Audience

Sunday, 10 February 2019




2. The Crisis: Is it Psychoanalysis or the IPA:

Writing this post was a response to the IPA’s dealing with the crisis of the declining interest in psychoanalysis. The IPA offers solutions-like encouraging research-without looking for the causes of its fading relevance. I believe that the problem is with the psychoanalysis offered in the IPA’s training institutes. Increasing the membership to IPA-if it will ever happen- is not a measure or indication of gaining strength. The strength of psychoanalysis, which should be evident in the teachings and training in the IPA's institutes, is the measure of its usefulness as an international association. Better, instead of making psychoanalysis more appealing try making it more convincing as a science and a practice.

Resorting to some arguable measures of training to make psychoanalysis appeal to more candidates, as is the trend in some psychoanalytic circles will harm psychoanalysis more, or at least-will change its particular quality as a specific psychotherapy. This trend is responsible for allowing the improvisation of schools of psychoanalysis and for some analysts to revise basics analytic premises without enough scrutinization. The point to make is that if we-psychoanalysts- are members of an International organization- we should have a system to allow and disallow certain changes to psychoanalysis. Even though it is healthy that analysts consider making changes to psychoanalysis to advance it, the current changes to psychoanalysis do not have any convincing evidence that they are done to improve psychoanalysis or take it a step forward in its natural course of evolution. The IPA is supposed to be the insitution that should organize and provide an international agreed-upon standard from of uncontrollable changes to psychoanalysis. It is not right that under the provisions of the IPA there is learning and training in some societies and institutes of theories that contradict-openly and blatantly- the basic premises of “traditional” psychoanalysis.
The present situation in psychoanalysis reflects a state of chaos that has already made the future of psychanalysis untenable.  Firstly, we have a gap between psychoanalysis on this side of the Atlantic and the other side.  Psychoanalysis is comfortably established there as an academic subject. The IPA institutes seems to all be still adhering to traditional psychoanalysis. There is no noticeable conflict between the two systems. On this side of the ocean we had a dozen “schools” of psychoanalysis since Kohut initiated self-analysis. The birth and death of those schools does not follow any comprehensible theoretical line. The basis of one of the present popular schools is founded on almost a psychoanalytic rumor that one cannot hid his- self.  Psychoanalysis is not a political issue where people are free to follow their own preferences or their choices: we are professionals who provide an identified health service to people (and get paid for it), therefore we have to either agree on what we do or do not claim that we are all the same.
The IPA assumed and still presumably act as an international professional body of psychoanalysts who work to promote the right kind of psychoanalysis.  We have no idea of what is happening in the different, diverse, and theoretically confusing conditions of learning and training in the IPA institutes. It is understandable that monitoring training is left to the regional and local societies. However, maintaining the hundred years notion of the function of the IPA is misleading, and causing unnecessary distraction from the solution: If you cannot do it let that who could do it instead.
My argument is with analysts who should dispel the myth of the IPA, but do not want to lose the sense of distinction that comes with it. 
I should give up hope to convince the 12,000 analysts that they are better off with strong university programs adopting psychoanalysis. But, as a Chinese proverb says: not the last blow that splits the rock, all the blows that precede make that possible.

Sunday, 3 February 2019




The Crisis: Is it Psychoanalysis or the IPA:
It is very important for this post to be put in its proper context for me to say that the psychoanalysis I am talking about here is that which the IPA claims to be the original classical one that it was entrusted, over a century ago, to promote and preserve. Psychoanalysis exists and thrives in some academic centers in many parts of the world. Yet, the IPA claims an original authoritative  legitimacy that stands as an obstacle in making psychoanalysis something more than the psychotherapy it imparts in its training institutes, producing a vague sort of a profession. 
Of late, it is noticeable that there are obvious concerns in the IPA community about the declining status and appeal of psychoanalysis. Just to show the nature of that concern I quote an exchange between two responsible and senior analysts about that matter. The first says: “…. North America had the fewest number of psychoanalytic candidates in training among the IPA’s regions, I have been thinking about ways in which the IPA could help …. to increase that number”. The other analyst commented by saying: “Institutes around the country, . . . have found that efforts put into the promotion of diversities can have multiple benefits, including an increase in the number of candidates (my emphasis) and clinical opportunities for them”. Most the discussions about the present predicament of psychoanalysis comes to the same point: the number of candidates in the IPA institutes. Worse, there is no mention in the rest of the exchange, and the ongoing discussions,  of the possible causes of that phenomenon or the benefits of increasing the number of candidates (since there is agreement on the declining number of patients seeking psychoanalysis for treatment).
Does the crisis we are facing pertain to something happening to the IPA and its membership, or pertains to something with psychoanalysis it advocates that makes it lose its status? Because I believe that the lack of interest in psychoanalysis shows only when we look at the IPA and its institutes. I wanted to underline two basic ideas: not all the psychoanalyses offered outside the IPA institutes are psychoanalysis, and that not all the psychoanalyses offered in the IPA institutes are psychoanalysis especially those that are offered under the guise of “a School”.
It was difficult to get any official or unofficial information from the IPA on the condition of psychoanalysis and training in the different parts of the world. Because of that difficulty I tried to get information directly about the from 11 different societies in Europe and South America. Not one was able to say that things are OK, four admitted having difficulties, the rest did not even go that far to disclose any information. In 1975 I asked casually about the number of analysts in the USA. I was given an unofficial figure that was close to the total number of analysts in world now. Only lately we got some statistics about the membership and the candidates in training from the IPA. Therefore, it is only logical to say that the crisis now is a crisis of the IPA, because of the dwindling number of memberships threatens its existence. However, I mentioned before that the relationship between psychoanalysis and the IPA is bad for both, because psychoanalysis is a theory that should not have organizational restrictions put on its progress, advancement, and reaching for farther horizons, which requires continued modifications in the system of learning and training. Even though IPA is supposedly an only membership organization, it still maintains and continues the early function of ‘psychoanalytic education and training’. This function was given to it due to certain circumstances related to the early initiation of psychoanalysis, which do not exist anymore. It is not proper or useful for the IPA to continue doing that, which is now interferes with its fundamental and its natural function of protecting psychoanalysis from deviating, deteriorating, stagnating, and dying. The IPA is not supposed to be both the teacher and the overseer of education. In another way of putting it, the training institutes of psychoanalysis are run by the IPA which is supposed to investigate, cheque, evaluate, and certify the quality of their learning\training programs. This is a violation of the most obvious rule of credibility.
My post is not about the credibility of training in the IPA institutes or the IPA’s latest attempts at reviving psychoanalysis. I want to bring to attention the role the IPA is playing in the deterioration of psychoanalysis and taking it to the verge of disappearing. We all know that there is no serios principle of checking the proficiency of any IPA training institute. This is logical and right because we have no clear system of teaching psychoanalysis and no criteria for assessing training. This is the case under the present conditions of training in IPA institutes, because of a very subtle but plainly missed reason. We might have a structure for training (the tripartite components of seminars, personal analysis, and supervision) but we have no uniformal functional definitions of those components.  If by horrific effort we could agree on a curriculum (a) for the seminars will not be able to do that with the other two legs of the stool.
 The IPA is concerned about its future as an ‘organization’ not about psychoanalysis as its professional reference. However, because the IPA assumes a major role in the formation -training- of the psychoanalysts and could also wield the power of accrediting training and granting membership, it becomes the tail that wags the dog. There is an inherent structure in the IPA of a hierarchy of positions and functions which come with some privileged statuses. It is an attractive and corrupting residual of the early days of the IPA. It still seeps down to the regional and local societies creating a self-destructive union between training and membership. The concerns of the IPA and the local societies about membership and recruitment shows in bursts of energy-every now and then- to vitalize the interest in psychoanalysis which are, in fact, concerns about the IPA and its future. For the last forty years psychoanalysis was distorted, infused with strange if not weird ideas, and is left to eventually will not exist. I mean that there wil come a time when we should not worry about psychoanalysis because it will not exist anymore.   

The Uselessness and Usefulness of the IPA:
The IPA served its purpose of protecting and growing the psychoanalytic movement for almost half a century. It established its prototype in all the culturally advances societies. It even found its way to the USA and managed to navigate its way in the turbulence of ‘the medical vs. none medical’. Duplicating its training institutes everywhere it existed does not need any comment. The IPA was with no doubt Freud’s smart idea. However, the fast success of the analytic movement tempted most members to assume the attitude of the different, the special, and the better, which isolated them from the professional base they came from. This trend had to backfire at some point, causing an unhealthy gulf within the wider circle of mental heath providers; we still hear its echoes. It also attracted quite a number of ambitious young professionals who were seeking status more than learning psychoanalysis. The membership of the IPA became aa it still- to an extent- a fringe benefit.
Because psychoanalysis is knowledge and experience it went on changing from merely a psychotherapeutic method to become a science of the human subject. Those changes started with discovering more details about the psychodynamics of the intrapsychic and its origins in childhood. It was also found out that the newly discovered intrapsychic dynamics show in the normal and natural expressions and manifestations of character formation and in interpersonal relationships. The range of psychoanalysis, both theoretically and involvement kept widening, and it was not possible to fit it anymore in the old training institutes of the IPA. Analysis requires a different setting to extends its reach. If not, it will disintegrate into schools, as mentioned above. Psychoanalysis has to become an academic program. This is happening now in many reputable academic set ups but the full power of this movement is hindered by the continued existence if the IPA institutes of training. The situation is like keeping the apprentice system of training physicians along with modern academic medicine.  
 What will happen if analysts failed, willed, worked on the demise of the IPA? Would psychoanalysis suffer from that or benefit? The answer with confidence will thrive and very likely will enter a new golden age. There is no place in the world that does not have some psychoanalytic activity. In those places or near by, a psychoanalytic establishment in the form of a university program or and academic intuition exists; next to the IPA organization if there is a psychoanalytic society in the vicinity. Thus, analysis will not disappear and the old belief that the IPA is the only “legitimate” base of psychoanalysis will eventually lose its credibility. However, this movement to change  has to be organized  to avoid some drawbacks of replacing the old with the new  without preparation. Bottom line, they cannot and should not coexist.

Thursday, 31 January 2019

Self deception

I usually do not get much response to my postings on my blog. What I get is rarely approving or approving with reservations. Lately, especially for the last two posts, the responses were more than usual. However, I noticed that they were all-with the exception of three- were very much against 'bad news'. I also noticed that the IPA is lately spreading all sorts of 'good news'. Whoever is right or wrong about the present condition of psychoanalysis should not endeavour to create false atmospheres of optimism or pessimism.There should not be self deceptions in that regard [lowering the standards of any of the criteria of being psychoanalyst and claim that things are just wonderful ]. We should face facts and let them  create our feelings; not let manufactured atmospheres create our phantasmic realities based on what we feel (wish).    

Friday, 25 January 2019





The Disintegration of Psychoanalysis and the Schools:
The theory of the Survival of the Fittest awakened the human race to the fact of evolution and kept developing and advancing to what it became now: possible to edit genes. Psychoanalysis also came to awaken the human race to acknowledge the existence of a psychical core behind what is displayed of the human subject. Since Freud said: “Hysterics suffer mainly from reminiscences (1893-1895)” he kept developing and advancing his theory of catharses to his last theory of the intrapsychical structure of three agencies that are different in function but similar in structure (Ucs., Cs., Pcs.). This is the natural way for any substantive theory to survive: the original theoretical issue (evolution-intrapsychical, etc.) remains, to be developed and unfolded by new generations of scientists.
For several decades this feature in the psychoanalytic theory was well maintained, by Freud in particular, who kept advancing it in the same direction toward a better conception of the intrapsychical dynamics. The controversies in England- after Freud’s death- advanced the theory intact: the intrapsychical remained the subject matter of the issues that were in debate. The difference between “identification” and “introjection” did not make Anna Freud and Melanie Klein heads of two different schools of psychoanalysis. Putting the intrapsychical in the context of the early child-parent relationship was not new to psychoanalysis, but they highlighted serval processes that could explain matters in the intrapsychical that were not considered before. But then they were considered from the unconscious angle. The Kleinians were more insightful in showing that aspect of the intrapsychic. Glover and Bion were not contradicting each other; they were concerned with two aspects of the same theory. In France, the splits were not creating new “psychoanalyses”, they were all pertaining to issues related to the “subject” of psychoanalysis and its basics propositions (early Lacan was more concerned about the human subject than the early traditional French psychoanalysis). The differentiations between Klein and Anna Freud, and between Lagache and Nachte did not announce a birth of schools of psychoanalysis, but two approaches regarding the same subject.  In Europe-as far as I knew- the conflicts and disagreements within the psychoanalytic community where about the subject matter of psychoanalysis and not about psychoanalysis itself as a theory of the subject. Therefore, the issue of the “schools” did not exist and still does not exits, because the original theory is preserved and still prevails.
In the USA the situation was different. Ego psychology was the most agreeable theory to a medically oriented psychoanalysis. The attention was concentrated on turning the subject matter of psychoanalysis into a quasi-nomothetic issue that has the flavour of something that could get sick and could be cured. Hartmann reified the Ego to almost embalming it. The ego became the reification of a subject and stood for him but without any features of psychological life. Psychoanalysis was not, anymore, the growing theory of the intrapsychical, but a theory of some entity called Ego. Naturally, psychoanalysts had to find a way out of that dead end. The most intriguing thing in that matter is concentrating their efforts on finding a substitute to the embalmed ‘ego’ and not the loss of the dynamics of the psychical processes. Kohut came up with the concept of self as a substitute for ego. It bred few more concepts but got stuck in what could bridge to gap between the self and the self-object [the other!!]. Empathy! How could we train someone to be empathic and what would happen after the termination of analysis with an empathic analyst? Is cure an improvement in the subject’s empathetic potential!
Yet, no doubt self-psychology gave a jolt to ego psychology and started a movement. The movement was rejecting the subject as the psychoanalytic issue and wanted the relational aspect to be the issue (analysis of relations not subjects). In a discussion with a relationist colleague (few years ago) he was not able to make up his mind: am I--as the analyst- work to treat the patient so he would improve his relationships with other or treat his relationships so he would not be neurotic?
This is when psychoanalysis in the US started to disintegrate in a specific manner. The first change was freeing the ego from its reified nature to become a relational object. The critiques of analysis (like R. Holt) and the announcement of a new psychoanalytic paradigm were calling for the reinvention of psychoanalysis in a relational format. Wallerstein (1988, 1998, 2005) was expressing the anxiety of the classical traditional analysts in regard to the disintegration of psychoanalysis, manifested in the rash of schools or what he called later ‘plurality’. I am characterizing it as disintegration because “relational psychology” permits and even condones plurality, i.e. breaking the unitary theory of psychoanalysis into several different theories and leaving it without a theory is disintegration.
It makes a difference if the IPA- as the institution in charge of training- has the function and responsibility of unifying training and learning psychoanalysis in its vast number of training institutes, all over the world. However, it goes without saying that it is not advisable that such a function be given to an organization of membership. Therefore, we should ask: is the ongoing model of learning and training in the IPA capable of securing and guaranteeing that all analysts are getting the same training in psychoanalysis and all are qualified to be called psychoanalysts. The answer is definitely no: it hasn’t been, it is practically impossible to be (though it should) and with eruption of schools of psychoanalysis it would be ridiculous to expect something of the sort. No training organization the size of the IPA could monitor all its training centers. Moreover, the divergent theoretical claims in different parts of the world makes it logically impossible certifying all the members as psychoanalysts unless we admit that that certification has no professional weight. Therefore, why are we still insisting on maintaining the IPA: it is has no input in training, has no professional significance, and has a confusing type of existing. No Respectable Profession Anywhere has our system of organization. The IPA has no function of any convincing way; moreover, it has a distinct harmful impact. It is giving legitimacy to illegitimate distortions of psychoanalysis. We will get to that next.
The position we are taking from the IPA remind me of a joke:
 A narcissistic masochist was frustrated because he cannot find someone to torture and humiliate him. Talking to himself begging for that sadistic person he came to a mirror and continued begging. His reflection  looked back with a certain smile and said no.

Saturday, 19 January 2019


Freud: An Unwilling Structuralist:

Reviewers of history endeavour to show that historical events are determined by factors that when exposed put the events in a better perspective and reveal new implicit aspects significance. I intend to do something of that sort with a brief account of the Freudian theory of psychoanalysis. Freud’s strive to get a comprehensive theory of psychoanalysis has never succeeded. The reason- surprisingly-is his genius.  He was looking for a functional theory, which would have been a theory of cause\effect format. This is the nature of theoretical formulations in Nomothetic sciences because dealing with the physical world permits confining observations within causative relations. Functional theories were the only perspective of scientific endeavours in Freud’s time. There was no clear concept of human sciences as a different set of sciences, or that their theories would be different from the causative format.

It was not until the thirties of last century when structuralism began to take shape and get identified. Human phenomena emerged (the first one in that regard was language) as a different type phenomenon that necessitated different type of theories. De Saussure- a linguist (1906)- made a distinction between speech and language in which language was the underlying structure of the varied speeches, thus set up the varied rules of each speech. The human sciences were born as distinct sciences. Thinkers realized that human phenomena were not amenable to simplistic cause\effect explanation, because they are formed of interconnected complex parts and aspects that require to be interpreted not explained. Marriage, for insurance, is a complex social phenomenon that exists in all human society but has varied and different essential rules. Yet, with all those variations it serves one purpose: encoding incestuous prohibitions.

Every time Freud seemed to have reached a functional explanation of a phenomenon (like dreams), his genius did not let him get away with it. His theory of wish fulfillment in dreams gave him the insight about the working of the primary processes in the formation of dreams, which led him to reveal the secrets of Parapraxes and Jokes (two subsequent works). So, the wish fulfillment discovery was pushed aside and the primary processes- or an unconscious processes- became what was behind the structuring of psychological phenomena (the unconscious that was stipulated in the three early books did not have a content like sex). Something more important transpired from that change in direction. The theory of psychopathology was at that point still based on sexuality as the cause of symptoms, which were the effect of repressing it.  The five years between the Interpretation of Dreams and The Book on Jokes were spend in revising the aetiological theory of sexuality. He came up with the theory of infantile sexuality, and repression of sexuality was no longer the cause of the neuroses. On the contrary, infantile sexuality reversed the causal relationship between sexuality and the neuroses: psychoneuroses were causes of sexual difficulties and their repression.

In the humanities, the functional theories collapsed in the face of the structural nature of psychical phenomena. Psychical phenomena, natural and pathological, were structures that could be interpreted as manifestations of other dynamics.  The notion of drives behind psychological phenomena was not anymore acceptable because the contribution of ‘something unconscious’ in creating psychic phenomena obviated the notion of a direct connection between drive and reaction.  At that point Freud’s genius made him revive a concept that has mentioned in the Three Essays: TRIEB.  He identified it as a pressure put on the mind to respond to endosomatic pressure. The concept of Trieb removed any trace or confusion about the psychoanalytic concept of human phenomena: they are not the responses specific internal or external stimuli (Instinkt), but a response to the pressure put on the mind by those stimuli to act. Therefor, it is not accurate or correct to think functionally about human phenomena because they are always a structure created in the mind before being actualized. Since no two minds are alike, even no response is like a previous one because the concept of Trieb eliminated functionalism from psychoanalysis. The human subject has to change the pressure of a stimulus into a wish before responding to it.

Freeing himself from the narrow concepts of functionality and causality, Freud was able to reveal that psychical phenomena are made of dualities (sexual Trieb vs. ego Trieb, life and death, etc.). Without articulating this foundational insight or the contribution of any other known external input,  Freud wrote three papers (1915) called -wrongly-by Strachey “the metapsychological papers”. The three papers were on Repression, Trieb, and the Unconscious. He stipulated that our psychological life is structured as dualities and not entities. Repression is not a defence mechanism but two processes one deals with the preverbal and the other with the post verbal issues. He also added that unconsciousness is three states of dualities. The most important of those dualities is the duality of pre consciousness and unconsciousness, which is a systemic state in our thought processes and the function of the primary process.

In his search for the ultimate functional theory his genius made him discover several structural formulations of the psyche, which he called “metapsychologies”. Freud’s metapsychologies allowed talking about psychical processes and structures in qualitative and quantitative terms without turning those reprocess into entities. He said that if you could talk about a process from an economical, dynamic, and topographic terms then you are talking about it metpsychologically. In other terms: Freud (the closet structuralist) was aware that metapsychology could be distorted to become other functional theories.

The good example is his latest metapsychology of the tripartite agencies of ego id and superego. Once he established this tripartite model of the psyche, he immediately attached to it the first metapsychology of the conscious\ unconscious, and preconscious. Thus, it was not possible to use the agencies as entities because they differ based on their topographic state of functioning. Nevertheless, we still find   Hartmann and Rapaport ignore Freud explicit warning and build an ego psychology that had a detrimental and lasting effect on psychoanalysis, more so in the USA.
The result of misunderstanding, ignoring, or just the mirage of a functional theory of psychoanalysis has resulted in the kind of distortions that created its modern crisis. Exploring this point further would be a good way of ending this long posting. Therefore, I stop here and plan to visit the catastrophic theoretical condition of psychoanalysis. 

I have to emphasize that my views are product of the American field of psychoanalysis more than its condition in other parts of the world due to my limited contacts out of North America.

Monday, 14 January 2019


Addendum


I think I was misunderstood when I said that the IPA certifies us. I meant certifies us as psychoanalysts, because I know that IPA recognises and accepts to membership only the graduates of its accredited institutes. In Canada, one has to finish training successfully for the Training Committee to present him for election to the society. Getting elected is the only way to become member of the local society. This membership gets the new comer his membership in the IPA. Certification for the practice of psychoanalysis is an administrative issue and is based on the academic education of the practitioner, and if it meets the local and national standards of the mental health providers.
The reason I mention that distinction is that the surge of academic institutions that educate and train people in psychotherapy that is firmly based on psychoanalytic principles (mainly European) exceeded the standards of the IPA training system. Academia has more facilities, experience, potential, let alone the freedom to do what is necessary to bring their students the best of psychoanalysis and discard what is dated without the narcissistic adulation of everything ‘classical’. The IPA with its training system, concepts of what is psychoanalytic and what is not, lacks the cultural perspective of psychoanalysis. It only train in psychotherapy. It has a low level of tolerance to change. The academic expansion of psychoanalysis is inevitable and is enriching it. The coexistence of the IPA as an educational resource create harmful confusion.

Saturday, 12 January 2019




4. An Unhealthy Symbiosis
The crisis of psychoanalysis is intriguing: the IPA was the incubator that protected and strengthened psychoanalysis to survive, but it is now-inadvertently- causing its gradual demise. The reason for changing form the protector to the danger that threatens it is the analysts’ refusal to acknowledge that its function in Freud’s time is not what is expected of it now. 

Jones (1955, p 74), commenting on the early success of psychoanalysis said that it came with ‘sinister signs of growing tension between the adherents’, which made Freud think that the remedy is a wider organization not local societies that would eventually form an international organization. The IPA was then born. Although this move proved to work at that time, it left an indelible mark on the psychoanalytic organizations: growing from the top to bottom (the secret committee, the training analyst status, the centers of power in the local societies). Thus, a symbiotic link between psychoanalysis and its organization was established and with it something wrong happened without any attention paid to: instead of psychoanalysis giving the organization the justification to exist, the organization became the official authority and official representation of psychoanalysis. This reversed dependency affected psychoanalysis negatively. Psychoanalysis is knowledge that is living, evolving, and advancing while the organization is supposed follow that advancement and change to keep serving it. Instead, the organization of psychoanalysis has become the authority that decides all the issues of the community of psychoanalysts: training and practice, what is acceptable deviations from the standard the Freudian theory, accreditation of and certification. The result was changing the organization-IPA- from a membership organization of professionals into an educational training organization and licencing body of professionals.

The link between education (learning and training) and membership was beneficial at the beginning of the psychoanalytic movement. It contained the disruptive trends and even the individuals whose personal idiosyncrasies could have ended the movement early. It also adopted the developing and expanding theoretical aspects and improvised a system of to oversee learning and training. However, there should have been some awareness that the symbiotic relationship between the membership aspect and the educational aspect that were entwined in the structure of the IPA has to end when psychoanalysis reaches a level of stability and strength that allow each aspect to endure on its own. Maybe this was too much to expect early in the history of psychoanalysis when people were busy building to expect them to think of changes of that nature. Yet, it was obvious as early at that time that the entwined functions of education and membership was creating  damaging and unsustainable conditions within the movement. The continuation of the “sinister signs of tension between the members” proved that the symbiosis between analysis and its institution was detrimental.  It actually got worse; the tension between individual analysts- as was the case before the creation of the IPA- became wars between camps of leading figures in the movement.

Separating education from membership could have kept psychoanalysis, as the evolving knowledge, away from the political, hierarchical, personal and status revelries, and made membership an expression of devotion to the profession. That separation should have been regarded the wise thing to do at a future point, since it was too early to think of it before Freud’s passing. Now when we have the history of the movement spread in front of us, we ask: at what point this separation should have taken place? A reasonable point was at the time of the conflicts in Great Britain between the Kleinian and the A. Freudians (the controversies), and in France at the time of the splits of Nacht\ Lagacht then Lagacht\ Lacan. My vague and limited knowledge of the history of psychoanalysis in the US, before the late sixties, makes me think that the environment at the Menninger’s clinic could have made that separation successfully happen with less pain; if it was not for the dominance of the psychiatrists at the scene, who were also academics. At those points in the history of psychoanalysis the separation would have solved several problems then, and many of our current problems.

Those three points in the history of psychoanalysis are significantly indicative of what happens to demand change. They were points that came when psychoanalysis was turning the corner from a simplistic understanding of  Freud’s functional theorizing of the psyche to a more structural attitude toward more advanced psychoanalysis and newer understanding of the blind spots in Freud's theory.  Kleinian psychoanalysis was moving towards exploring the processes that structure the infant’s intrapsychic core, instead of the psychologies of defence mechanisms and adaptation which were simplistic expansion of ego psychology.  As I will discuss in the next section of this posting, analysts ‘revolted’ (sometimes unsuccessfully) against functional analytic theories because their analytic insights went further and beyond the last of Freud's insights. Psychoanalysis was evolving and gaining new perspective of the human subject. Missing this feature made the IPA miss the chance to understand the nature of the changes in psychoanalysis and the chance to change accordingly. For us now, we should look back on the lost chances to know what we could do  to save psychoanalysis from the decaying IPA. The IPA’s function is no longer the same of Freud’s IPA.  
In the next part of this posting I will concentrate on the changes in psychoanalysis that occurred and were not given the proper attention to consider making the appropriate changes in the functions of the IPA, particularly in the leaning and training in psychoanalysis.