Audience

Thursday, 30 September 2021

 

A responsibility we are supposed to carry:

In a second reading of Solms book it became clear to me that we psychoanalysts were or are not keen to advance our science or profession. We kept recycling old ideas and trying vainly to adjust and readjust some theoretical novelties, but we could only use the terminology that those the novelties introduced. The novel approach Solms has taken to study consciousness could actually lead to solving the issue of the unconscious and makes it clear. We need that because we should work on our difficulties, not leave it to others to solve for us. Just as sample: We know that the unconscious material comes in the forms of metonymy and metaphor, and what is unconscious is not a return of the repressed but a reformulation of what is conscious which happens outside the conscious mechanisms of expression. Solms is putting conscious in the core of our sense of being, thus the unconscious is related to the subject’s sense of being. My slip of the tongue or my transference say something ABOUT ME not hiding something of me. The conscious is only conscious relative to something unconscious (out of my sense of being) . Therefore, psychoanalysis is not making the unconscious conscious but making the subject own both of them as  his subjectivity. Missing a session does not have a meaning outside the patient’s recognition of himself in that missing. Analysis is analysis of the subject and not his expressed speech.

Monday, 27 September 2021

 

Analysis of the Subject and Analytic Material:

 

What ‘psychoanalyzing’ means is very important, yet it is neglected, and its literature is relatively not impressive. The immediate response to this query is that we analyze the patient’s free association with the assumption that ‘free’ associating reveals the unconscious. This basic assumption needs to be reviewed because created an attitude that we analyze the human subject in our patient when we actually try to get to the subject through his verbal and mental expressions and presentations. In other words, in effect we analyze the patient’s psychoanalytic material (association, memories, slips of the tongue, dreams, etc.) and not the subject himself. Then comes the question:  what else is the subject but his ‘psychoanalytic naterial’!!

A vignette might help:

A new female patient noticed that that that in coming up the elevator to her session there was a nice-looking woman who usually comes  down from my floor. She just mentioned that casually twice or three times. After few weeks she noticed that woman is not doing that anymore. In a casual way she mentioned that and made the comment that she must have finished her treatment. As she was familiar with the process she did not expect a response from me about her observations.

After a while she noticed the pretty woman coming down the elevator again. She made several remarks and did not get a response from me. The issue became a persistent issue in her analysis. As I was not responding to her disguised curiosity she expressed her thoughts that there must be some truth to her suspicion that there is something personal in the matter. After another period of agonizing curiosity about that woman and thoughts about jealousies she suffered from in different events in her life, I responded by saying that the presence of that woman in her association made her think and talk about aspects in her life that she did not tell me about before. She dropped silent for a while and then gave some confused memories about a childhood family situation in which her mother was unhappy and ended with her parents’ divorce.

Her parents’ divorce and the surrounding events was disclosed in my assessment interview and was not new material. My response to the repeated mentioning of that divorce was basically that there is some link between her thoughts regarding a personal relationship with that woman and the events that led to her parents’ divorce.  I followed that with saying that she is now talking about other people and not only her complaints. The outcome was a fundamental change[aF1]  though in a very subtle way. She was more expressive as a patient talking to her analysts than just ‘reporting’ things to him about herself., Put it another way: she became a living subject taking about a lived life; instead of a patient reporting a neurotic existence to her Shrink.

The idea is that in psychoanalysis we analyze the patient, i.e., the subject that appears to us in his associations. However, we should always consider that what we hear has to be interpretable to the subject who said them. In a different way, the subject has to relate what we interpreted to his own associations. Most of the time (in my experience) analysts depend on the way the theory of psychoanalysis understands the associations[aF2] . This kind of interpretation is not therapeutic interpretations because it misses the obvious fact that the patient is going to take it back to his own ‘theory’ of it.

If we remain on the level of interpreting the patient association we would not be doing psychoanalysis because we aim at restructuring the intrapsychic condition of the patient. We should be keeping that in mind when we do in interpreting because what we interpret has to be re-constructed. Therefore, the process of reconstruction has to be clear in the “consciousness’ of the subject. In other words, the associations are our windows to the nature of the subject’s intrapsychic structure.

This patient was not telling me what she thought of me as a professional; instead, she created a painful scene from her life that was not fully worked through. Transference is the return of the repressed but with the implicit meaning that it is in a ‘lived moment in the analysis. Analysis of the patient’s childhood experience is not the analysis of remembering it. Analyzing a remembered experience is very different from analyzing a transference event. Analyzing the patient’s memory, is not as analyzing the patient himself. Solms’s subject is a livening human event and not a representation of a subject.

 Interpretation as a Step Toward Reconstruction[aF3] :

The most important thing in our continuous questioning of psychoanalysis is missing the difference between A. Theory and Practice, B. Learning and training.

Theory and Practice:

Psychoanalysis began as a practice looking for a theory. This is the reason we are very much lost when it comes to the theory of psychoanalysis. I will dare we say it: We do not have a theory of psychoanalysis because we refrained from recognizing or realizing that “psychoanalyzing” is endeavored to discover the subject, and every subject is a theory in his own right. Thus, a theory of psychoanalysis should be a theory of the subject (See Solms). The practice of psychoanalysis is a different issue: it is the way we listen to patients giving us a picture of their intrapsychic dynamics and the way make them have a look on the way they are psychological structured with some help from us to add to their effort to change themselves. This is the work on -interpretation-reconstruction (base on the discovered subject). 

 

Learning and training is more of a political issue than I naively though thout at the beginning. So!!!!!!!


 [aF1]

 [aF2]

 [aF3]

Tuesday, 14 September 2021

 

The Next Step Before the Last.

I was intending to write a post on the narcissistic base of patriotism. The main notion is that we naturally react negatively to all kinds of narcissism. With narcissistic patriotism we seldom react so negatively, as if patriotism regarding one’s country is natural and unquestionable. However, narcissism it the core of any identification of which nationality is a prominent one. There are some aspects in identification that could go astray when the subject of the identification is badly chosen. Psychoanalysis could initiate that kind of stupid narcissism that stupid patriotism could also create.

Reading Mark Solms’s last book “THE HIDDEN SPRING” made me change my mind. I went [aF1]  back to an old disliked if not even hated subject: “Is old or even currant psychoanalysis still useful!!!!

Solms’s thesis takes us to a new start for the understanding[aF2]  of the Freudian thesis; no wonder he was dedicated to revising the English (official) translation of “The Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud”, which is due to appear this year. Although this is a separate issue it raises many points: do we know what to do to update our theory! Do we think that Freud’s text is a ‘passee’ issue and we should not be rereading it but concentrate on the more recent works of the new generations of analysts instead? Is it a better translation of Freud’s able to change anything regarding our present attempts at modernizing psychoanalysis?

First, Solms’s book is a very serious attempt at creating a new psychoanalysis. It is based on recent findings regarding neuropsychology which astonishingly corroborates Feud’s first publication (The Project, 1895). Solms’s neurological discovery and integrating it in the whole context of Freud’s Text with the notion of giving the Freudian text its veritable meaning. He is changing  the idea that we have one psychoanalysis and that it is  the present psychoanalytic situation.

I think there are[aF3]  an elephant and two monkeys in the room: Solm’s new translation and what was behind that request. After almost seven decades, of The Standard Edition: do we need verification and explanation of psychoanalysis? The monkeys are: what is missing or flawed in psychoanalysis as it is thought of now[aF4]  and required revising? The second monkey is: are we really going to reread Freud to qualify as psychoanalysts[aF5] ?

It is useful to make a distinction between the SE. as the source of the psychoanalytic vocabulary and as the psychoanalytic grammar.  Something we should underline; although the SE remained the undeniable index of Freud’s work and translation, the European translations of the body or the works of Freud corrected the foundational mistakes in the English Edition. I will get to that later but for now I want to address this issue: what we have been practicing till now in the English-Speaking world was not totally the real Freudian psychoanalysis. Most the established analysts will reject this idea vehemently, however, there are very important woks about this point in English (Laplanche, Bettelheim, which brought to the attention of the “Anglo” analysts the distortions in the SE.

 The notions I will mention (to follow) will be just unmasking the second monkey in the room. Psychoanalysis is psychoanalysis as a verb and not nouns or adjectives. As an example: dealing with Trieb as a thing (instinct). and not as a pressure put on the mind to make the subject act turns psychoanalysis into a theory of functions not an act of analyzing structure. The evolution of Freud’s work attest to the progressing unmasking of the human subject.

If all that is gibberish have the freedom to say I like psychoanalysis as is or I will go to a new notion of psychoanalyzing.


 [aF1]E

 [aF2]

 [aF3]

 [aF4]That

 [aF5]ost