Audience

Monday, 18 October 2021

 

A Different Way of Saying the Same Thing

 

1.Overlooking a Basic Link in Psychoanalysis:

Saying something more than once when that thing is important and needed emphasis or was not understood well enough to leave it alone. I am repeating a previously emphasized idea that ‘psychoanalysis’ is a term that could connote a body of knowledge, and also a specific modality of psychotherapy, but not both at the same breath. The main issue in that distinction is the link between what is usually named the theory of psychoanalysis and what is considered a technique of psychotherapy. Those are two different things but linked. That link is a most elusive subject to agree on its nature. My view of that link is that if there is a link (which I believe there is) it has to come from a well-defined, verified, clearly articulated theory, so the analyst would not practice psychoanalysis arbitrarily. He has to adhere to his understanding of psychopathology and therapy, and how one determines the other. If the analyst understand psychopathology as the outcome of intrapsychic distortions that were formed during growing up his approach in therapy would be concentrating his work on transference manifestations that will give him the insight about those distortions and what to do[aF2]  the reformulate their structure. If the analyst believes that he can deal with the interpersonal mismanagement of the psychopathology, he then will not bring transference in the work and concentrate on correcting the patient’s views about relationships. Each approach has clear distinctions in terms of what to do and what not to do.

Those two different understandings of psychopathology and its link with psychotherapy goes back to something in the Freud’s dealing with discovering ‘psychoanalysis’. Freud began the notion of psychoanalyzing with-maybe-some general social ideas about sexual frustration as a possible causation of hysteria emanating from common social attitudes and some remarks from physicians who must have encountered issues related to sexuality and morality in their daily medical practices.  Hypnosis showed him that he could make his patients talk about those frustrations in less reservations. However, he was able -due to his special psychological sensitivity- to hear double meanings in what patients were consciously relating to him. Talking did not just revealed ‘the unspoken about’ but also unconscious ideas that were implicit in what is spoken. The rest is our history. Freud was endowed with certain mental gifts in addition of great and advanced psychological familiarity with the neurological foundation of most of his discoveries in in psychotherapy (see the “The Project”, and Holms extrapolations). However, Freud noticed and intuitively knew what should be done with listening to the patients’ free associations. In 1912 he made the clear recommendations of a practice of good psychoanalysis; the three or the four (1910) restriction on practice. Nonetheless, he was the biggest culprit in breaking his rules (analyzing his daughter!!). In other words, Freud discovered the core qualities of the real and true psychoanalyzing but did not follow them. He was not a good clinician, but he discovered clinical work that matches his theory[aF3] . He dropped hypnosis and started ‘psychoanalyzing’ the patients’ speech. The link between what is said and what was ‘not said’ but relayed to Freud created that gap between psychoanalysis and psychoanalyzing.  

  However, the gap is very clear in the huge difference between his building of a body of knowledge about psychopathology and psychodynamics on one side and the technique of psychoanalyzing (practice) on the other. The gap between Freud’s clinical work and his knowledge of the subject of psychoanalysis remained a trademark of psychoanalysis as a whole and its literature, since then. The scarcity of clear and committed literature to how we do psychoanalyzing-practicing it- is the background of all the unresolved issues regarding the so-called theories of psychoanalysis (the schools). It is obvious that all the well-known schools of psychoanalysis that were competing for dominating it were related to its practice and not to new knowledge; with the exception of Kohut’s self-psychology. He killed it early trying to find a new way of practicing his sudden discovery of the duality of the subject.

The link between theory and practice looks important as a major issue in the world of psychoanalysis. But it is a link in every individual practice of psychoanalysis. A psychoanalyst who has his patient on the couch or on a chair in front of him has to keep in mind that he is obligated to keep the distinction between his understanding of what the patient relays to him and his response to it, should bridge that gap properly and in the proper moment. The link between his theory of psychopathology and psychotherapy will determine his response, from silence to reconstruction. This means that the practice of psychoanalyzing should always be based on the link between the two connotations of the term psychoanalysis. In other clearer way: the link between what we know and what we do with what we know is where a clinical psychoanalyst has to keep in mind all the time and readjust his work to make that link a daily obligation.


 [aF1]

 [aF2]

 [aF3]

Thursday, 30 September 2021

 

A responsibility we are supposed to carry:

In a second reading of Solms book it became clear to me that we psychoanalysts were or are not keen to advance our science or profession. We kept recycling old ideas and trying vainly to adjust and readjust some theoretical novelties, but we could only use the terminology that those the novelties introduced. The novel approach Solms has taken to study consciousness could actually lead to solving the issue of the unconscious and makes it clear. We need that because we should work on our difficulties, not leave it to others to solve for us. Just as sample: We know that the unconscious material comes in the forms of metonymy and metaphor, and what is unconscious is not a return of the repressed but a reformulation of what is conscious which happens outside the conscious mechanisms of expression. Solms is putting conscious in the core of our sense of being, thus the unconscious is related to the subject’s sense of being. My slip of the tongue or my transference say something ABOUT ME not hiding something of me. The conscious is only conscious relative to something unconscious (out of my sense of being) . Therefore, psychoanalysis is not making the unconscious conscious but making the subject own both of them as  his subjectivity. Missing a session does not have a meaning outside the patient’s recognition of himself in that missing. Analysis is analysis of the subject and not his expressed speech.

Monday, 27 September 2021

 

Analysis of the Subject and Analytic Material:

 

What ‘psychoanalyzing’ means is very important, yet it is neglected, and its literature is relatively not impressive. The immediate response to this query is that we analyze the patient’s free association with the assumption that ‘free’ associating reveals the unconscious. This basic assumption needs to be reviewed because created an attitude that we analyze the human subject in our patient when we actually try to get to the subject through his verbal and mental expressions and presentations. In other words, in effect we analyze the patient’s psychoanalytic material (association, memories, slips of the tongue, dreams, etc.) and not the subject himself. Then comes the question:  what else is the subject but his ‘psychoanalytic naterial’!!

A vignette might help:

A new female patient noticed that that that in coming up the elevator to her session there was a nice-looking woman who usually comes  down from my floor. She just mentioned that casually twice or three times. After few weeks she noticed that woman is not doing that anymore. In a casual way she mentioned that and made the comment that she must have finished her treatment. As she was familiar with the process she did not expect a response from me about her observations.

After a while she noticed the pretty woman coming down the elevator again. She made several remarks and did not get a response from me. The issue became a persistent issue in her analysis. As I was not responding to her disguised curiosity she expressed her thoughts that there must be some truth to her suspicion that there is something personal in the matter. After another period of agonizing curiosity about that woman and thoughts about jealousies she suffered from in different events in her life, I responded by saying that the presence of that woman in her association made her think and talk about aspects in her life that she did not tell me about before. She dropped silent for a while and then gave some confused memories about a childhood family situation in which her mother was unhappy and ended with her parents’ divorce.

Her parents’ divorce and the surrounding events was disclosed in my assessment interview and was not new material. My response to the repeated mentioning of that divorce was basically that there is some link between her thoughts regarding a personal relationship with that woman and the events that led to her parents’ divorce.  I followed that with saying that she is now talking about other people and not only her complaints. The outcome was a fundamental change[aF1]  though in a very subtle way. She was more expressive as a patient talking to her analysts than just ‘reporting’ things to him about herself., Put it another way: she became a living subject taking about a lived life; instead of a patient reporting a neurotic existence to her Shrink.

The idea is that in psychoanalysis we analyze the patient, i.e., the subject that appears to us in his associations. However, we should always consider that what we hear has to be interpretable to the subject who said them. In a different way, the subject has to relate what we interpreted to his own associations. Most of the time (in my experience) analysts depend on the way the theory of psychoanalysis understands the associations[aF2] . This kind of interpretation is not therapeutic interpretations because it misses the obvious fact that the patient is going to take it back to his own ‘theory’ of it.

If we remain on the level of interpreting the patient association we would not be doing psychoanalysis because we aim at restructuring the intrapsychic condition of the patient. We should be keeping that in mind when we do in interpreting because what we interpret has to be re-constructed. Therefore, the process of reconstruction has to be clear in the “consciousness’ of the subject. In other words, the associations are our windows to the nature of the subject’s intrapsychic structure.

This patient was not telling me what she thought of me as a professional; instead, she created a painful scene from her life that was not fully worked through. Transference is the return of the repressed but with the implicit meaning that it is in a ‘lived moment in the analysis. Analysis of the patient’s childhood experience is not the analysis of remembering it. Analyzing a remembered experience is very different from analyzing a transference event. Analyzing the patient’s memory, is not as analyzing the patient himself. Solms’s subject is a livening human event and not a representation of a subject.

 Interpretation as a Step Toward Reconstruction[aF3] :

The most important thing in our continuous questioning of psychoanalysis is missing the difference between A. Theory and Practice, B. Learning and training.

Theory and Practice:

Psychoanalysis began as a practice looking for a theory. This is the reason we are very much lost when it comes to the theory of psychoanalysis. I will dare we say it: We do not have a theory of psychoanalysis because we refrained from recognizing or realizing that “psychoanalyzing” is endeavored to discover the subject, and every subject is a theory in his own right. Thus, a theory of psychoanalysis should be a theory of the subject (See Solms). The practice of psychoanalysis is a different issue: it is the way we listen to patients giving us a picture of their intrapsychic dynamics and the way make them have a look on the way they are psychological structured with some help from us to add to their effort to change themselves. This is the work on -interpretation-reconstruction (base on the discovered subject). 

 

Learning and training is more of a political issue than I naively though thout at the beginning. So!!!!!!!


 [aF1]

 [aF2]

 [aF3]

Tuesday, 14 September 2021

 

The Next Step Before the Last.

I was intending to write a post on the narcissistic base of patriotism. The main notion is that we naturally react negatively to all kinds of narcissism. With narcissistic patriotism we seldom react so negatively, as if patriotism regarding one’s country is natural and unquestionable. However, narcissism it the core of any identification of which nationality is a prominent one. There are some aspects in identification that could go astray when the subject of the identification is badly chosen. Psychoanalysis could initiate that kind of stupid narcissism that stupid patriotism could also create.

Reading Mark Solms’s last book “THE HIDDEN SPRING” made me change my mind. I went [aF1]  back to an old disliked if not even hated subject: “Is old or even currant psychoanalysis still useful!!!!

Solms’s thesis takes us to a new start for the understanding[aF2]  of the Freudian thesis; no wonder he was dedicated to revising the English (official) translation of “The Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud”, which is due to appear this year. Although this is a separate issue it raises many points: do we know what to do to update our theory! Do we think that Freud’s text is a ‘passee’ issue and we should not be rereading it but concentrate on the more recent works of the new generations of analysts instead? Is it a better translation of Freud’s able to change anything regarding our present attempts at modernizing psychoanalysis?

First, Solms’s book is a very serious attempt at creating a new psychoanalysis. It is based on recent findings regarding neuropsychology which astonishingly corroborates Feud’s first publication (The Project, 1895). Solms’s neurological discovery and integrating it in the whole context of Freud’s Text with the notion of giving the Freudian text its veritable meaning. He is changing  the idea that we have one psychoanalysis and that it is  the present psychoanalytic situation.

I think there are[aF3]  an elephant and two monkeys in the room: Solm’s new translation and what was behind that request. After almost seven decades, of The Standard Edition: do we need verification and explanation of psychoanalysis? The monkeys are: what is missing or flawed in psychoanalysis as it is thought of now[aF4]  and required revising? The second monkey is: are we really going to reread Freud to qualify as psychoanalysts[aF5] ?

It is useful to make a distinction between the SE. as the source of the psychoanalytic vocabulary and as the psychoanalytic grammar.  Something we should underline; although the SE remained the undeniable index of Freud’s work and translation, the European translations of the body or the works of Freud corrected the foundational mistakes in the English Edition. I will get to that later but for now I want to address this issue: what we have been practicing till now in the English-Speaking world was not totally the real Freudian psychoanalysis. Most the established analysts will reject this idea vehemently, however, there are very important woks about this point in English (Laplanche, Bettelheim, which brought to the attention of the “Anglo” analysts the distortions in the SE.

 The notions I will mention (to follow) will be just unmasking the second monkey in the room. Psychoanalysis is psychoanalysis as a verb and not nouns or adjectives. As an example: dealing with Trieb as a thing (instinct). and not as a pressure put on the mind to make the subject act turns psychoanalysis into a theory of functions not an act of analyzing structure. The evolution of Freud’s work attest to the progressing unmasking of the human subject.

If all that is gibberish have the freedom to say I like psychoanalysis as is or I will go to a new notion of psychoanalyzing.


 [aF1]E

 [aF2]

 [aF3]

 [aF4]That

 [aF5]ost

Saturday, 28 August 2021

 

Freud’s Intuitive Discovery of Psychoanalysis and the Essential “Classical” Rules of Practice.

I expect that neurological, neuropsychological, and psychoanalytic discoveries will ultimately reveal a link between intuition and the unconscious. By knowing how to analyze such link it will be possible to answer this question: Do great thinkers uncover what they discover about the human subject and human nature by intuition or do they unconsciously sleepwalk to their great thoughts. Did Freud discover psychoanalysis intuitively or through a process of organized thinking? The differences in answering this question could help us decide if psychoanalysis is something that has to be taken the way Freud proposed it with minimum elaboration, or we could take it as a starting point in a progressive process of thinking.    

There is something about the start of psychoanalysis that forces that question on us: Why did Freud start so early in his psychoanalytic journey by thinking and working on the proper conditions of practicing it (1910,1912)?  Did he intuitively foresee that there are surprises awaiting us if we followed him in the path to therapy? Or did he anticipate that practicing psychoanalysis will lead to more than just replacing hypnotism with free association?   

                     ___________________

In a previous publication (‘Understanding Classical Psychoanalysis,2017) I underline the great intuition that Freud had to standardize the practice of his new discovery, ‘psychoanalysis’. In my opinion then, and now, a profession based on listening to a person speaking about himself in order to lead patients to change their intrapsychical dynamics has to be done in a consistent predictable environment, and treatment has to be decided only by achieving its success within that unchangeable protocol. This is not the familiar medical model of therapy in which the physician is the one who decides about the treatment. Standardizing the conditions of doing psychoanalysis was Freud’s ‘intuitive’ work on the patient’s disclosures. They have to be derived from within an identical process of work, with very limited external interference and variations that could affect the analyst’s unfolding of the unconscious aspect of the patient’s self, as well as affecting the analysand’s gains of insight. There was also the requirement of maintaining a necessary distance (mild in the case of the patient) between the patient and the analyst. Freud’s tripartite protocol for doing psychoanalysis and the regularity of the patient’s sessions added to restricting analysis to what the patient says about himself formed the criterium of the correctness of the analytic process.

The rules of practicing analysis, which were inherited ‘blindly’ up till now, were founded on the available knowledge of what psychoanalysis was, then. I have to add that early psychoanalysis and most of current points of view are basically of functional nature (causes like deprivations and effects like reaction formation, etc.), which limit or eliminate the uncovering of the intrapsychic psychodynamics which is the forming influence of the psychopathological condition.

There was an underlying tendency to use the new vocabulary improvised by new discoveries as theoretical background of an advancing psychoanalysis. But the main trend was to make psychoanalyzing an act of ‘making sense’ of the psychoneurotic conditions, assuming that this ‘making sense’ is the curable factor.

Things have changed overtime: in the first place we know now much more about the structures of psychical phenomena.. We also know that obvious functional understanding of psychological manifestation is more likely to be misleading and limiting of the analyst’s field of work. Moreover, we deal now with much more healthy patients- in terms of the old criteria of pathology, which makes our work in need for serious revisions of our blind rules of practice. Thirdly, we should have realized by now that the practice of psychoanalysis as therapy is related to the intrapsychical structures of the patients and not about pressures, deficiencies, lacks, deprivations that still demands satisfactions, etc. The rules of psychoanalysis that we followed till now in terms of the number of sessions per week, the length of time of a session, duration of therapy for cure (or training), couch, vacations, etc., were arbitrarily established in the past, and were chosen to fit the analysts’ professional needs (not the patient’s requirements).

In other words, the rules of practicing psychoanalysis did not come from the patients’ need or from understanding what psychoanalysis is about, because there was very little known about any of that till few decades ago. But I assume that we know now what unconsciousness versus consciousness means, how to interpret psychological material and reconstruct interrelated psychical manifestations which changes the nature of our work from receiving the remnants of transference to showing the patient the intrapsychical distortions in his transference relationship with the analyst. We are not automats who just follow a prescribed way of practice; we are supposed to know the psychodynamics of the human subject and the way to deal with them to affect the required changes.

Learning and Training in Psychoanalysis:

The history of psychoanalysis shows that it had to begin with a period of apprenticeship, which lasted much longer than the usual apprentice periods in other professions. Both the master craftsmen and student in psychoanalysis were learning a totally unexplored field of knowledge. However, in a gradual way knowledge about human psyche accumulated and most of the pioneer apprentices turned that knowledge into a theoretical body (though stubbornly most senior analysts wanted it to remain some details of a profession of psychotherapy). By the seventies of last century there was a firm body of knowledge, and interest in that knowledge in neighboring fields of academics, to turn psychoanalysis from an apprenticeship to an academic branch or program. Doing that conflicted with the personal interests of the leading psychoanalysts, or the training analysts. Although that at the present time there are great kafuffles, debates, and complaints about the Training Psychoanalyst status they is a resistance to SEE that we cannot have a training system based on apprenticeship without having master craftsman (A training senior). How could we maintain the model of apprenticeship in training candidates in an IPA and alike institutes without “training analyst”?

Back to the standard rules of practice:

·       The standers rules of practice, which we follow till now, were very useful but were arbitrarily decided then.

·       They reflected an early status of psychoanalysis based on a limited knowledge of what psychoanalysis is.

·       Knowing what we know now about psychoanalysis, as well as

psychoanalyzing (interpretation and reconstructing) demand a review of our practices.

If the notion of a need for a new psychoanalysis is accepted a revision of the practice will come as a natural outcome. If that notion is rejected there will be no need for revising those rules because they will die with the dying psychoanalysis.

Whatever the way will lead us to  the link between the psychoanalysis we adopt and the method we will apply it is not arbitrary: we practice the psychoanalysis that dictates its own method.

Friday, 20 August 2021

 

Addendum to the previous posting: The Irma dream

I received a few remarks and queries about something I said in my above published note on the unconscious. I said:” The unconscious is a state in the mind that is of a linguistic structure, or an explicit structure in the mind that could be talked about, even as an absence.

What I understood of the unconscious and put it in my own thoughts and words is that our minds have the potential to turn something conscious into something unconscious via innate linguistic adeptness. That process, transforms the intrapsychical conflicts into interpersonal relations or wishes, thus conceals its real content. The mind translates the intrapsychical entities into verbal or proverbial meanings, but seldom succeeds completely in achieving that goal. That is how Freud’s controlled rage the night before the Irma dream and projecting his anxiety (intrapsychical constructs) regarding the physicians’ opinion of him created -while asleep- the scene that when translated into words revealed a statement of contempt OR a wish to be blameless. 

This way we can put the unconscious outside cognitive function of consciousness because even if the subject’s function of consciousness is affected by something neurological or physical he still could have his psychological life intact and make things unconscious in the analytic sense. We could be neurologically brain imperfect but mind OK.  

          By detaching consciousness from its neurological basis, we get to deal with two other very central issue of psychoanalysis: interpretation and construction\reconstruction. Because the unconscious is a function of the mind and not of the brain the mind and its amenability to verbalization can only be made conscious when it is interpreted (matching verbal forms with meaningful content). Iinterpretation is the analytic act that gives the unconscious its meaning when the time comes to understanding the vagueness of some psychical material. 

The Irma Dream attests to the fact that the Unconscious is not a psychical entity (negative ideas…), content (censored intentions), a process that turns psychological entities into different entities (nonverbal or psychical). The unconscious is a state of mind that has a clear linguistic structure, or it is an explicit structure in the mind that could be talked about to make what is absence (unconscious)to presence.

A patient who lost her mother to suicide was constantly apprehensive to hearing bad news. There was nothing basically unconscious in the ‘symptom’ in light of her mother’s way of dying. But at certain times her apprehension was more active after disagreements with her stepmother. On one occasion the analyst requested her to talk more about her relationship with that woman because her anxiety about what could transpire in any of those times made the kind of apprehension itself unexplainable.  In that talk the analyst pointed out to her that her apprehensions seem to come in place of anger, which made her think for a while. Interpreting and reconstructing her apprehensions with the stepmother engendered few memories and thoughts stemming from losing her mother very young (nine years old). Working on that issue showed that anger and fear were unconsciously fused to make one bring the other forward in consciousness. Unconsciously the fusion of opposite feelings confused the patient but verbalizing them (from analytic material) turned the unconscious into consciousness and permitted some reorganizing of the intrapsychic configurations of anger \fear, and fear\anger. Still, reorganizing the intrapsychic in an effective way needed both analyst and patient to find the proper points where the disorganization happened. In this case the patient talked about memories of her mother’s suicide and how both sadness and anger at her mother for what she did scared her of herself. Anger, fear, sadness and a strange sense that she will never grow up “produced” a setup of both her intrapsychical and interpersonal worlds in which the patient had to make the unconscious conscious in order to work on reconstructing her psychical identity.  

The unconscious should not be treated as if it is the same substance of Cs.\Ucs; it could only take one of those two forms in the act of interpretation. It does not connote certain material but denotes the state of certain material. Those subtle, and sometimes not so subtle distinctions make the analyst listen to differentiate the unconscious from the conscious and preconscious. When that is done then the latent meaning in the unconscious should be verbalized (normally in stages if needed). When that is done both analyst and analysand- through free associating about the ‘content’ of the conscious and preconscious, should gradually identify the event or events where the intrapsychic has lost its integrity and work on reconstituting and reconstructing it. Psychoanalysis is the finding of disturbed intrapsychic conditions, make them conscious, then reconstructing them by the ‘working through’. However, this process needs some long time and several attempts, but it is much more effective if we listen (the basic and most difficult work) to hear first the unconscious talking.  

In this patient, her main topic was her mother’s suicide (not her mother), what that event tells about the mother (a mixture of longing and rage), exposes a sense of not getting what was her right to have…. What the mother’s suicide made her lose.    

Thursday, 19 August 2021

 

The Irma Dream, the Unconscious, and a New Psychoanalysis  

 

Freud and early psychoanalysts worked on discovering the psychological nature of the human subject. Now we reached the point where we should be curious about that ‘psychological subject that was discovered’: he always says more about himself than what he intended to say. He also understands more than the speaker intended to say with no help from any speaker. Not everything about that happen consciously. We should also deepen our understanding of what could constitute an aspect in a new and contemporary psychoanalysis “the unconscious”. It is one of those aspects that still intrigue psychoanalytic thinkers.

……………………………….

                                            

The unconscious is a term that is foundational and fundamental in the concept of psychoanalysis. It goes without saying that psychoanalysts are expected to know well what ‘unconscious’ means. Yet, this idea is not supported by the literature of psychoanalysis, even in the Freudian text itself. Freud specified three types of unconsciousness (topographic, dynamic and the systemic) suggesting that the term is a denotation not a connotation of a specific something. Analysts and none-analysts mean by unconscious either not conscious or something that has been conscious and got repressed, thus it is not anymore conscious. Linguistically, ‘unconscious’ is the not conscious. The prevailing sense, whether in psychanalysis or elsewhere, is that consciousness is the basic state of affairs or the natural source of phenomena in its positive or negative state. There is something to mention about that. This state of uncertainty about a basic concept in psychoanalysis requires a dedicated new study of the human subject or studying the human subject differently than the usual concept the double and adapt to the concept of duality.

A point of view:

Over years of being active and in the midst of the psychoanalytic movement I came to realize a simple and a straightforward fact; psychoanalysts do not delineate ‘well’ the difference between causes and effects in psychical life. The notion of the unconscious gave us the privilege of assuming that the existence of unconsciousness is enough to confuse the link between causes and effects. Thus, we would not find and answer to this question in our literature including Freud’s own: is the unconscious the cause of certain psychical phenomena (parapraxes for example) or does the parapraxes and similar events cause something conscious become unconscious or are they cause by something unconscious. There is nothing in language itself or in the function of speaking that could explain parapraxes in terms of causes and effects. Therefore, in order to answer the question of the unconscious without inviting many exclamations marks I am resorting to a dream (well-known one) to make the necessary distinction within the duality of Cs\Ucs, and the meaning of unconscious, analytically speaking.

The Irma Dream (the first analytically interpreted dream) was about a patient of Freud (Irma) who was not doing well in therapy. A friend of his mentioned that to him the night before the dream; something that frequently worried him early in his new career as therapist. He worried about his critics in the medical community using those chances to belittle his claims to a new discovery in the field of the neuroses. He was uncertain about his self-worth and worried about humiliation. He had a high degree of tension in that regard the night before the dream.

His dream that night was a scene of a gathering of the physicians whom he has some tension with. In the dream he depicted them the way he would have liked them to be in reality (mostly idiotic). The same with the patient whom he depicts as uncooperative and resisting his work. His interpretation of the dream was a functional interpretation (the dream was a function or the result of a wish).  He concluded (in his own words) that “the dream represented a particular state of affairs …its content was the fulfillment of a wish, and its motive was a wish” (p.118-119. His interpretation of the dream as a function or the result of a wish makes no sense that could explain of the complex process that created his complex ‘dream scene’. However, there is question about Freud’s interpretation of that dream.

The wishful content of the dream was ‘vaguely’ conscious in his mind before sleeping. Yet, the complex scene of the dream itself and all the meaningful details that could be derived from those details happened were formed only during his sleep. There is no mention of thinking consciously or preconsciously of anything similar before sleeping. This implies that the meaning of the dream happened ‘not consciously’ because the dreamer did not have the vaguest idea about his dream before dreaming it. The most remarkable and interesting is how Freud structured such a complex scene- in which he made fools of the medical gathering and accused the patient of resistance to his suggestions- and fulfilling his wishes to maintain his self-worth, all happened and was done while he was sleeping. Freud created a complicated solution to his anxiety, unconsciously, while he was sleeping, and most of all it was all in the language of consciousness. Did Freud think about his dream before dreaming it? Were there any signs of how he intended to exonerate himself from harming his patient before going to sleep?

The answer to those questions is no. The Irma Dream attests to the fact that the Unconscious is not a psychical entity (negative ideas…), content (censored intentions), a process that turns psychological entities into different entities). The unconscious is a state of mind that has a clear linguistic structure, or an explicit structure in the mind that could be talked about as an absence.

The Irma dream shows in a clear way that it is in the nature of the human subject to establish his relations with his world according to his intrapsychic structures, needs and potentials, not according to the nature of the external world itself and its demands. This point is of major importance: the human subject has a spontaneous tendency to create the world around him according to is internal psychical organizations, and in that case the external world would be of a functional usage or value and structured to serve the subject intrapsychical demands. Therefore, psychoanalysis that is built on the notions of drives, resistance to certain drives, psychodynamics of conflicts, need for ‘hiding and revealing’ the defended against internal pressures, correcting, and redressing and restoring defects ignores (avoids) the main issue of the duality of consciousness and unconsciousness that decides the reaction. In our contemporary psychoanalysis, those elements mentioned above are separated from other things by ‘defenses’ and exist in the subject as his unconscious. Despite the obvious ownership of what a mind could generate, the human subject has the audacity to still ‘negate’ that ownership.

The point to underline here is that consciousness and unconsciousness are of the same fabric (linguistically) and when the ‘unconscious’ becomes conscious we find nothing intrinsically different in it from what was split or separated from, i.e., consciousness, even in sleeping. The most interesting about the duality of Cs\Ucs. is their inseparability and the ease by which they could exchange places rhetorically. The conscious subject is only one ‘aspect’ of the subject that he truly is, because what is unconscious proves to be the other aspect which is of the same cloth. The two aspects complement each other and together make a psychical self.

This where the distinction between the intrapsychical the interpersonal happen or be examined

At this point I have to get myself in trouble in order to explain this point better. Consciousness is merely negation of unconsciousness. The intrapsychic-even in the simple meaning of the term- is unconscious or preconscious in the eyes and ears of the experienced psychoanalyst. No confirmation of a conscious issue, or just a conscious notion, can stand by itself as a separate issue: it has to implicitly negate its opposite, i.e., we consciously negate the unconscious [ I am doing good work with Irma…she is resisting me, and you could see that in her preset resistance to be examined by you]. This might sound strange to analysts who do not question the nature of the verbal human who is us, or the nature of the symbolic order we live in which necessitates the coexistence of the antithesis of the duos that constitute our lives. Yet there is and adage that I do not remember who came up with, which goes like this: The Ego is Negation.

The Psychoanalysis of the Discovered Subject:

Anything we think of or speak about has its negation present in the same sentence. This is something that permeates every aspect of our mental, cognitive, psychological and social life [when Freud depicted the gathered physicians in his dream as idiots he indirectly (unconsciously!) said ‘I am not one of them and am not an idiot like them”. There is another characteristic of human language that allows other matters to happen equally unconsciously. Human language has the grammatical and the vocabulary that could make the affirmative confirms the nature of the opposite at the same time. If I say I would never try to mislead anyone makes misleading a conscious issue, without which it was not there consciously but unconsciously. The speaker could unconsciously use the potentials of human language and say something he did not intend to say: parapraxes, negation of negation, omission, etc. The same could happen to the listener who could hear something said in the speech of another which was not intended to be heard. Human language is structured that way: Animals’ quasi languages affirms but have no place for the negation of the affirmed.  

My point is that Freud revealed an aspect of the human subject that characterizes his most intimate and personal nature… his intrapsychical makeup and formations. He also revealed the existence of unconscious psychical entities that reside only in a linguistic structure in the mind. Those two discoveries explain how a psychical issue is expressed outside the verbal limitation of consciousness (intrapsychic sense of inferiority!). Awell verbalized conscious interpersonal issue could be totally irrelevant conscious issue. The intrapsychic structures are more likely to be unconscious and their interpersonal equivalent be the material for consciousness.

  If this distinction makes sense to analysts the next step is to rethink practice and training. Resistance to rethinking our psychoanalysis is not pervasive.