Supervision:
The Skill of Teaching and Educating:
In the previous posting- I disapproved of personal
analysis as a prerequisite of training. I emphasized the importance of
supervision as the main training event in the preparation of the candidates.
However, I emphasized the importance and significance of the supervisors’ knowledge of
how to analyze, i.e., teach and demonstrate the skill of listening and deciphering
the implicit unconscious in what the patient says in his conscious speech. Discerning
the unconscious from the conscious material is an ability (we are not all of
the same ability). Yet, there are things to learn about that ability which
could learn to do to make the supervision better.
There are two things the supervisor has acquire and
sharpen to do that. The first thing is to know more about consciousness.
Paul Davies says: “Among life’s many baffling properties, the phenomenon of
consciousness leaps out as especially striking. Its origin is arguably the
hardest problem facing science today and that remains almost impenetrable even
after two and a half millennia of deliberation […]. Consciousness is the
number-one problem of science of existence even.” Quoted in Solms’s (The
Hidden Spring, 2021).
The reason
I am quoting that phrase is because analysts consider their main task is to discover
the unconscious, and mainly from conscious material. But how could we
discover the unconscious if consciousness itself is supposed to be problematic.
To make that clear I would say that consciousness is only consciousness if it
is consciousness of an object or the subject himself. In a less complicated
format we should ask: how could we make a candidate listen to what the patient
is conscious of, but not aware that he also ‘says’ something else without being
conscious of it? How to supervise a candidate without a systematic approach to
listening to what was said but not verbalized? The answer is if we know
the psychical process that creates the psychoanalytic term we use to
understand the none verbalized. Let me try a self-evident situation like Projection.
In any speech of a patient-or anyone else- that talks about another person there
would be a process of projection, if not for any reason it is for delineating boundaries
(he\she and me). Projection in that case is ‘to say something ‘about’ the
person but in regard to the self: he is a nice person in (my opinion). This
psychical process is the origin of the enfant’s budding sense of self: Mother
is smiling, this is nice, I am nice I smile too. Projection is the original
source of the sense of being. Infant and child psychology are essentials in
doing analysis, in supervision, and making sense of psychoanalytic terminology.
Without too
much elaboration we can notice that there is projection in any relationship
because we gain a sense of being, or cannot gain a sense of being, without the
being of another. We have to be conscious of the external as the condition of
being conscious of self. This point is a source of so many features of psychological
life in humans, because after a while and in different degrees of clarity and
correctness we could become conscious of consciousness… of consciousness itself.
Considering all those related subjects we can see how a supervisor could be
good or not so good depending of his psychoanalytic knowledge, analytic gifts,
but most of all is not using preformat meanings of terminology.
Most of the research done on infants’ recognition and
reaction to the mother in the very early weeks and months of life. The point I
am making is that within each psychoanalytic term there is a psychical process
that if it is identified and studied properly teach candidates the techniques
of practice,. i.e.., how to listen, what to listen to, what to derive from the
patients’ speech and do proper supervision.
Psychical Processes and Analytic Terminology:
I had a
professor of psychology who was not a psychoanalyst but (though very senior) a
student and friend of the French psychologist Henri Wallon. One day I used the
term projection in a presentation he attended. He later asked me what I meant
by projection. When I used the simple meaning I got from the few psychoanalysts
who were in Egypt at that time, he said: as psychologist you should know the
psychological process that creates your definition of ‘unconsciously seeing
in the other a characteristic of yourself’. The importance of his remark kept
developing over decades of thinking to become an [aF1] eagerness
to understand all the vocabulary of psychoanalysis in terms psychological
processes. What is the psychological process that creates identification or
narcissism, etc.?
One of the
first psychoanalytic terms that I spent time researching was “Projection”,
especially when I realized that Klein hyphenates it with the term
“Identification”. It was thus more clear but also more complex. Projecting
suggests that the person identifies both his-self and the subject he chooses to
project on one of his traits. Therefore, projection is not a defense mechanism
as A. Freud presumed. It is a process of making something unconscious gets a
means to become -indirectly-conscious. Knowing what gets conscious and what in contrast
becomes unconscious is a main issue of psychoanalysts. In other words, we can
use psychoanalytic terminology to name psychical manifestations but not to understand
the psychical process behind it. The psychoanalytic term makes the process just
knowable but not understandable. Good psychoanalysis-and definitely good supervision-
request the extra work of making the analytic term explain not just defines. The
point that my professor made sheds light on an important problem in our
training in psychoanalysis. We learn a psychoanalytic vocabulary, and we also
know how to use it correctly (most of the time). Nevertheless, we do not know
how it happens, i.e., what is projection/ that identifies.. In other words,
most of us would know if the patient’s conscious associations about someone is projective
or objective, we do not what happens to make that happen. What is the
psychological process that creates identification or narcissism, etc.?
For now, I
would say that the key to revealing the psychical processes behind the
psychoanalytic terminology is in the language, the verbal expression of the
term in actual explanation of it.
I finish this part of the post by underling an issue
in the field of the unconscious (which relates to the vagueness of consciousness.
The unconscious is a specific means of saying something in not-conscious format: metaphorical and or metonymical.