Mass Shooting: A sad social event or a social phenomenon that needs attention???
Mass shooting could be taken as sad social events that could happen and had happened in different societies in different periods of time. But when they happen repeatedly in one place-as it has been happening in the USA lately- we have to consider them more than just sad events. They should be considered social phenomena. The difference between social events and social phenomena is not in the repetition or the gravity of the outcome; it is a difference in the meaning they carry and convey about something grave happening to the society. Mass shootings in Iraq few years ago, or in Afghanistan now, are sad social events because they are merely direct manifestations of an ongoing sectarian divide aiming at victory or defeat. Mass shooting in the US has no common denominator like being against a particular enemy, or seeking an identified objective as scaring the immigrants. They are also mostly without known common motivation and blatantly illogical to both the doer and the victim. Events are “understandable” when put in their proper context, while social phenomena should not be just understood; they need to be interpreted because their causes are not defined and explicit in the act itself. Another difference is that social events are understandable by knowing and retrieving their sources that might not be understandable. Mass shooting in Iraq was understandable although the sectarian war itself was understandable.The were the declared aspect of the phenomenon, and ere not not events.
The last mass shooting in the USA in Texas and Iowa was understood, explained, and defined by the media and the members of the current active political situation as a result of Trump’s racist public statements, his setting sections of the society against others, dividing the society to better his chances to get reelected. However, the man is mentally incapable of thinking to make a plan of any kind, or to execute a plan designed for him to perform. In clearer words, Trump is part of the phenomenon of mass shooting in the US not its cause. It is only needed to say that the mass shooting events in the US are bizarre, illogical, look to be emotional reflexes, showoffs, etc., to realize that there must be a link between Trump and mass shootings but not the link of cause and effect. Selecting him from amongst 18 respectable politicians is a puzzling phenomenon in its own right. Electing Trump coincided with a substantial number of internal political crises and encountering several constitutional flaws that were not uncovered before Trumps method of ruling. Trump is a figure in the phenomenon of mass shooting.
What is the phenomenon that could create mass shooting in a society like the USA, and to make electing a man like Trump possible? What is the phenomenon that ‘interprets’ one of the most weird election in the USA history and makes it coincide with one of the most active phases in the phenomenon of mass shooting? It is not right for me (foreigner) to venture and answer this question. However, what drives me to raise this warning flag is what happened in Toronto (Canada) yesterday and also few weeks ago. A small-scale mass shooting happened in sober Canada. Hopefully, what is happening south of us will not justify emulating our big sister. Maybe there are hidden reasons for what happens in the US but to happen in Canada too should be scary to all of us.
It is a blog for my psychoanalytic observations, commentaries on events, responding to some published material in psychoanalysis, and a way to say what I have no interest in publishing as printed material.
Audience
Wednesday, 7 August 2019
Wednesday, 24 July 2019
The response to this posting made
me think of adding an addendum to it. It is about few things to consider if
there is an intention to approach the local university about introducing
psychoanalysis to its interested students. The addendum is not a set of advises
but only mentioning things to consider.
…………………………………………………………………
Approaching a university department
to allow few lectures on psychoanalysis is better done through the local psychoanalytic
institute or society rather that by individual initiatives. It makes it an organization addressing an organization.
The involved local psychoanalytic
body should discuss and design an approach to the departments of psychology,
sociology and social work (psychiatry !) and prepare:1. Individual lectures- at
the beginning of the academic year as 'general knowledge'. 2. if there is interest
in the subject the local psychoanalytic body should design and advertise a
series of 3-5 lectures in certain topics to be offered in the different social
and cultural activities in the allied departments (Dreams, transference,
interpretation, etc.). 3. The involved analysts should make themselves available
to the faculty in the concerned departments to help in post graduate
theses, both with ideas, theoretical suggestions, and readiness to help
with the literature.
This last point demands from us some humility and desire to know more about certain areas that we actually know very little ( the emergence of the sense of being in children and how it evolves. It is an invitation to cooperation.
This last point demands from us some humility and desire to know more about certain areas that we actually know very little ( the emergence of the sense of being in children and how it evolves. It is an invitation to cooperation.
Having a framework of cooperation
and performing it without making the revival of psychoanalysis our ‘hidden’
purpose of approach could lead in a natural way to making psychoanalysis a valuable addition to the academic program that is accepting it
as a guest or as a trial.
I am worried-though- about three
things:
A. I expect good immediate
response, which could make the analysts in such project to quickly think that students are future patients, and they start
upholstering their couches. This will kill the project instantly. Our lectures
in such a project should be about psychoanalysis, what it has discovered about
us\them, and not about the neurotic cousins.
It is important not to let our present predicament colour our approach
to introducing psychoanalysis to academia. We have to be aware that it will
take few years to make it natural to be part of the curricula of those
departments. Most importantly, moving toward academia is a step in the direction
of changing psychoanalysis as it is learned and be trained now and finding a
new and better psychoanalysis.
B. Young and recently trained
analysts did not learn psychoanalysis well because both they and their training
faculty were interested in the contributions of the new schools. We have to
agree or disagree about this point to decide what is fundamental in the psychoanalysis we will introduce and avoid creating confusion about us. My view is that there is nothing psychoanalytic of any
form in the new schools of psychoanalysis (since Kohut). The basic and
foundational is the theory of psychodynamic is: the centrality of the working of
the primary processes, interpretation, analysis of transference; NOT of relations, reconstruction
that links the past with the present, revealing to the patient the presence of
his childhood fixations in his present conflicts. Those points could be the source of very
interesting lecture to the public, and could show that psychoanalysis is about
our daily life, and there is more to learn about it and more contribution it could offer other human sciences.
C. It is VERY important that the
faculty in those department know that we are not there to compete with them,
find new patients, belittle their specialties, etc. we are there to contribute
in an educated way to their efforts.
Sunday, 21 July 2019
3.
Where to Learn Psychoanalysis:
A. Deviating and Getting Lost:
The reason I wanted to emphasize
that psychoanalysis is not a profession is a wrong attitude we take from the
training we get in IPA institutes. For us-trained psychoanalysts-whenever the
term psychoanalysis is mentioned it meant what we learned in the institutes of
psychoanalysis. The fact is that we were supposed have learned everything about
psychopathology and many aspects of psychoanalysis in our professional degrees,
so what we would learn in those institutes should have been the technique of
practicing psychoanalysis. In other words, the institutes were for training us in
the skills of psychoanalyzing. The skills are how and what to listen to (notice,
observe, sense, etc.) in order to discover the unconscious elements in what we are
hearing. Listening like psychoanalysts should lead to interpreting the new
psychical meaning that emerges from what we discovered during our listening,
and use it skillfully to make the patient recognize what else he has said
(painted, did, meant, etc.) without being conscious of it. In addition to
leaning this skill we learn how to reconstruct to the patient his psychical
life as one comprehensive LIFE. Without noticing the difference between
learning a skill and training in a new profession we created a major distortion
in the concept of training; training became an objective not a means to an
objective. This was the downfall of psychoanalysis as the subject matter of our
professional endeavours and the worsening of the practice of that deteriorating
(deteriorated) theory.
The IPA institutes were not and
still are not the ideal place to learn psychoanalysis. The candidates of
sixties and the mid-seventies learned most of the theory of psychoanalysis
before they applied to the training programs. Most of us had training- analyst
who were actively participating in expanding and sophisticating
‘psychoanalysis’. They stimulated in us the interest in learning what
psychoanalysis has added to our knowledge as psychologists and psychiatrist.
Therefore, we never lost our connection with our original formation and became
more interested in the theory psychoanalysis. Sadly, this attitude changed when
training in IPA institute became a short cut to a practice in the mental health
profession. Psychoanalysis changed from being a skill that could complement our
original professions to a profession in its own right. There is something
basically wrong in that change: psychoanalysis was supposed to be the source of
the knowledge that we seek training in the skills to use it, to understand the
patient and make the patient understand himself. What happened instead is a
major mistake: training analysts ignored the difference between learning and
training and gave themselves the right to be both: trainers and professors.
This point was not examined thoroughly enough when the problem of the training
analysts was highlighted last few years in desperate efforts to solve the
negative impact of that created status on training.
Unconsciously, we sleepwalked into a
trap we set for ourselves: we blurred the difference between psychoanalysis as
knowledge and as practice (in ALL respectable professions the clear and sharp
difference between knowledge and practice is a fundamental feature). The
outcome was a gradual deterioration in both psychoanalytic knowledge and its
practice. As I mentioned in the last part of this posting: psychoanalysts
referred the crisis of the continuing drop of interest in psychoanalysis to
misconceptions about it, due to people’s ignorance of MODERN psychoanalysis.
The issue is that the crisis of psychoanalysis is due to the poor quality of
modern psychoanalysis, which is a result of the poor quality of training in the
IPA institutes; what else!!!!!
B. The Restoration of the Reputation of
Psychoanalysis:
Psychoanalysis
was born with a very good reputation. From the beginning, which we all know,
the initial refutations on moral basis and the medical professions attacks on
its findings, did not sway people and the many young aspiring physicians from
seeing something futuristic in it. In a nutshell, psychoanalysis had all the
features that made people realize that it talked to them about what they knew
to be right, because they could see it in themselves and in other people. Psychoanalysis
was a theory of the subject and not a theory of “something” and needed to have
the evidence to prove its believability; it was a theory of us and them and
that did not need to look for confirmation of its discoveries. After a short
while Freud introduced metapsychology and was tempted to use its language to
create a new vocabulary for his observations, and to give them some abstract
meaning. It still was relevant to people’s direct observations and
understanding of the subject. Close to the end of being in charge of theorizing
for psychoanalysis Freud formulated a metapsychology that was basically a
reification of his findings (ego-psychology). Yet, unnoticeably, he corrected
that deviation in his work “Inhibition, symptoms, and anxiety”, a work that did
not catch much attention, mainly due to it heuristic discussion of the
cause-effect nature of psychological phenomena. Freud’s psychoanalysis was a
theory that was stemming partially from his clinical experience and mainly from
true and valid observations and understanding of the subject (there is no
clinical reason for Freud to have discovered the super-ego, except that the
presence of the Ego was not enough to explain all the conscious faculties of the
subject. The ego had to have a metapsychological addendum to explain other function
its direct presence in the subject. Thus, he had to work out a place for that
addendum in his metapsychology.
In
my view, psychoanalysis until Freud was alive and a little after his death was
distinguished and deserved its respectability. Psychoanalysis’s main concern
was knowledge about a subject. Even when the conflict between the Freudians and
the Kleinians emerged the subject matter remained the same and psychoanalysis
preserved its distinguished status. The controversies did not reduce the
value of the arguments; in a subtle way the issue was what would explain
the other: does metapsychology explain psychology (Anna explains Melanie) or
does psychology generate metapsychology[aF1] (Melanie as the basis of Anna)? Even the French controversies did not reduce
psychoanalysis to mere personal disagreement: Lacan was trying to give
psychoanalysis its ‘Structural’ identity and dissipate the
functional point of view but went about it in provocative way.
It is
when some of Freud’s early
and ardent supporters (Stekel, Jung, Rank, Ferenczi, etc.), started to argue
about technique that psychoanalysis entered into a downward spiral. There are
‘possible’ causes for that feature in psychoanalysis. The first is that
analysts who narrowed their views and limited them to matters of practice were usually
either victims of over confidence in their knowledge of the foundational
knowledge of psychoanalysis, and argued from a false position of regarding psychoanalysis
a theory that has reach the point where it stopped growing, and they knew it
well enough to ignore evolving it further. The second, matters of technique relate to
training and not knowledge. IPA institutes are not built to graduate psychoanalyst,
they are supposed train psychoanalyst to practice psychoanalysis; their
function (with time) changed to graduating clinical practitioners presuming
that they also learn psychoanalysis in the process. Training in those
institutes in the best case is to teach enough of psychoanalysis that makes
training in the technique possible.
Where
then could someone learn psychoanalysis?
C:
Psychoanalysis as an Academic Issue:
Answering this question is not a simple one. To
evaluate answering this question properly we need to clarify the attitude of
the ones who answered it: do they believe that psychoanalysis could be learned
without the clinical aspect considered, or there is no psychoanalytic knowledge
outside or without the clinical component. If the answering person believes
that learning psychoanalysis is meant to prepare the candidate for clinical
practice then the IPA institutes, or the equivalent, is the place to go. If the
answer comes from an intellectual (physician, social worker, psychologist,
drama teacher, etc.) it will be: go to an academic institution that has
intellectuals with various interest in the human subject to study
psychoanalysis well, where they know how to transmit knowledge to their
students. Although some academic institutions did and still do that (though
mainly for psychoanalysis as a therapeutic act) they did not take it as a
branch of the humanities, or as a significant aspect of psychology in
general.
Psychoanalysis
is knowledge that hast to be protected and given the opportunity to be
recognized as such, expand to reach its own extent of capability and eventually
change psychology as it is taught now in universities, and is involved in
psychiatry and social work. By adding psychoanalysis to the existing psychology
in academia makes the nature of the human subject more coherent and easily
shared by all the branches of sciences that deal with the human subject.
However, this kind of change and its extent is not possible without a radical
change unrelated to the psychoanalysts. We, the old and older
generation, have to realize that a change in direction in the way
psychoanalysis is understood, transmitted to newer generations, setup to relate
to other burgeoning human sciences, branching out into different areas of
interest outside the clinical aspects, and becoming ‘knowledge’ in its own
right and it is not just those mystical things that are available only in the
IPA institutes training system, those changes have to happen to us first with
sincere intention to give up the present system and make psychoanalysis an
academic issue.
However,
it is a challenge to expect such thing to happen. Twenty-five years ago, IPA
acknowledged the existence of the present crisis. It did nothing more than
convened committees ‘puzzled’ about it till now. It resorted lately boosting
our moral and suggesting that it is trying and succeeding in containing the
crisis. But the most glaring failure in its efforts is not telling the
membership what its findings about the causes of the crisis (curing a disease
without a diagnosis). I cannot help
wondering what is the undeclared opinion of the- elected- leadership of the
IPA, and if they see hope in things improving spontaneously.
I
think that sincere and serious analysts about the future of psychoanalysis
should just bypass the psychoanalytic organization (s) and go ahead and try
with acts of good faith make contacts with the academic institutions in their
locations. In other terms we should admit and announce that we the analyst
will save psychoanalysis without the permission or approval or even the support
of its organizations. The individual attempts will prove to the hesitant
analysts that nothing tangible is coming from the IPA; it has stand or opinion
about the crisis.
What
is of the utmost importance is to keep in mind that taking serious measure in
this regard is to save psychoanalysis and not save us and our livelihood. We
can survive without psychoanalysis but psychoanalysis cannot survive without
well learned and trained analysts.
Sunday, 14 July 2019
2. The
fallacy of Psychoanalysis is a Profession:
The concern
about the survival of psychoanalysis in North America is directly related to
the numbers of patients seeking psychoanalytic psychotherapy. The numbers have
dropped and are still dropping. The drop in other parts of the world, maybe,
not as bad but enough to raise the alarm about the future of psychoanalysis.
The concern about the future of psychoanalysis goes back to 1995 when the IPA
tried-officially- to understand the reasons for that drop and could not do
anything about it for the last twenty-five years. Therefore, my argument about
the issue is that the shrinking status could be more serious in some parts of
the world more than others, but the crisis is universal all the same. The
crisis as it has been raised is clearly related to psychoanalysis as a
profession and not psychoanalysis itself (as body of knowledge),
because what concerned the IPA all along and the regional and the local
societies is the dwindling numbers of analysts, candidates, and patients without
any concern about ‘what is practiced as a profession of psychoanalysis’.
The IPA has
a membership of forty-eight (48) societies (one fourth of the countries in the
world). It has 12797 member and 5434 candidates in training. This means that in
average each society has 267 analyst and 113 potential future members. Could
those figures qualify psychoanalysis to call itself a profession; or even a
profession that might have future? No. By no means we can claim that
psychoanalysis is a profession, in the real sense of the word, with those
numbers. Not even when the number jumps few hundreds or a couple of thousands
in a society it still not qualified to be called a profession. This rigidity is
because those figures were double, and in some places triple the present
numbers, i.e., if psychoanalysis is a profession, it is a dying profession. Any
successful profession grows stronger with time as when psychoanalysis did the
first forty years of its history but started to die forty years ago. In my
opinion, reviving psychoanalysis is not difficult but restoring psychoanalysis
as a profession is not possible anymore, unless something be done to psychoanalysis
itself. It was wrong from the
beginning to pay attention to the practice of psychoanalysis and neglect the
looseness in regard to the modification introduced to the theory in the guise
of developing and improving its practice.
We have to
solve an additional problematic in the crisis. We-the clinal psychoanalysts-
are the ones who turned the fundamental discovery of the twentieth century and
the pillar of the Western civilization into something very unidentifiable as a
body acknowledge. Better, we analysts kept working on therapeutic of
psychoanalysis claiming to improve it, turning it into a profession. We became
contented with having an international organization that gave memberships to the
practicing psychoanalysts without any examination or investigation of the
quality of the theory they practice. Assuming the right to training analysts, the
IPA was happy to increase the number of training institutes without any serious
examination of the nature, content and quality of the training offered and the
training faculties. No wonder we realized the serious problem with the status
of the training- analyst and were unable to deal with it.
Psychoanalysis
in its mightiest time as a profession in the sixties and seventies of last center
was-in fact and better judgment- less important or significant compared with
the discoveries it generated during that period of time. It continued rejuvenating
the Western culture. In that period of time psychoanalysis penetrated all the cultural
and social aspect of the culture. It positioned itself in the midst of the revived
intellectual life after WWII. To clarify what I mean I would that discovering
that dreams are wish fulfillment is far more important than interpreting a
dream in a psychotherapy. Realizing that symptoms have meaning gave the society
a new sense of the structural nature of our psychological nature, instead of
the previous preoccupation with causes and effects. Psychoanalysis and some
psychoanalysts positioned structuralism in the humanities and created the
advancements we are enjoying right now.
It is a
moral obligation to revive psychoanalysis before it totally dies because it
belongs to our civilization and not to us as clinicians. Morality and moral
obligation are offshoots of responsibility. Our moral responsibility to save
psychoanalysis from its impending death comes from the fact that we, and nobody
or anything else have caused it to go dying: who or what else? Psychoanalysis,
as was conceived by none clinicians and we did not consider ‘real’ psychoanalysis
kept changing, getting better and more comprehensive. The changes in education,
in child rearing, accepting the idea of latent meaning in ordinary speech,
etc., kept developing, expanding and improving its basic premises, without
input from the organization of psychoanalysis (the IPA). The theory of
psychoanalysis was shaping the society while we stagnated or went afar from the
essential discovery. There is an undeniable fact related to that: when we
stopped building the theory of the subject there was nothing left for us to do
but to turn our attention to its practice as psychotherapy. We lost our
bearings. Clinical psychoanalysis as practice has a profession and practitioners,
but psychoanalysis as a body of knowledge and a theory of the subject has thinkers,
philosophers, scientists, practitioner in a wide range of other specialties. Just
to give a glaring example: it has movies and theater to practice.
Psychoanalysis
is not the profession of psychotherapy.
All analyst
without exception have professions that preceded bestowing on themselves the
title psychoanalysts. We all have obtained university degrees that qualified us
to apply to training in IPA institutes of psychoanalysis. This is not facetious
remark or just an argumentative ploy. We have to have professional rights in
the mental health field to have access to training in psychoanalysis.
Therefore, we mislead, mostly ourselves, when we do not acknowledge this fact. If
we miss this fact, we should then allow anyone with a recognized profession
(psychology, law, history of arts, commerce, etc.) apply and get training in
psychoanalysis and bestow on himself the title psychoanalyst; and practice it. The
criteria for accepting people in training was loose but got tightened up
gradually to be limited to mental health professionals: psychology, psychiatry
and social work (the details are not relevant to what I am to underline). However,
some institutes, when they felt the pinch, and under some pressures from the
training committees and the influence of some senior analysts accepted some
none health providers in training (I know few cases in the Canadian Society). Those
members, if they are truly good, are wealth to any society and this
trend should be encouraged. But they should not be permitted to see patients
based on their training in the IPA institutes only.
Discussing
this point is of crucial importance, because it puts psychoanalysis in its
proper place. If the mental health provider, who is trained in
psychoanalysis feels competent to do psychotherapy he should do that on his own
initiative that is rooted in his own professional background. However, there is
more to psychotherapy than what the IPA institutes provide. Practicing
psychoanalysis (psychotherapy) should not be authorized by the IPA and its
institutes. What I mean is that we should not link practicing psychoanalysis to
training in IPA institutes but to really learning psychoanalysis both theory
and technique and having the right to deal with patients. This issue should addressed
this point: is 2000-2500 hours of training in IPA institutes (excluding
personal analysis) enough to make ‘anyone’ learn psychoanalysis (as a body of
knowledge and technique)? I training in IPA institutes adequate for all of us-irrespective
of our backgrounds- be learn what it takes to practice psychoanalysis? The answer is no, not enough whatever the numbers
are. This is not a matter of how long training has to last to reach its
objective. The issue is that when we go for training, we should integrate
psychoanalysis with what we already learned in our specialty, not adapt our
specialty and basic profession to psychoanalysis. I learned psychoanalysis when
I was already a clinical psychologist. My profession as diagnostician by way of
psychometric testing did not change or was modified by psychoanalytic training;
maybe I became more particular in interpreting the patient’s psychometric
profiles, and maybe I improved my understanding of some of the cognitive
functions that I deal with in interpreting the patient’s associations. But,
training in psychoanalysis was to learn the body of knowledge called
psychoanalysis, which could allow me do psychotherapy in a special way. Psychoanalysis
was never my profession.
Friday, 5 July 2019
1.The
Moral Obligation of the Contemporary Psychoanalysts
In my opinion
psychoanalysis in North America is living under a false name or already dead.
In Europe and South America, it is living on low heart beat. If I do not have
the statistics or the proofs to support my opinion the challenger of my
judgement does not have the evidence to prove me wrong either.
Being an old
psychoanalyst, I strongly believe that my generation of psychoanalysts have a
moral obligation to persuade, guide, and actively help getting psychoanalysis out
from its current rot, to where it should flourish. It is difficult, yet there
is no substitute for trying. The difficulty is that- we the old guys- have to
recognize that we resisted the inevitable development and evolution of
psychoanalysis and some of us (particularly in north America) preferred to come
up with their personal views and claimed them appropriate to replacing the old
with the new. They still call them psychoanalysis. In other parts of the world
different things happened, but each area had its own style in modifying
psychoanalysis and improvising its method to keep it breathing. They do not
disclose easily its status and the IPA too keeps that as secrets. The
psychoanalytic institutions hide the facts about psychoanalysis from the psychoanalysts
!!!!. Those attempts to replace a dying
psychoanalysis have failed to actually fill its vacant place or revive it as substitutes.
The most they did was postponing the inevitable.
I will address that point
in another posting. But for now, I would say that we-psychoanalysts- helped preventing the death of
psychoanalysis but did not do what should have been done to revive it. We
always claimed that we are the custodians of psychoanalysis and limited any
input from none analysts (none clinically inclined intellectual). Their
contributions might have been useful but we did not take full advantage of them.
Secondly, there are two possible venues to revive psychoanalysis: to
tinker with the present way analysis is transmitted from generation to another
(training), make some tweaks in the its practice and use publicity to declare
its improvement. The other venue is changing completely the way analysis is transmitted
(education), declaring it a science and not a profession, then looking into
what is left off it that could still be of significance. To do that we must
move its base from the IPA accredited training institutes to academia, and
making it either a program in the departments of humanities or even make it one
of the departments of the humanities in the university.In a very recent posting
it was found out that the programs of psychodynamic and psychoanalytic subjects
in some universities were in big demand in the departments of human studies
that was offering them. In some large and reputable universities there was waiting
lists to register in those programs. I had an old experience (1964-1969) that
convinced me- in that early time- that psychoanalysis would have a very
welcomed and prosperous place in the departments of psychology at universities.
Experienced and old analysts like me oppose making the shift from
training (acquiring a skill or a trade) to learning and obtaining an academic
degree in a branch of knowledge (enough to qualify for a licenced profession). We
-old analysts-cannot forget that when we went to learn psychoanalysis, we were
already highly reputed professionals in our fields. Teaching psychoanalysis in
universities will let teenagers do what we considered for a long time a
privilege that we should cherish. We do not notice that those youngsters have
to learn much more than what was available to learn in our time, and they will
be the analysts who will do the real research in psychoanalysis. We also
resist to acknowledge that psychoanalysis in academia (with the graduate and
post graduate levels of studies) will open it to more than just the field of
psychotherapy. In Europe some universities were dedicated to open doors for
psychoanalysis but mainly in psychotherapy. The IPA institutes in those countries
maintained their traditional functions, which blurred the difference between
learning and training. A leap from training in parochial and archaic institutes
to learning in open well-connected departments of the humanities will be faced
by our resistance, but eventually the resistance will collapse. When that happens,
it will be our duty to participate in introducing good psychoanalysis to
the universities. It will be our duty to participate and contribute to putting
psychoanalysis where it should have been three decades ago.
An additional thing to do
is to give the IPA a specific period of time to wind down its role in
psychoanalytic education and to improve
its function as a membership institution.
Thursday, 30 May 2019
In the same spirit of my post about the present glorious times of a world going through change I want to add a couple of short paragraphs.
I was in Portugal lately. I followed a very significant European political event: the electing of the Parliament of the EU 28 countries for the next five years. Over 500 million subjects (old friends a foes) electing more than seven hundred representatives based on each country's independent political system. No procedural glitches, whatsoever. The dazzling thing is the role of the young is playing in the different countries and changing the face of the world there. The greens got rid of the central right and left parties. One of the leaders of the new movement is a 16 years old young woman with all the bright, mature, self confidence that we did not see in the "seasoned" politicians of Brexit and anti-Brexit. A child of Eight manged to make Starbucks stop plastic straws. In the US we watched something similar but on a smaller scale when school shooting happened and issue of the climate were mentioned in opposition to the knowledge and wisdom of Trump and his likes. The call for free education, health services, substantive changes in social justice is gaining recognition and strength in the States by pressure coming from teenagers and young people.
This is more than a phantasy for a guy who lived and still remembers the war in Europe and in East Asia, initiated by "old experienced politicians" (Hitler, Roosevelt, Stalin, Franco, Charles De Gaulle, Mao, Minh, etc.). In history, the history of of any human issue, the young start the revolutions and pressure for change but the old usurp the revolutions, and here we go again. But it seems that this is not happening anymore. The young are moving and holding to the reigns of power.
Could we see something similar in psychoanalysis? Psychoanalysis is also dying like old politics. We, old analysts,talk about the need for change and we just give it a lip service (maybe this the only part we could still move). Young analysts learned only the old analysis we taught them, in the same archaic institutes system, and infused in them the distorted image of the training analyst. The desperate needs for modernizing psychoanalysis expressed in "schools" were even more destructive because the schools were not dealing with the subject of analysis; they were distortions in its practice: from empathy to inter-subjectivity. The schools are the old hanging on to the straws that were the first indication of a sinking psychoanalysis.
Young analysts have no ideology to call a revolution and renewal. How could they assume the leadership in changing psychoanalysis or holding back the old dying psychoanalysis? They should know that we have nothing to offer, so they have to look at two things: why they want to be analysts, and that analysis is not matter of training. It is a knowledge, a theory of "something", and they will find it in psychoanalytic literature not in training based on transmitting knowledge from a person to person. Is it too much to expect a generation of psychoanalysts who say that we will stop doing analysis as psychotherapy and we will look for new, different, meanings to the act of psychoanalyzing? "We want to be analysts because it is knowledge we aspire to learn, not a profession we want to practice. It is too much to find enough young analysts who are trained by us-the old parochial-training analysts, who would say out loud: analysis is not psychotherapy?? Analysis is....something else and we will find ways to learn it. There are some actual analysts who are knowledgeable of what psychoanalysis is who would extend a helping hand.
The hope-and there should be some left- is some psychoanalysts who hold academic positions will bring it where they work as academics, making it an academic issue and not a 'professional' matter. The hope is to take reign of matters and not leave it to us the old cadre. We will not allow But even resist) our ways to be pushed aside and a new true knowledge of psychoanalysis emerge.
Things change, that is the normal course of events. Change needs new and daring people who know what is wrong with the present and take that as the starting point of finding the future.
Why not psychoanalysis too?
I was in Portugal lately. I followed a very significant European political event: the electing of the Parliament of the EU 28 countries for the next five years. Over 500 million subjects (old friends a foes) electing more than seven hundred representatives based on each country's independent political system. No procedural glitches, whatsoever. The dazzling thing is the role of the young is playing in the different countries and changing the face of the world there. The greens got rid of the central right and left parties. One of the leaders of the new movement is a 16 years old young woman with all the bright, mature, self confidence that we did not see in the "seasoned" politicians of Brexit and anti-Brexit. A child of Eight manged to make Starbucks stop plastic straws. In the US we watched something similar but on a smaller scale when school shooting happened and issue of the climate were mentioned in opposition to the knowledge and wisdom of Trump and his likes. The call for free education, health services, substantive changes in social justice is gaining recognition and strength in the States by pressure coming from teenagers and young people.
This is more than a phantasy for a guy who lived and still remembers the war in Europe and in East Asia, initiated by "old experienced politicians" (Hitler, Roosevelt, Stalin, Franco, Charles De Gaulle, Mao, Minh, etc.). In history, the history of of any human issue, the young start the revolutions and pressure for change but the old usurp the revolutions, and here we go again. But it seems that this is not happening anymore. The young are moving and holding to the reigns of power.
Could we see something similar in psychoanalysis? Psychoanalysis is also dying like old politics. We, old analysts,talk about the need for change and we just give it a lip service (maybe this the only part we could still move). Young analysts learned only the old analysis we taught them, in the same archaic institutes system, and infused in them the distorted image of the training analyst. The desperate needs for modernizing psychoanalysis expressed in "schools" were even more destructive because the schools were not dealing with the subject of analysis; they were distortions in its practice: from empathy to inter-subjectivity. The schools are the old hanging on to the straws that were the first indication of a sinking psychoanalysis.
Young analysts have no ideology to call a revolution and renewal. How could they assume the leadership in changing psychoanalysis or holding back the old dying psychoanalysis? They should know that we have nothing to offer, so they have to look at two things: why they want to be analysts, and that analysis is not matter of training. It is a knowledge, a theory of "something", and they will find it in psychoanalytic literature not in training based on transmitting knowledge from a person to person. Is it too much to expect a generation of psychoanalysts who say that we will stop doing analysis as psychotherapy and we will look for new, different, meanings to the act of psychoanalyzing? "We want to be analysts because it is knowledge we aspire to learn, not a profession we want to practice. It is too much to find enough young analysts who are trained by us-the old parochial-training analysts, who would say out loud: analysis is not psychotherapy?? Analysis is....something else and we will find ways to learn it. There are some actual analysts who are knowledgeable of what psychoanalysis is who would extend a helping hand.
The hope-and there should be some left- is some psychoanalysts who hold academic positions will bring it where they work as academics, making it an academic issue and not a 'professional' matter. The hope is to take reign of matters and not leave it to us the old cadre. We will not allow But even resist) our ways to be pushed aside and a new true knowledge of psychoanalysis emerge.
Things change, that is the normal course of events. Change needs new and daring people who know what is wrong with the present and take that as the starting point of finding the future.
Why not psychoanalysis too?
Wednesday, 24 April 2019
A
Glorious Time to Live:
Psychoanalysts tend to think of the unconscious as
material existing outside realm of consciousness. The unconscious material exists
in consciousness but in a disguised way, and that what makes it unconscious. We
are supposed to be trained to decipher those disguises and restore the material
to its original state. Treating a patient requires discovering the disguise and
revealing it to the patient, so he could do with it what he wishes. Social
groups do something similar with their matters, i.e., disguising their
willingness or unwillingness to change; similar but not the same. We are
presently living a period of history where change is not limited to one aspect
of our life or one place in the world. There is a mass of processes of social change
going on everywhere with different degrees of urgency. Yet, there is something
unique about that world awakening.
The world is going through major changes that are
different from equally drastic changes that happened before. Before, every step
forward taken by humanity involved resistance, which we can see around us again
in different degrees of intensity. Social resistance to change in the past manifested
itself in to changes resulted in more need for changing the changes that happened.
The German reaction to the Versailles surrender created changes that needed
changes in a second war. War was always the most used measure for resisting change
or paying for the change in advance. The equivalent to that in psychotherapy is
named resistance, which made change in most of the times a war with the
therapist as an enemy.
The current changes are different because they are mostly
done in conditions of peace or done peacefully (with the exception of the
changes in the Islamic world). Living in north America, watching the changes
that are happening in the US lately, and knowing few things about its impact on
other parts of the world (middle east for instance) urge me to mark some
features that could be of interest to analysts regarding social disguising of
intentions and meanings (social unconsciousness).
The current happenings
in the US are both political and social changes that will soon be in history books
and be read about only in books. It is a privilege to be close by and witness
that change. To witness the change is better than anything written about it. The
change in the US will ‘eventually’ have a remarkable effect on the world. They
are political changes but they are more of a change in the nature of the
American nation itself; an important nation that had a central place in the
events of at least the last century. It is also a nation which has shown
obstinate rejection to change in the past and blind adulation of its
forefathers, consequently of itself. The significance of the recent changes in
the US are not a simple process of maturation; they are creating a different
perspective for a past that was hastily judged to create a great deal of distortions
of the meaning of events. Americans changes will definitely have an impact on a wide range
of the world when they reach their Zenith.
Just as a start to put all that in perspective: A nation that-few
decades ago- would not elect the better candidate for president just because he
was Catholic is now open to elect a Jewish Socialist; that was when few months
ago the word socialism and few other terms were anti American and taboos .
Changes of such nature and extent have to be put in a context; any context- but not to be looked
at just as incomprehensible unusual turn of events. Fredrick Engels, after an
extensive and very intelligent analysis of the course history usually takes in
its progress, stipulated that History evolves in a dialectical spiral. Small events
happen in what seems a casual way and reactions to the whims of some political
characters or local events. They accumulate (unconsciously to the individuals) leading
to the day when a deciding event or
events that relate in a clear way to the innocuous events that happened
casually before. Then, and suddenly, the society takes note of that deciding event
and it becomes a historical moment; i.e., a
historical thesis. The historical thesis creates its antithesis and both
initiate a sweeping historical change. Minor and individual events, relating to
racial discrimination, kept happening (the multiple events that took place in
the US from the times of eliminating school segregations to the wave of open
objections to police brutality with blacks) till 9\11 happened and the whole narcissistic
edifice collapsed: ‘we are not what we always thought that we are’. Then, suddenly BOOM, the election of a
black president.
The election of a black president was not the only available
reaction to the American nation in its struggle against racial discrimination,
but it was the antithesis that proved to be essential for other changes to
continue advancing and not die sooner than it should. The US changed radically when
Obama was elected: no more prefabricated ideas of the supposedly right
president for ‘us’, maybe no prefabricated ideas about ‘our’ social life as
whole as well. Following the election of a black president a wave of breaking
old taboos became a national obsession. The idea of the white peoples’
entitlement over the blacks, or the entitlement of some groups over the rights
of their opposites (poor, uneducated, homosexuals, woman, etc.) was a national
game. However, to appreciate social change properly it has to be put in the
context of what was to be changed. In that case, the context that made electing
a black president significant was declaring the readiness to give up sacred and
very old dear and sacred elements of life that were gripping the nation’s.
Those fixed notions were a core of a sense of moral superiority. It meant that
some unquestioned sacred beliefs and convictions are now merely debatable
The Americans looked back at their past, and the
present, and possibly the future, especially after the 9\11 drama, and became
aware of a tendency to create pervasive unquestionable and blind senses of righteousness.
It took more time for the American to become aware that they are not entitled
to run the world according to their own sense of what is right and what is
wrong. It was also a shock to realize that there are other and better ways of
doing things than their own. Americans are open now to “not despise’ what is
not American. It was difficult to come to acknowledge that some blacks could be
better than an American white. The most important aspect in those changes is
how the Americans basic ideological sense of being is founded on those same
principles they believed that they have followed all the time. The whole world
was also waking up to its bundles of prejudices. The way Nelson Mandela was
received in Great Britain was far different from how Ghandi was received eighty
years before.
What we can see in the US is an obvious (not yet
fully sincere) trend to be just a part of the world, not only its leader. It
goes without saying that the impact of that kind of change is so new and
unfamiliar to the three generation living now in the US and the rest of the
world to appreciate its future effect. The impact of change in the US on the
Western world and the rest of it is very significant because it has already
made great progress in eliminating dictatorship in the world. There is something
ironic in this phenomenon. Dictators of the past suspended the constitutions of
their countries to rule without opposition; they did not break the law. In the
US the present elected president is trying to “constutionalize” dictatorship.
Analysts should study social phenomena psychoanalytically
and not use psychoanalysis to explain social phneomena.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)