Audience

Thursday, 25 February 2021

 

The IPA: A Solution that Became the Problem.

There is an Arabic proverb that goes like this; the one who reveals the truth to you is your friend (Sadeekak mun Asdakak), Notice the rhyme in the two words of friend and truth.

                                               ……………………………………….

I am starting this post with a proverb because I expect, if not rejection it will be resentment toward the main idea I am promoting here. I think the IPA is an obstacle in the way to getting psychoanalysis a place in Academia, and extending its life in the field of the humanities.

I am aware that the subject of the IPA is of no of interest to psychoanalysts anymore; members and none-members. I am also aware that tackling that subject will not bring any changes to the ‘ongoings’ of psychoanalysis in any local or regional psychoanalytic institution. In my limited research of the status of psychoanalysis in some countries, I could not even sense that the IPA constitutes a problem to deal with. On the contrary, in some regional branches there are more concern about the IPA than the IPA causing concerns. Because the IPA is the final point of authorization in psychoanalysis it is not sensible to ignore its real current status. The IPA is in trouble everywhere. Maybe it is not an issue in practical terms, but it is important in terms of reflecting the true image of psychoanalysis anywhere it exists. Its trouble has been felt for many, many years (since 1995), and it was and still is the dwindling numbers of its membership. However, I did not come across any real effort or attempt at understanding the nature of the problem by looking at the declining interest in the membership of the IPA as the right thing to expect and to happen. Quite the reverse. The IPA custodians seem to think that the lack of interest in its membership is caused by lake of shared interests and poor interaction between its members. I have the impression that lately, the IPA hired a marketing company that suggested a competition in short stories writing between the members, and other things of the same nature to create an atmosphere of camaraderie between the members. The most obvious in those attempts is the avoidance of dealing with the issue in trouble: psychoanalysis.

The existing and symbolic status of the IPA brings to focus three chronic problems that psychoanalysts refrain from confronting and dealing with. The three problems are: apprenticeship as the means of qualifying the psychoanalysts, training and certification, and the vague link between membership and professionalism.

1.      Apprenticeship and Qualifying the Psychoanalysts.

Back to history. The unchanging function of the IPA as the legitimate authority of psychoanalysis conceals (camouflages) the natural changes that are inevitable in any evolving thought like psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysis was not a Freudian discovery; there was no psychoanalysis to discover. He discovered few new and radical things about the ‘psyche’, which were later called Psychoanalysis. Professionals, mainly from the medical profession, and from different parts of Europe got interested, and they started meeting regularly to exchange ideas. During those meetings interested physician and none-physicians were learning from Freud and from each other. Some genuinely and important matters started to emerge, and the meetings were in bigger demand. The promising nature of those meetings got formalized, and an IPA was the solution. In 1910 the IPA was formed. It became  both a membership body and an apprenticeship club (by the nature of the novelty of the subject that required transmitting new knowledge through others who knew more and better). Ten years later both training and membership became practically the twins that the IPA produced to make psychoanalysis a movement; not just a local endeavor. The notion of training and organizing the membership qualification gave birth to the psychoanalytic movement that expanded nationally and internationally to become a new addition to Western Culture.

Unfortunately, the double functions of overseeing training in the IPA training centers and accepting the newly trained candidates as members of the same institution fused, or rather confused, the two acts of training and membership. In spite of the expanding of the psychoanalytic movement and the practical impossibility of maintaining standards of training in psychoanalysis in the system of the IPA training centers, the ‘guardians’ adopted the idea of duplicating the same modality in the newly opened frontiers. They just keep exporting the Berlin ethos to the new center. There was nothing wrong with the Berlin model except that it was just a starting point and not the end line. The IPA should have separated the two functions or kept them together with the understanding that they should not be confused so the same training analyst will not serve in both capacities ever, or at least not at the same time.  

In the glorious time of the guilds and apprenticeship in the middle ages the line that separated the apprenticeship system from the guild functions was strictly preserved and respected. The training part of a profession was kept independent of the professional part of belonging to the guild. What difference does it make? The apprenticeship part of any fundamental profession was under the authority that was creating the requirements and standards of the training needed, and the innovations that were introduced to those professions. On the other hand, the membership body of the professional “Guild” was independent, as the condition to secure its neutrality and objectivity in accepting its members.  In psychoanalysis, the apprenticeship part is assigned to the training institutes, which is supposed to meet the standers defined by the Association (the analytic guild).  In other words: the training institutes of psychoanalysis are responsible for the standards of education and training of the psychoanalysts. The Association is the body that oversees those standards of psychoanalysis and decides if the quality of the graduate is good enough to qualify him to become member of the guild. The separation of the two bodies is fundamental and elemental.[aF1] [aF2]  Without their separation the IPA will accept all the graduates of its training institutes (do you notice where the problem of the training-analyst starts from?!) and the institutes will guarantee the graduate the acceptance in the IPA, thus qualifying him as a certified analyst (again do you see where the training analyst status could be corrupted). The difference between fusing the two functions of qualifying and certifying the psychoanalyst and separating those two functions is the ‘common sense’ of professionality.

The other inherent problem in the IPA being the training body and the accrediting authority at the same time is the functional interdependency between the training side of the IPA and the membership of the Association. For the association to survive it needs to increase its membership and that could be done by managing the institutes in certain ways. The training faculty of the institutes could also manage training in a way that will attract more candidates to training, thus the membership will have more members. Moreover, the membership institution could lower its standards of training for the same purpose. Am I talking about things that could happen and are actually happening in our revered psychoanalytic profession!!

2.      Training and Certifying the Trainees:

The IPA- officially- recognizes only its training centers as the qualifying place to its membership. However, the graduates of its training centers are not allowed to see patients unless they have a recognized clinical degree from a recognized university. Instead of going through the many contradiction the IPA membership creates I will just remind   the readers that we are dealing with a situation created close to century ago regarding psychotherapy, which was an unheard-of term, let alone a term that had a meaning. The contemporary contradictions the IPA embodies are coming from the very limited changes done to that old conception and system, which was conceived in the first four or five decades of last century. What we have to ask and answer and finally decide is: should we end the old conception of psychoanalysis as it is engraved in the IPA’s protocol, or just tinker with it a little? It also clear that we are facing another more profound question that is implicit in the first one: Could there still be psychoanalysis if we do away with IPA) if we decided to do away with the concept of psychoanalysis which the IPA still adopts?  

The answer to the first question is not supposed to be an expression of attitude or personal preference. In my very modest survey of the status of psychoanalysis in different local and regional IPA branches it was evident that there was not one psychoanalytic society that membered the IPA, that had one society (except in North Europe). The splits within the psychoanalytic community are always the same: a training analyst and his followers (previously private patients in training) disagree with the controlling figures of the society and split, claiming theoretical disagreements. Not one (according to only me) was ever capable of articulating the points of difference he claimed to make him think of saving psychoanalysis from other psychoanalysts. Even Lacan who was and still is the most articulate innovator in psychoanalysis did not say something convincing about what was wrong with Lagashe. All IPA sub-associations are made of more than one local society (with its own ideas about training) and there is no justification offered for that split. I did not find two branches that had one and the same definition of psychoanalysis. Practically and pragmatically speaking, the IPA as a global association answers our first question this way: we could do away with psychoanalysis, but we cannot do away with the IPA if we want to keep psychoanalysis living. That answer highlights that belonging to an organization is the gist of our identity

3.      Membership and Professionalism:

Psychotherapy is no longer a frivolous matter or unverified method of dealing with a major need of many people. It is also impossible to talk about psychotherapy without psychoanalysis coming in the picture, because all psychotherapies are offshoots of psychoanalysis, one way or another. This is a very subtle but important issue to examine when we talk about the IPA. IPA was the beginning of the profession of psychotherapy and it was natural that gaining its membership implied that the member is a psychoanalyst. It was the dream of so many young people at the beginning of the twentieth century to become, one day, member of that reputable organization. The gradual emergence of other types of psychotherapy on the one hand, and on the other, the gradual deterioration of the standards of the IPA training, which is not considered or confronted by the IPA Guardians, created a very confusing situation in the field which IPA considered its backyard. The impossibility of checking the standards of few hundred centers, scattered all over the world, resulted in a multifaceted deterioration of psychoanalysis.

The old idealized link between the professionalism of the psychoanalyst and earning the membership of the IPA hardly exists anymore. The vanishing unified meaning of “psychoanalysis” in the different IPA branches makes that link impractical. Most analysts would not accept this characterization of the situation and refute my judgement of the quality of contemporary psychoanalysis, if not because of lack of concern by the leadership of the IPA, it will be for narcissitic reasons. In the narrow field of psychoanalytic activity, which I live in in North America, psychoanalysis is a generic term of psychotherapy. To put in a more precisely: psychoanalysis is the grammar of the language of psychotherapy, and we could have good grammar and bad grammar. But the IPA that was once strictly psychoanalytic, and its function was limited to learning, training, practicing, and professional certification and accreditation of psychoanalysis and psychoanalysts has diversified. A couple of years ago a strong call for adapting the functions of the IPA to the needs of the public so the IPA would accommodate those needs failed in making any change in the dropping care about its basic function. That attempt that started west of the USA proves that psychoanalysis as it is now has no appeal to people anymore. At any rate, it is not correct to certify a practitioner in psychoanalysis that does not have the basic shared qualifications required to work with patients, in the field. In other words, the IPA could be considered a fraud because it certifies people- as psychoanalysts- who are not allowed to see patients because they do not have the right to that.

All those ‘real’ issues against the present status the IPA shrink if compared to the emerging-if not the already established – systems of training and qualifying psychoanalysts away from the influence of the IPA. Universities -notably- almost everywhere- are open to include psychoanalysis as an academic program or part of a psychotherapy program. This development changes the IPA from the solution to organizing the psychoanalytic movement for most of the last hundred years, to makes it a problem because its coemption with academia. If someone wants to become a psychoanalyst where would he go? IPA or a university program? Officially and traditionally he should seek training in an IPA training center. Practically he should go to a university program to get a better education and possibly some practical training. The difference is that in academia the aspect of apprenticeship would not be considered favorably.

From a Solution to a Problem:

The IPA, or the international institution of psychoanalysis was the solution to the burgeoning movement of psychoanalysis up to maybe the sixties of last century. It created a sense of commonality and internationality. However, it should have been expected that with time, psychoanalysis, the demand for it, the cultural factors and social evolution will change it, and the need and the structure of an international institution will be in need for revision. The IPA was a solution to a situation that needed it. That situation changed and the need to maintain it became more undesirable to the practicing psychotherapist. However, both candidates and training analysts maintained a fixed idea that there is something called psychoanalysis. As such, the IPA had to be preserved and remain the shelter for that ‘thing’. If there is any truth to that untested belief it should be ‘there is psychoanalysis of the subject that should emerge from him and not applied to him. For instance, sexuality of the present subject, and even aggression, are very different from what they were ninety years ago and fifty years ago. Therefore, psychoanalysis and its institution have to be put in the context of the time. I do not think anyone would miss that internationality now-a-days is not the same as it was in the time of the International Psychoanalytic Association.

If this point is missed by the guardians of the IPA psychoanalysis will suffer in its way to die. It is now suffering –differently- in different parts of the world because the IPA does not accept that it is psychoanalysis that need to change, not the organization or the membership. Changing psychoanalysis is not as it was thought about in the early years: making it psychotherapy (which is now nothing but…). No, changing psychoanalysis is changing the notion of the repressed and the psychodynamics of defense and resistance into a psychology of expression and the sophistication of the human phenomena: psychoanalysis not anymore the message that Freud came down with: it is the message that we need to decipher, interpret and understand.


 [aF1]

 [aF2]

Thursday, 11 February 2021

 

The Political Leader and the People: Who Leads and Who is Led?

1.       Prologue

In this posting I am thinking and writing about the events of January 6 on Capitol Hill in Washington not as an American (I am not American) or an expert in the subject, but as an educated person who has a point of view that comes from his background as a psychologist\psychoanalyst.

I have to clarify that what influences my approach to this subject is my background as a psychologist-more than being a psychoanalyst. However, understanding and interpreting the phenomenon is purely derived from my psychoanalytic training experience. My attempt at that is not based on what psychoanalysts say about the phenomenon; it is how psychoanalytic clinical thinking -not psychoanalytic theory- approaches the link between causes and effects in nonclinical issues like social phenomena.

 

Psychologists study and work with cognitive functions, which they consider the core of psychological life: perception, memory, development and evolution of affective responses, memory, etc. Thinking is one of the most significant topics in that list. People differ greatly in their abilities and inclinations to think; sometimes innately (intelligence) and sometimes personally (preference and bias). Trump is an extreme and rare case of a subject who is not able to think either ways. He is not even insightful and inclined to manage anything mentally as some of his kind sometimes do. He even does not fall in the category of selective thinking potentials. He just does not think, period. One example: when he suggested to the team of physicians in the White House to use detergents as injection against Corona Virus, he did not think what could have stopped all physicians over the last two centuries from doing that with other epidemics (I do not mean that he should have thought medically but just to engage his mind in a process of thinking, asking himself a question?). In my opinion, Trump, in most cases of being accused of lying did not lie, because lying requires remembering, evaluating, thinking, and having a conscious intention to lie. He is not capable of activating all those human gifts to use them either together or in coordination to deal with the facts that he manages.

 

People like Trump assume that they think and get ideas about things. What they get is only allusions of ideas. The distinction is between thoughts that a person knows that he has created- in his own mind- and thoughts that seem to have been created by reliable others who got them the same way he gets them [just whims]. Trump’s ideas were mostly the making of others (God knows what kind of others!!!) and he claimed to have been their origin. The “USA first, let us Make America Great Again” are not his thought. His thoughts (if we could think of any of his) were expressing psychological pressure that did not go through the thinking process to give him feedback needed to judge them. In other words, with people like Trump the task is not to deduce from what they say or do some implicit meaning, but to understand the person because he would be only responding to internal pressures.

2.Understanding the Subject:

In normal life we react to others with the belief that we can understand them. Yet, in most cases, it takes some time and several corrections to know whom we are dealing with. The person within the subject has to be firmly defined to be predictable enough to know. We usually accept the discrepancy between the subject and the person behind him if it is within reasonable period of time or significant change of circumstanced. With people like Trump, and because of the absence of any ability to think the task is not to understand him as a subject via his idiosyncrasies and strangeness, and mostly through event by event. The task is to force accepting him as an odd person (difficult!!). We all recognize and remember Trump’s shiftiness between the best in the history of the USA, and never worse than ever before. What is unique in dealing with those people is the absence of what we call ‘unconscious’, because nothing in those people is conscious in the first place to permit contrasting it with unconsciousness. Everything to them is either present or absent but never an issue of where it should belong: present, past, or ever at all. In dealing with North Korea there was nothing existing beyond the moment of being with its leader. The whole event was judged based on how the meeting went, contrary to his meetings with the leaders of Europe. They came up with topics other than Trump himself to discuss, thus he had no interest in the meetings.  Trump’s issues have one entrance (it is also its exit): it is the psychological pressure of a need or a demand, but just not demanding thinking. This point gets us close to the issue of narcissism. I do not think Trump is narcissitic because a narcissist thinks of himself, about himself, his duality as an I and a Me, which Trump has no clue that such things existed. He has no image to embellish or protect, he is an imageless entity.  

The event of the Capitol Hill was Trump’s last chance to do something about being ousted from the presidency and facing the darkness of a world empty of any issues but also still full of issues for thinking. The psychological pressure he was experiencing made him think of a solution: paralyze the democratic system of the USA so they will not find but him to solve the problem (Easy!!). [An intervening sentence: The USA used insurgence successfully in managing the governments of South America, for decades]. As usual, psychological pressure in people like Trump is good for protecting themselves from unmanageable depressions. Trump tried-with the limitations of his thinking -to turn his helplessness into imaginary potency- by fantasizing the collapse of the collegial verification of the result of the election. His imagination did not even go beyond the breakdown of the meeting. What then? Too much thinking needed to answer that question which he was not equipped to do.

The rioters of January six were not much better than trump in regard to thinking. They were very confused and muddled about the objective of their rioting, then they became disoriented about invading the Capitol. They were without any sign of leadership that thinks for them. Without a thinking leadership they got violent and destructive (even murderous). The vagueness was “clearly obvious” in the nonexistence of a defined achievement to reach by their actions. There was no thinking or signs of knowing what their rioting could specifically bring about. It is easy to say that their instigator-Trump- is the kind of leader who could not deliver to the rioters a demand that has process of thinking behind it. This it is too simple a solution for something more complex. He did not think of how the uprise of three or four thousand rioters would make a nation, a system of government, a constitutional legitimacy, and a history of elections and several millions other American who gave their choice of presidency already in their traditional democratic heritage. No one in the USA, a thinker or a no thinker could have moved those thousands of Americans to that senseless uprising by seducing them to adopt his own personal grievances. The rioters were following their own grievance, which happened to agree and overlap with Trump’s. It is also impossible for those thousands to have moved- toward a definite failure- by themselves. In other terms neither the leader (Trump) alone could have moved that crowd, nor the crowd could have encouraged the leader to lead them to a definite failure. The relationship between the leader and the masses-in general- is a relationship that could be a match or a fit. Germans were egging with anger since Versailles. Hitler was ‘A pollical vagabond”; thus were a good fit, but not a good match. A good match at that situation would have been between a capable nation that wants to take her place in Europe and a leader who knew the potential of his people (which happened in the person of Edenauer and the rest of the German leaders.. That fit requires good timing. The timing of the link between leader and people is not studied enough to give some good answers. However, a hasty observation would miss something obvious: people are there in the scene years before the fitting leader appears to ignite them. Therefore, we could say that the insurgency of January was caused by a problem of timing. Although the rioters and Trump are of the same nature (no thinkers) the timing was very wrong. The USA has gone through foundational changes after the impressive rise of China, the creation of the EU, the fall of communism in Russia. It also had to face internal changes in the fields of gender equality, revision of some basic believes regarding race, social equality, international superiority some of the old values.

What happened on Capitol Hill has to be ‘interpreted’ and reconstructed in order to make it subject for deliberation and maybe change, instead of repetition.  From the slogans used and the other mementos that came with the rioters we could conclude that the memory of the civil war of 1861-1865 was lurking in their minds waiting to be announced. The repressed about that major historical event seem to be pushing for return to be worked-up its repression and to announce its presence. The sense of hurt pride and a wishful attempt at reversing an old and a present defeat answers the questions of what, how, and when, but the why question is the difficult one to find an answer for in the same context. Better, January 6 was a return of the after effect of the unworked out repression of the civil war memories. The why question has to deal with two things at the same time: why the hurt of civil war is still living, and what is the link between it and the present sense of defeat?

If I am not mistaken (and it is difficult to not be) historians did not work out a good and proper understanding of the civil war: was it just to emancipate the slaves?!This interpretation takes us to the possible absence of good construction of the past (political working through). Another factor in the event is that replacement of the south’s sense of pride by a new sense of pride reached the point of replacing fact with imaginary thinking. The four years of Trump’s presidency were life in the imaginary both on the side of the president (he took little time to believe that he is really the president) and for his supporters to think they are back in power. Losing power and status after the civil war engendered unconscious and preconscious feelings of self-hate. With self-hate anger is the comfortable twin. Going back to self-love (living with one’s self) is possible if the individual finds a target to hate to free the self in order to be loved again. The search for that hateful other to re-love oneself is possible and easier if someone loves the person. Exteriorizing self-hate and interiorizing selflove - is almost like saying please find me someone to hate to be able to re-love myself.  This is a change that is very fragile and also very demanding because they could happen jointly.

3.       Psychoanalysis and fact of inevitability of change.

 

The inevitability of change is a complex biological, historical, philosophical, social,issues. Putting that aside is necessary to keep this posting moving forward. The end of WWII was a time stated that the world as a whole has to change. True enough, the world started to undergo and is still undergoing unprecedented changes. In the last few years, especially after 9\11 the USA went into a mode of changing too with all the expected resistance to “giving up” what is familiar and American, and adopting what was once anathema. Giving up racial discrimination is a good example of social change. After few decades of quiet and gradual rejection of racial discrimination, determined in some cases by the location and place like north\south, a sudden revival of the old tendencies of the past happened in special forms (police brutality, mass shootings, etc.). Yet, the most important and impressive change was in the rise of the support the white population of the colored population rights and equalities.  Another change was that the movement for the rights of the colored expanded to include more right for more people (immigrants). Racial discrimination was losing its firm grip on social life when it was previously the norm. The call for social justice and change in class distinctions was not looked upon as communist ploys to destroy capitalism as it was judged before. Social change encompassed gender, sexual choices, social, class few more aspects of life. Those changes happened silently over the years (maybe since the assassination of the Kennedys and Martin Luther King).

 

It is not only natural but even normal that change to a more advanced point in development would elicit some temporary regressive reactions to maturation. What happened in January sixth is a convincing sign that Americans are changed and changing, and some are just objecting in a desperate and frantic way to that change. Psychoanalysts and child psychologists could give valuable insights in that regard and confirm the possibility of regression after progression in a process of growing up. The maturation of Europe after WWI was followed by regression in WWII war, which was obviously just a glitch in a remarkable movement to peace in that unstable continent. In other terms: January Six is a glitch in the history of the USA and almost a declaration of an advancement and progress.  The Capitol event takes us right to the relationship between the leader and the people. The most evident feature in the relationship between the racially inclined masses and Trump what looked in 2016 as a coincidental match between an unexpected (even just a temporary) leader and a long dormant old grievance. Neither Trump could have expected to win the election, nor the dormant racial issue could have found a contemporary leader ready to adopt the long-neglected subject of racial discrimination. He was an empty container that was ready to be filled with anything that needed to be contained. The rest is what we witnessed few days ago. Before moving to the next point I would like to bring to attention that grievance of the time of civil war seems to still has a part to play in what is discussed here and should be addressed because the war was not just a noble gesture to free slaves; it has other dimensions that are very active till now.   

 

4.       Psychoanalytic Approach to a Current Problem.

How could psychoanalysis contribute to a discussion about some phenomenon that is void of unconsciousness, and its leader is mentally inadequate!? This phenomenon still needs interpretation and construction because it has a distorted meaning that should be made distinct and clear to make changes-if possible- to its understanding.

The act of psychoanalyzing is an act of interpretation and construction. Interpretation is to elicit the meaning behind obvious expressions (verbal, symptoms, dreams, transference, memories, etc.), thus a new or another meaning emerges and comes through the previous manifest- usually rigid meaning. Construction is putting the patient’s psychological life, including the unconscious material that was revealed by interpretation, in context; the patient’s context’. Psychoanalytic work is interpretation in the service of constructing a past to make it amenable to change. For that work-to-work, analysis should avoid looking for the causes of what is discovered (why), because the answer will always be influenced by the patient present conscious function and not by the past conditions when the event really happed. Psychoanalyzing should be limited to what, when, and how the associations the analyst is dealing with materialized. I would also add that leaving the best interpretations without construction, when the opportunity appears, makes the psychoanalytic work worthless.

Working with candidate in supervision of their early practices raised two questions in mind: one I mentioned before. I was able to articulate clearly to the candidates that the vocabulary of psychoanalysis is not the theory of psychoanalysis and using that vocabulary does not mean that we are talking theory. The other, which I only got it clearer in my mind lately and after I finished work as supervisor. ‘When we listen to a patient it is to interpret and elicit the unconscious meaning in it, not to find out what psychoanalysis says about it. I noticed that Kleinians are more inclined to look first for the mechanisms that explain the patients’ association and derive and formulate their interpretation based on that finding. This remark relates to the quick application of psychoanalytic ideas in understanding social and historical phenomena.

How can we look into the January sixth events to find an interpretation for it? It was an act of desperation because even if the rioters managed to kill few of the ‘enemy’, stop the certification of the result of the election, and prevent the transfer of power, they still would not have been able to fulfill their leader’s ambition (stay in power). It was also an act of abreaction of rage and the pain of depression, but not a recent and lived one; it was rage and depression of a time passed. The way they appeared and acted indicated that they are living another time in history. The most obvious, but negated thing, in the whole matter, is the actual and factual discrimination the rioters were expressing in the material destruction of the building… this is not ours. The rioters were American of a time passed. This is the danger that should not overlook. Those events could be repeated in the same exact manner because they are not time-related if the problems are not addressed.

I would end this endless discussion by making two observation only a foreigner could make nonchalantly. The USA needs to look at the greatness of its beginning as a past that affected its present decade ago, but now with the whole world solving the problems of pride, nationalism, patriotism, and distinction in different ways. I know more and firsthand that the distinction between the Sunnis and the She’ates is based on two historical lies, and much of their history is the reactions to activating those lies every now and then. I would not be surprised if Americans have similar things in their history that could correct many flaws that politicians use for their own benefit.

Friday, 15 January 2021

Psychoanalysis and Research III:

A Future for Psychoanalysis

Without giving an appropriate explanation of the distinction I make between functional and structural psychoanalyses I should expect analysts to yawn in boredom and lose interest in following the posting to its end. This distinction is specifically in regard to the evolution of psychoanalysis, in particular its training, and its future as a 'certifiable' profession. Psychoanalysis has been losing status, credibility, the trust of patients, the interest of a new generation of candidates, and lacks a defined future perspective. Despite this real gloomy picture there is a glimpse of hope. It is becoming clearer every day that psychoanalysis has evolved, and its traditional system of training- in apprenticeship institutes- is the obvious direct cause of its decline. The time assigned to learn, and train is not enough anymore, to generate competent analysts. To become an analyst nowadays needs fulltime dedication, several more years of study and training in one of the ‘psychoanalytical specialties’ chosen by the candidate, and acknowledging that psychoanalysis is not merely a designation in the three clinical discipline that take on the task of training in psychoanalysis, but a specialty in many fields of knowledge. It is sad to notice the effort the IPA is making to bring some zeal in psychoanalysis the way marketing expert use to bring to life an old forgotten product.

Another encouraging feature is in the indications that departments of psychology and maybe some universities are starting to offer academic programs in psychoanalysis. This sign is encouraging because in a short time there will be better venues to study psychoanalysis than the IPA institutes. The academic venue will (already)face resistance from the present senior (age) analysts and most of the presently active and practicing analysts. When the departments of psychology in universities open their doors for programs in psychoanalysis there will be a demand to qualify the graduates in one of the dozen or so specialties in psychoanalysis, and the monopoly of the therapists will quickly loosens up. The most important outcome of having a new venue to learn and train in psychoanalysis it the gradual (and maybe a fast) deterioration and decline of the parochial IPA system of training in institutes that have no quality control on its endeavors. The most significant and extremely important outcome of that shift is separating the membership institution from the educational and professional institution. In any respectable profession education and certification are independent of each other.   

If, and eventually, when psychoanalysis will become an academic specialty it has to take a functional or a structural approach to its subject matter. This distinction is the core issue in designing and building the teaching and training programs and curricula.  If the program is geared toward studying and working with the subject (clinical and nonclinical) psychoanalysis, in this case, would be more geared toward functionalities: causes and effects.  Functional psychoanalysis involves psychotherapies and studying issues like creativity, child development, etc. However, functionality is not simple reduction of issues into what causes this or that effect. It has to deal with intricacies of the psychodynamics of the interaction of causes and effect [ How does the mother’s attitude toward a child at age three affects his sense of autonomy]? A second trend in psychoanalysis in academics would be geared toward studying social phenomena in general. A sizable part of Freud’s work was on social and group phenomena: Group Psychology and the analysis of the Ego, the Taboo of virginity, Thought for the Times of War and Death). This field of interest requires a structural approach to get to common denominator in the social (group) phenomenon.

Two Obstacles in the Way to Academia:

I mentioned above that contemporary psychoanalysts are, would resist, and discredit any attempt at changing the present status of psychoanalysis. My ‘impression’ is that contemporary analysts would feel inadequate to be academicians and moving psychoanalysis to Academia would eventually weaken the apprenticeship system that requires extraordinarily little, compared with academic expectations. Although psychoanalysis is dying or at least is disfigured badly with the effort to keep it under the auspices of ‘an international organization’, the IPA is unsuccessful in maintaining its previous high quality in training and catching up with its evolution. In other words, the resistance to moving psychoanalysis away from the IPA methods of managing its affaires comes mainly from the analysts and not from anything that could call or justify keeping the status quo. This is from the psychoanalytic point of view. However, there must be some resistance in Academia too to include psychoanalysis in its syllabus. Some come from old disregard of psychoanalysis because of its doubtful scientificity. Some other come from the attractiveness of psychoanalysis as deeper sort of psychology, which could affect the interest in academic psychology as a science of the conscious processes. Those two opposing sources of resistance to ‘academize’ psychoanalysis will not succeed any longer. Psychoanalysis place is naturally next to psychology. The psychology of the conscious functions has to join its long-missed side of the psychical coin, i.e., the psychology of the unconscious.

Whatever is right and the other is wrong, and whoever is correct in his stand and the other is incorrect, psychoanalysis is losing its grounds outside academia for the simple obvious reason: The psychology of consciousness or cognitive functions has to be in dynamic link with the psychology of the unconscious or the affective side of the subject. They should be the subject matter of one and the same academic program. If I put that reasonable deduction in question, we find ourselves face to face with a puzzle: Wundt’s introspection and Freud’s free association were realized almost at the same period of time. However, they did not materialize in the same place: one in the Clinique and the other in Academia. The resistance of the medical professional of psychoanalysis and the relatively busy other analysts is causing a grave harm to themselves and to psychoanalysis. They are more permissive of deviations from the proper practice of psychoanalysis and less keen to maintain the recommended practices in each side. The current status of psychoanalysis and with less urgency in psychology will cause both to sink.

Addendum

I am reading a magnificent book by Noah Feldman entitled "The Arab Winter". It is a reaction to the previously celebrated events called the "Arab Spring". The book is a Model of  structuralism (in social politics). It answered the question of What, When, How, but never the question of Why. Freud's psychoanalysis started with an eager wish to answer questions of Why, but continued and ended with answering only the three structural questions, and few insignificant answers to insignificant questions of Why. The right answers to the structural questions could reveal the why, but not as an answer to question, but as elucidation of the inquiry that leads to a natural understanding of the matter. The dream is a wish fulfillment [why]  because of the workings of the primary processes.

Tuesday, 5 January 2021

 

Research ... Research

It was my impression that the issue of the scientificity of psychoanalysis has subsided, if not because that it failed in coming up with hypotheses or suggestion of research, it would be because it is a ruse and displacement to the real problem in psychoanalysis: we just think that it works but have no prove to confirm that belief. Still, we keep seeking rescue from science. The latest appeal was few days ago:  One area for research that would be valuable is to examine what kinds of features "failed cases" or impasses, or negative therapeutic reactions have in common from the perspective of the clinician or the analytic pair. The notion of a Personal analyst in a dyadic situation assumes that one person is a capable match for the entirety of an analysand's developmental issues.

I will venture and IMAGINE a research done (by who!!) in that area:

We need four experimental groups of ‘failed cases, impasses, negative therapeutic, and successful analyses. Due to the original small numbers in psychoanalysis in general, each of those four groups could be 25 persons. The statisticians will raise the validity coefficient if they consider 25 a small number to guarantee validity of the coefficients. The members of the four groups have to be identical or very much similar to each other in age, gender, socioeconomic background, etc. They should also go through a battery of psychometric measures regarding the reason for referral to psychoanalysis. There are other aspects of the similarities that should be considered but this is not the place to go into details.

Then we come to the analysts: how similar in what and how we could judge them to be of equal competence. Add: four years of analysis with same number of sessions, duration, and circumstances. To avoid the sarcasm of my colleagues of Experimental Psychology I would say: I, personally-as psychoanalyst- do not think that any serios research in the field of psychotherapies is possible. The validity of psychoanalysis comes from internal consistency and correspondence between theory and practice. Based on the changes that happened in the field of theoretical and practicing psychoanalysis in the last ‘few’ decades, this link is quite questionable now. Analyst (in the USA at least) who are calling for research to validate their work are not paying enough attention to the theory and the practicing of that theory in their work. We should keep in mind that psychoanalysis reached its peak of credibility from 1900-197….. without any experimental proof of its validity: It was bringing to the attention the unconsciously obvious in the human subject.                           

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

 

D. Learning or Training: The Dilemma of Psychoanalysts.

This distinction is seldom mentioned or considered in the psychoanalytic circles. It is the distinction between learning what to know about psychoanalysis and training in psychotherapy, which we are inclined to still call it psychoanalysis.  It is a distinction that is blurred- almost intentionally- by the psychoanalytic institution(s) because if it is clarified and recognized there would be some serious questions about the functions of that institution itself. 

However, let us start with another distinction that was fundamental in the development of psychoanalysis itself. It will prepare for a more comprehensive reply to our main issue. What is the difference between a profession that demands certification to practice, and a craft that only requires apprenticeship? This question is in fact fundamental, because though it is avoided by the psychoanalytic institutions it still preoccupies analysts- more unconsciously than consciously (the endless questioning of psychanalysis itself and what is it really). It arises whenever some particular issues are raised like the schools of psychoanalysis, the training systems, the scientificity of the discipline, etc. It has not gotten an answer yet!!. Without answering to that question, we should not talk about ourselves as psychoanalysts. Psychoanalysis has to prove first that it is a profession and not just a designation in other professions to call ourselves psychoanalysts.

Psychoanalysis started with a few physicians and men of knowledge, who were already influenced by the notions of the subject’s duality (German ideological metaphysics). It started with Freud proving -by using hypnosis- the coexistence of dual streams of thoughts in patients. After a short while he realized that the ordinary speech of the patient could, with some attention to its idiosyncrasy, reveals the second stream of consciousness without hypnosis. Freud and his followers embarked on a process of exploring the human subject-via his psychopathology- by just ‘analyzing’ the duality in his speech. The findings revealed that there are obscure psychodynamic processes that link the two streams of thought.  The processes were active and unconscious. Those revelations required improvising new definitions for the common vocabulary and language used to refer to them (repression, etc). Gradually some sort of theoretical framework of psychopathology emerged. The expansion of Freud’s insights and thru the contributions of his group of inquisitive colleagues a movement was created, which evolved to be what we have now: an international organization that is supervising a self-created training system that qualifies a person as psychoanalyst, if trained in one of its accredited institutes.

The reason of choosing this path to start this part of the posting is to show and underline that the onset of psychoanalysis and the objective of the first Freudian group was an interest in acquiring the skill of analyzing people’s speech, not to create a profession. Even those who sought to practice psychoanalysis as treatment of patients took more than two decades to identify-in a definite way- a psychotherapeutic attribute to psychoanalysis. Knowledge of the “unconscious” changed the curiosity, aim, and the dynamics of the group and created an ambition to practice that skill professionally… by making the unconscious conscious. With the increasing number of people who wanted to join Freud’s group the idea of systematizing training in psychoanalysis emerged and linked with the expansion and the reorganization of the IPA. Training in institutes that are governed and accredited by the IPA was found to be the sensible and a practical thing to do. However, there was no external official independent authority to certify the training and authorize practicing that type of therapy (still there is none). Certification is a precondition in the practice of any professions. Analysts, must come to their membership in the IPA already certified by their specific professional qualification to practice their training in with the public, legally.

In Freud’s discussion of the “Question of Lay Analysis” (1926) he was obviously clear in not considering psychoanalysis a profession. He stated that it is an applied psychology that requires special training but is not enough to constitute a separate and distinct profession. He also talked about psychoanalysis as knowledge which is applicable to other professions. As knowledge that could influence- positively-several other professions it could be- symbiotically- a major player in psychotherapy. As psychoanalysis proves its usefulness and functionality in several fields of the humanities it should be treated as such, and not limit it to psychotherapy and characterize it a profession of psychotherapy. A shift to that perception of psychoanalysis requires a different outlook on who is or could become a psychoanalyst?

Up till now, the graduates of only three clinical professions (Medicine, Psychology, Social Work) are accepted in the training programs of the IPA. This stance confirms that the IPA considers psychoanalysis a clinical discipline only. Since the three specialties are not clinically of similar backgrounds, and are markedly different in their clinical functions, we could safely conclude that the graduates of those three disciplines are accommodated in the IPA training in psychoanalysis because they are ‘certified’ professionals. It does not need much to say that such accommodation has nothing to do with psychoanalysis; it only increases the number of the analysts and gives the IPA more members who are certified to practice legally a health act.

 I have to repeat my previously declared view regarding training and the true nature of psychoanalysis to proceed without unnecessary distractions in futile arguments:

If psychoanalysis is a skill and not knowledge, training should-in principle- be restricted to the clinicians who are certified by their academic degrees to treat patient. Example: for a Ph.D. psychologist to be accepted in training in psychoanalysis his Ph. D has to be in clinical psychology and not in experimental psychology, so that after passing his apprenticeship training, he could join the psychoanalytic community. If psychoanalysis is knowledge, training therefore should be open to all the qualified candidates in the humanities, who seek the additional ‘depth’ psychoanalysis offers. Training that meaning should be geared toward the nonclinical aspects of the psychoanalytic discoveries. The term psychoanalyst (if used as an adjective) would then indicate a specialization within a profession.

Losses and Gains:

There are two main issues to address in regard to the membership of the psychoanalytic community: learning/training and the applicants. Psychoanalysis should lose the fixed image of a clinical discipline and being simply a psychotherapy, in order to gain the quality of being a knowledge that enriches other branches of knowledge (including psychotherapy too).  Thus, it would no longer qualify as an apprenticeship but becomes an academic subject. It will not be learned in institutes that are run and overseen by the “membership” organization of the IPA. The learning institution will be Academia which overlook all that is related to getting certifiable in the candidates’ choice of their domain of psychoanalytic interest. There would a real separation between the educational body and the membership body. Psychoanalysis become an integral part of several recognizable professions like medicine.

We lose the unsystematized and haphazard curricula and the subjective significance of the ‘training’ analyst.  We gain the respect of academic learning and the teaching faculty’s concern about its educational input in learning. We also gain that our contributions to psychoanalysis will be scrutinized by other academicians, therefore we open the self-imposed isolation and the gradual deterioration of psychoanalysis.

In regard to the candidates, we will get younger people who are going to spend more years in learning a profession that will give them a quality of credibility they will work hard to deserve and keep. It will weed out those who are not there for learning but only for quick training in doing something less credible than it was many years ago because of its novelty. 

Wednesday, 23 December 2020

The Dilemma of Learning and Becoming an Analyst:

D: Personal Analysis and its Place in Training:

Psychoanalysts are assumed to get their learning and training in institutes that are accredited by a system of hierarchical supervision, which leads to an international 'certification'. Training has three components: Seminars (theory), supervised practice, and personal analysis. The seminars are supposed to go through the classical writings of Freud and previous and contemporary leading analysts, supervision is reporting to three or four training analysts the clinical work with three or four patients to learn the technicalities of practicing the theory 'properly' in psychotherapy.  There is a third requirement for completing the training trio which is known among analysts as “personal analysis”. It is evident to any scrutinizing eye that the first two elements of training are impossible to standardize among analysts who have very different theoretical backgrounds in different parts of the world. However, remedying this flaw in the system of training is possible if psychoanalysis moves to academia as we know about the main defined professions like medicine and engineering. The problem is with the third component Personal Analysis. Most of the time and more frequently Candidates are excited about that component in particular because it used to give psychoanalytic learning and training an air of superiority (a fantasy of analysts being cured of their psychical disorders to be allowed to practice psychotherapy).  I do not know the source of that fixed phantasy, because the requirement to undergo personal analysis is basically to learn how it is done because there is no literature or other means that could show and demonstrate:

1.     How the unconscious is derived from the conscious verbal reporting of the patient,

2.    How an interpretation is formed and delivered to the patient,

3.     How construction is done to turn the interpretations- every time they are ripe- into an insight of an intrapsychical element that was formed or deformed in childhood.

Since 'personal analysis' is a requirement in the training process it became a central issue in the problems of "training analyst". The problem is best recognized in a recent question raised in the American Association. Is there a difference between personal analysis in training and psychoanalytic treatment of patients?

All the arguments in regard to maintaining the status of the training analyst were supporting the notion that analyzing a future analyst should be qualitatively better, therefore personal analysis of a candidate should be with a training analyst. Sounds logical but it is really sandwiched between two contradictions.  A. For any psychoanalysis to work as a therapeutic tool has to come from the patient’s own sense of need for it, and that it is not imposed on him for any external reasons (father, wife, boss, etc.). B. Its benefits should not be linked with any external beneficiary (father, wife, boss or the INTITUTE. 

However, even though the motive behind personal analysis is the right one there would still be a difference related to a genuine desire to train. This difference is imbedded in the process of psychoanalyzing itself. 

Free Association, Interpretation, and Construction: 

There is something about psychoanalysis we usually forget although its effect on our thinking as analyst is very evident in two things: our conception of the unconscious and the meaning and link between interpretation and construction. The roots of the discovery of the unconscious go back to the hypnotic stage in the history of psychoanalysis: the unconscious is the repressed objected to conscious material. This indelible attitude that our work is to make the unconscious conscious takes different forms in the different school but boils down to missing that the unconscious is psychical construct that exists independent of its content, It makes conscious material unconscious (through the primary processes). Unconsciously, Freuds conscious concerns about himself and his patient Irma created a dream-scene full of sarcasm and despise of people. Therefore, our work is to find the hidden meaning -in open sight- of the associations and give it to the patient to understand what he distorted and how. In other a more concise words: interpretation is to elicit the disguise meaning of the given material.

Doing that whenever possible leaves the patient at a loss (he is saying two things all the time). Freud (1937d) says: " 'Interpretation'   applies to something one does to some single element of the material, such as association or parapraxis. But  it is a 'construction' when one lays before the patient of the analysis a piece of his early history that he has forgotten …" (p.261). This new issue fits well the dialectical nature of the human subject who is always in a state of duality (Hegel). I preciously underlined the notion that we do not analysis psychical issues, material, or other psychical 'things', we analyze processes that construct those issues. A transference reaction is the result of a dialectical interchange of analyst analysand relationship[that is why the tripartite recommendation of neutralit,...is very important to adhere to it].

The difference between self-analysis and (regular) psychoanalysis:

In principle there should not be any difference. However prosonal analysis is in all likelihood is gone through with another objective in the mind of both analyst and candidate. The difference could be unnoticeable or insignificant, but we should not ignore the preconscious in that respect ( I am not factitious in raising this point. I am pointing out how much could be swept under the rug in ignoring this point.)   Both will have in the back of their minds issues pertaining to admiring, identification and future encounters in professional life and society. Putting that aside we have to consider the process itself. What could be different in interpreting and construction work.

I am speaking from the point of view of one training analyst. I used to take more time and reveal more of my mental process in reaching my remarks, I did more so when it came to constructing. It was sometimes not easy to hide the teaching aspect of my comments, but I did not notice any marked difference in the outcome of those works on the therapeutic work. However, several times in my own training one of my supervisor (of the cases of training) suggested that I take some of my clinical experiences back to my analysis. The attitude of the supervisor brought to my attention that training is not three separate activities but they are all one process in the "formation" of an analyst. with this in mind personal analysis took a different meaning that I tried to subtly convey to the candidate\future analyst.

  
















0


Friday, 18 December 2020

 The Dilemma of Learning and Becoming an Analyst:

 

C: The Link Between Theory and Practice!!!??

The actual reality is that there is no definitive or approved link between what we call the theory of psychoanalysis and the technique of proacting it in psychotherapy. We have a rather impressive vocabulary we gathered over the early years of discoveries in psychodynamics and we it treat it as our theory of psychoanalysis. We also have few early recommendations about practice psychotherapy but they have no link with the theory. The proof to that is absence of any serious literature on their on their merits.  The main three recommendations are regarding the relationship between the analyst and the patient: Anonymity, Neutrality, Abstinence. Those three stipulates are mentioned in the ‘theory’ without any clear explanations of their significance. I will venture and reveal my own assumptions of their importance in the practice of “psychoanalysis”, The first and basic Freudian discovery was the interlinkage between the conscious and the unconscious, which made him recommend to the patient to say whatever come to his mind without any attempt to stop himself from saying whatever. He called that free association. Therefore, the analyst should not say or do anything that could interfere with that request, positively or negatively. At the same time the patient’s associations and reactions to the analyst’s demeaner and interpretations should be considered transference material (that is if the analyst adhered to the mentioned above trio). It does not matter if the patient has access to realistic facts about the analyst as long as the analyst does not confirm their accuracy or object to their incorrectness. The point to make is that the practice of psychoanalysis has theoretical parameters and is not just statements of ‘direction’ like making the unconscious conscious.

The first point to mention in this context is that without theoretical elucidation Practice becomes void of any actual orientation. Even in the multiplicity of schools there should be a link between theory improvised new school and its practice. The well-known adage in regard to classical psychoanalysis is that it is making the unconscious conscious (making the unconscious conscious is too abstract to mean anything). The core of the classical theory is that psychopathology manifests intrapsychical distortions caused by an unhealthy relation with a parent. How do we get to those dissertations to make the proper changes in them? Following the gist of the recommended Trio the patient will be less tempted to react to the vague undefined analyst and bring back his previous dealings with the parental figures, i.e., transfer to the analyst his past psychical life. Transference is the substance of the intrapsychical.

In the history of practicing analysts gave the three stipulates recommended for proper practice various imaginary ritualistic values. Being without linkage to the theory resulted in becoming some comic rituals of comic nature. I knew a lady of the third British group who never let her patients shake hands with her or hand her the fees…put them on the desk. The reaction to those meaningless maters engendered equally comic observance and understanding of the ‘ridiculous. The point is that analysts were left with an impressive vocabulary about the psyche that seemed and gave the impression of a new theory; but without any equally impressive explication of the process of psychoanalyzing. Worse, training in two generations lost its purpose: learn a trade; it became a process of imitating the training analysts and advance to idealizing them.

I am not comfortable describing and labeling psychoanalysis in those terms, because even if there some truth-in different degrees of correctness in what I said there are many analysts and associations of psychoanalysis who were able to avoid the negative and stick to the positive. Nevertheless, warning about the inevitable deterioration of training and learning psychoanalysis has something to do with something completely different. Psychoanalysis emerged in the Western culture little more than a century ago. This is the belief of most analysts and a source of their well-known pride; if not more than just pride. This pride is the basis of another falsified belief: psychoanalysis is a profession. Since the human subject suddenly had the insight that there is more to his kind to learn about a new field of achievement was born (3000 years ago !?). Man wanted to know more and detail about himself and others. He called that the love of wisdom philosophy. In other terms philosophy is- more or less- the verbal side of knowing ourselves while the achievements in the sciences are using our knowledge to understand the world around us. Therefore, we could pose the issue pertaining psychoanalysis this way: is psychoanalysis an aspect of philosophy (knowing ourselves) is it a science using our knowledge of ourselves to understand the world around us?  !!

There is a more specific duality that concerns the practicing psychoanalyst in that regard: Hegel (philosopher) realized and recognized- in one of the most revealing thoughts- that the human mind is incapable of dealing with an issue but only with the duality of the issue: morality is the antithesis of immorality, therefore for it to be considered its opposite has to be created and envisaged. His dialectical conception of the dualities of the human mind is the dormant giant of the human creation of language. In that perspective psychoanalysis is a discovery of a cardinal human quality and is also a method to analyze psychical what seems as singular issues. P. Ricoeur marveled at Freud’s dialectical conception of his thought. In a rapid conclusive  statement: the link between theory and practice in psychoanalysis is dialectical but that is only if the theory in its own right is dialectically formulated and the technique of psychoanalyzing is similarly dialectical in its own right too.