results to that stand, which are behind the present deterioration of psychoanalysis as it is adopted by the IPA. The first is to stop at where Freud and ‘Freudians’ have reached and keep recycling what they have achieved. Recycling of anything deteriorates the original substance of the recycled. That is what happened with ego psychology, object-relations (the second phase of the Defense Mechanisms), and the almost total abolition of the ideas regarding the unconscious. The second, is when the core of the psychoanalytic insights is neglected it has to be compensated for or denied completely. This is what happened with the period of the new schools that was followed-after their failure- to compensate for the lost insights by preserving the institutions instead.  

Good deeds never get lost, and psychoanalysis will come back but with different psychoanalysts.

Tuesday, 6 April 2021

 

The Third major insight is the existence of primary and the secondary states of affaire in every aspect of our psychological life. The paper On Narcissism (1913) was almost an obituary of the libido theory, and the formation of a need for either a new ‘dynamo’ for functional explanations of psychological life, or new conception of psychological life that could be explained neither by the libido theory nor anything external to the psychological phenomenon itself. Freud went back to the concept of Trieb which the libido idea emerged from (The Three Essays on Sexuality 1905) and to the concept of Repression; his first psychoanalytic concept. Those two concepts got two major shifts, in his thinking in his Papers on Metapsychology (1915). His dormant intuition made him rediscover that “…  ‘an instinct’ appears to us as a concept on the frontier between the mental and the somatic, as the psychical representative of the stimulus originating from within the organism an reaching the mind …”. He also distinguishing between two phases in repression: primal repression which “consists in the psychical(ideational)representative of the instinct being denied entrance into consciousness. Then comes repression proper, when primary repression seems to be failing in keeping the instinctual out of consciousness” (1915, 148). Freud’s third intuition-like his foundational intuition of the psychical representing the subject- did not catch the attention of psychoanalysts because they did not have an obvious or direct impact on clinical work, though, anything ‘psychological’ is a transformation of something somatic or mental. Therefore, the intuition that there are primary and secondary operation behind whatever we deal with as psychoanalysts (regardless of our specialty) is essential in our understanding of “analyzation”. We should not be searching for something unconscious about the patient that is not in his free association; find the unconscious in the patient’s conscious speech. I have to interrupt here to make a point: it is not important if Freud recognized fully or consciously the extent of his intuitions. It is our duty to bring out of his intuitions what we could and might be able to develop and advance our specialty. It is a duty to keep advancing psychoanalysis and avoid being fixated on something old. Freud’s greatness is exactly this.

The duality of repression’s make-up is very significant and instrumental in giving the unconscious the qualifications for its existence. Th duality of repression suggests that there must be a quantitative or qualitative gap between them. That gap is as part of human’s nature, because without it there would not be a psychical life. A wave of rage has to be primarily repressed and to be turned into psychical or mental representation of that rage. The facility of representation is what turns the urge to respond into a wish to react to the repressed rage. Thus, the rage could be properly repressed. The gap in the duality of repression is either the facilitator of the birth of psychological life, or the manifestation of psychological life. We do not differ in our somatic needs, but we differ in what wishes those needs generate. Our specific need could be shared by others but its transformation into wish is quite difficult to be exact like another person’s. Our differences start with our wishes, the unconscious condition of its repression, or finding the proper language to express it. The unconscious is a constant and inherent part of psychical life because there is a continuous process of repressing urges into wishes and generating gaps between the conscious and the repressed, i.e., the unconscious.

The forth major insight is the duality of human subject; heis a dual being, i.e., everything the subject is, is a duality. Dealing with this attribute of the human subject requires keeping in mind that although psychoanalysis is a human science it is very unique in a subtle way: Psychoanalysis studies the human subject directly through his personal attributes, while other humanities study the subject via his manifestations, like social institutions, politics, morality, religion, his reactions to new technology, etc. Psychoanalysis educes the subject from his condition, while the rest of the humanities deduce the subject from his social displays. Better, while the subject in the humanities is a unit in a social act, like marriage for instance, the subject’s marriage in psychoanalysis is sort of a ‘text’ about him. It tells things about him. This distinction makes us confront something about the psyche that psychoanalysis, or Freud’s forth insight, introduced to the world of the humanities. P. Ricoeur (1970.p475) said: “A reader familiar with Hegelian [dialectical philosophy] cannot help but notice the constant use of opposition in the structure of Freud’s concepts [which are consistently dichotomous] …it is true that dichotomy is not necessarily a dialectic, and that each dichotomy has a different sense. But his [Freud]style of opposition is ultimately involved in the birth of meaning; his dichotomy is already dialectical”. Freud, intuited that whatever we try to understand about the subject, deductively or inductively, imposes on us to put it in the context of a duality. In my last publication I stipulated several dualities as part of our psychological inheritance. I will mention here three:  I-Me, consciousness- unconscious, and manifest and latent. The subject is ‘his’ self and also an object to himself. When he speaks, he uses the pronoun of the first person, I; but when he speaks about himself, which he could and does all the time, he uses the objective pronoun Me.  He can be his-self and an object to himself. We can not be able to understand ‘sadism’ without mentioning (thinking of) masochism, because if we do not, we will confuse sadism with simple aggression. Even consciousness has to be defined by contrasting it with unconsciousness, so it would not mean awareness or cognition. We never deal with any message that comes to us from our external world-even our internal world too- that we do not give it our own twist of meaning. We are constantly trying to find, create, improve our conception\perception. So, we live in a world that is conceive of as a duality of manifest issue and latent meaning. In general, Freud’s forth insight is giving the obvious of ourselves the not so obvious meaning. 

Freud’s insight about the duality of the subject-with all its implications-is still a feature that is rarely noticed, and less so, in its importance in the practice of psychoanalysis (clinical and none clinical). The next and last part of this post will be dedicated to convincing the current retiring psychoanalysts that it is more sensible to give a chance to a new psychoanalysis that comes from the academic style of thinking. This call will show that we need to revive the intuitions that gave birth to psychoanalysis, and to only reveal its latent and neglected attributes that were fundamental in the past. It is illogical that an ideology of the subject that was largely very successful for 80-90 years to vanish-or deteriorate that badly, without leaving behind the seeds of a new one. This is our test: to replace contemporary psychoanalysis with a better and new one that comes out of it, but through academic thinking. We-the old generations analysts- have to refuse accepting current psychoanalysis, because it is already dead, not just in clinical practice and IPA experience but as a viable theory of many human characteristic. We are not able -since the time of the schools- to revive it. Something else has to be taken care of the new generation of seekers of learning and training have to understand that the easy way to become psychoanalyst in the IPA system of learning and training would only lead to fakeness and frustration. Psychoanalysis is knowledge that is worthy of an academic program and full-time dedication.