Audience

Wednesday, 2 January 2019


2. Research and psychoanalysis.
The discussion about research and psychoanalysis would die in the womb if it is not put in its proper context: Who and What initiated it lately? I am saying that because the outcome of this discussion and two previous ones with a small group of colleagues- whether “it stops at that” or continues beyond ‘that’- does not seem to related to any defined purpose. We just air some frustration we did not even articulate…the frustration with the state of psychoanalysis at the present time.  This year we got from the IPA the notion that the organization is going to sponsor research in psychoanalysis as an attempt to rejuvenate its “dormant” potential.
The problem - point blank- is the crisis of psychoanalysis in regard to the falling interest in it from patients and the young professionals who are less interested in faltering profession. In 1995, the IPA (the House of Delegates) formed a group of senior analysts to study (The Actual Crisis of Psychanalysis: Challenges and Perspectives). The outcome was reflective of the state of psychoanalysis itself, not the circumstances around it (See Cesio’s report on the findings in the IPA publication). Neither there was an agreement on anything in that report nor was a follow up on the subject. In my opinion, the thing that is keeping psychoanalysis alive till now is that we believe that it is still there and also the presence of our organizations, weak and disorganized as they are.In other terms, the issue that research is going to prove that psychoanalysis is still a viable psychotherapy, and if we publish those results, we will convince patients to seek it as a superior psychotherapy.
The IPA’s first report has several intelligent a revealing remarks about training and the loosing of our identity as psychoanalysts. There was no mention of solutions. I mention that to bring to attention that the IPA and We, as devoted members, are looking for what is wrong with people who are not paying attention to what is best for themselves (them !!).
Going back to the issue of research. A group of psychologists and three psychologist-psychoanalysts discussed (twice) the notion of investigating and comparing the changes resulting from psychoanalysis and ordinary psychotherapies. We thought of applying psychological tests (MMPI) before and after two years of psychotherapy. Although we were aware of the problems of sampling and discussed the issue of matching the therapists, two difficult problems remained unresolvable: giving the psychological test before the start of the therapy will influence the outcome of the therapy, and psychoanalysts are unable to be definitive enough about what they consider “change due to psychoanalysis”. This is the reason I could say with confidence that research in the human sciences is either impossible or will not lead to the certainty we expect from research.
W. Windelband (1894) clacified sciences into two groups: Nomothetic sciences, which generally pertain to the physical world. They search (and research) for the laws and the causal factors in physical phenomena.  The most imposing feature in this group of sciences is the deductive method of reaching its theories, which allow explaining matters. The other group the idiographic sciences which pertain to the human subject in all his attributes. They investigate human phenomena inductively (the intrapsychical) to discover their structural nature, thus could be interpret, Psychoanalysis, despite all Freud’s efforts and his disciples (like us) to objectify its findings is a human science and we cannot prove the correctness of our interpretations by any external evidence.
Therefore, we should be careful what we wish for: the wish to research psychoanalysis either will prove nothing, or if it proves something it will be a laughing matter to the serious researchers. 

Monday, 31 December 2018


Analyst are getting elated if not excited about the IPA's push toward encouraging research  in psychoanalysis.

Dr. Lear, who has a good position to examine  psychoanalysts' conception of research, gave some valuable comments that he and his team require to support research in Chicago University. I believe most analysts should think of those comments to balance out their excited enthusiasm  about research.

Dr. Jonathan Lear's remarks about research in psychoanalysis are important in putting us in a true perspective of what research is and in psychoanalysis in particular.

To start,: there are three questions that we should begin with answering: Why do we need research in psychoanalysis? What do we need to research in psychoanalysis? Who will be doing the research?

The first question: Psychoanalysis reached its peak in the seventies of last century without any thoughts regarding research, because what it offered (discovering the intrapsychic core of the subject) was remarkably evident and palpable to everyone. It was not an issue of whether it existed or not. Discovering the intrapsychic stimulated other human sciences to conduct researches in their own  fields of interest. child and social psychology are examples. We should keep in mind that those were investigations and not research. It is IMPOSSIBLE to do research in the humanities more so in psychoanalysis.

The second question: Most of what has been expressed till  now was about proving the effectiveness of psychoanalysis (as therapy). This issue (is psychoanalysis effective or more effective than other therapies) requires research of the "experimental type" to come up with answers of yes or no.  The experimental type of research is based on comparing two axact  samples of the research material, change only one aspect in one of the two samples to find out if that experimental change gives an answer of yes or no.  We cannot select two axat groups of patients (age, education, intelligence, etc., and degree of neuroses) plus two similar  groups of psychoanalysts (especially that we do not have one psychoanalysis or system of training) to conduct a scientific research.

The third question is of  who will do the research. It does not need too much fidgeting about that. Nothing in our training qualifies us to do research or investigations. The reasons are boring to mention and would be of no interest to people who think that they know the results of the  research and the investigation beforehand.

 Dr. Lear's description of some of the misunderstandings of the ethics of research are waking up calls to the analysts who think that research in psychoanalysis will solve the problem of its loss of its credibility. The loss of the credibility of psychoanalysis is not going to be managed by some ill guided or unrealistic research conceptions. It will be regained when we produce credible psychoanalysis, as was he case fifty years ago.   

Thursday, 20 December 2018



The Trump's sense of omnipotence.

I am writing a long post on the issue of diagnosis to be posted in few days, if in those days it is still  of value. However, the responses I received suggest that my purpose of getting involved in the issue of diagnosis was missed. Arnie Richards is the one who got the gist of it and reminded us twice about it: We are trying to help the senators to know what they are blindly.supporting.

Yet the resignation of the secretary of defense few hours ago obliges me to open the subject of the danger of withdrawing the American troops from Syria one more time.

The withdrawal will create a vacuum that has to be filled immediately or it will be occupied by Iran or Turkey. Israel will find itself dragged into the conflict forcibly. Knowing some things about the middle east Arab would accept  Iran or Turkey over Israel including the anti iran and Turkey. There will a possibility of a limited war but war all the same. More dead, maimed, children in misery on all sides of battlefield.   

My layman understanding of the Trump personality ( not a diagnosis) is a spoiled teenage brat with law IQ. He responds to fear with stupid bravado.  Lately the noose is getting tighter around his neck regarding his future. He is ( as he says) not a coward, rat, or scared. He will show them...us. He is reckless and self destructive (6 Bankruptcies) and now he is going into one of those situations. As a slightly retarded adolescent he thinks this bankruptcy will be like the previous ones; and he will be bailed out by someone.
It might happen by the stupidity of the senates but it could also take the party down with him.    

Wednesday, 19 December 2018

I am posting this post without the hesitation I always feel any time I make a comment on the US political scene. The reason is that it is scary, very scary to see the world so vulnerable because of Trump's presidency.

It seems that Trump took the decision to withdraw the US from Syria on his own and without consulting with any advisory body in his government. He did not do that before and this step he took with Syria's affair is ominus.
Making a diagnosis of Trump is REALLY of no value except for us who are making the diagnoses.  We should also remember that we - analysts-do not have a measure of normality to give our diagnoses any significance, even to psychiatrists.
However, as mental health providers we could and should express our views regarding Trump's mental and cognitive competence to preside over the administrative   branch in a country like the US. This is not building a wall or raising the price aluminum siding of homes. In the most limited version of the result of his decision there is a possibility of few tens of thousand killed and a similar number of refugees with no where to go this time.
Impeachment will not happen ( I am sure), disqualifying him mentally on cognitive and psychiatric measures is the way to encourage the wobbly senators to call for dismissing him as they did with Nixon before. It is unfair and immoral to allow a mentally deranged man cause so much misery away from his home to please his base at home

Tuesday, 11 December 2018


Quote for Anyday



Sometimes, in some countries, politics is white collar prostitution. 

Thursday, 6 December 2018

A diagnostic test for Trump

Yesterday, we in North America and to most of Europe watched  how the passing of a respectable president of USA was honoured. Whatever could be said about him his nation expressed appreciation, respect and love. The presidents and the dignitaries of the world showed their deference of the man.

Trump was present in the ceremonies. His participation was supposed the be of one of  very few- beside his family- who could give the funeral the status of a high event. He was pitifully neglected, distained, and sat there unwelcome guest.  The eulogies were almost direct critique of his style of presidency.

How he is going to react to yesterday's rejection of Americans and the Europeans is a test to his sick mind:

If narcissist he will be neraged (more than the usual).
If neurotic (hysterical disorder) he will be dangerously suicidal.
If psychopath he will make open gestures of defiance.
If no change or back to his daily silliness then the man is psychology dead. That could only happen when external or the reality of the others does not succeed in penetrating a neurological barrier between his mind and reality.
   

Thursday, 15 November 2018




3.Toward a Psychoanalytic Explanation of Social Events

History, myths, and social unconscious.


In preparing to write this part of the issue of the Social Unconscious I went back to Freud’s paper on Family Romances. I wanted to refresh my memory of how the individual creates his individual history from his earlier childhood experiences. I was struck by a statement that I missed in my previous readings of this paper.  After describing some general childhood experience and how they are remembered later Freud said: “These consciously remembered mental impulses of childhood embody the factors which enables us to understand the nature of myths”. Reading this sentence brought to my mind a book I read few years ago by Ray Raphael entitled: The Founding Myths. The book was proving in a methodical way the fallacies of some of the held beliefs about certain historical facts regarding the American revolution and independence. At the time I read the book my thoughts were that history is more important than the facts that created it, and making myths out of actual events is essential in turning events into lasting facts. Without those myths’ history would not link with the present and it would become meaningless. In other words, Jefferson declaration of independence is the issue and not whether he copied and improved Mason’s     prior daft of the document or not.
My point is that the facts and myth that comprises history constitute together the core of a nation’s identity. A similar process is behind the individual conception of our history. Whatever embellishment or correction made to any history it remains what people have created, accepted as the doing of real people in their past. British democracy is worth its value because it is connected to the myth of the Magna Carta! The Magna Carta is a fascinating document that was going to be ignored just few months after signing it, but it was brought back by the initial people who created it, thus it represents the resilience of democracy.
History is very much like dreams; it is there for interpreting. They are also phenomenon of wishful thinking, and that is enough to legitimize a nation’s ownership of its own history. Historians could vet history but people who will decide to accept it or reject it. The notion of history as the embodiment of a nation’s wishes is important in another aspects. Nations’ wishes change over time and relative to circumstances, but historical facts do not change. Therefore, nations could change the narrative of their histories to pronounce a certain wish at a certain time and give it work- over to express another wish. History is the reservoir of the nation’s wishes and is very much made of primary process mechanisms.
It is not difficult to accept and agree that history consciously tells of the past wishes of nations. Because history is the conscious story of those wish therefore there must be corresponding unconsciousness of the wishes. This is where we encounter the puzzle of social unconsciousness: There is no history that articulates the same wish all the time. History is recalled by nations according to existing circumstances, and the wishes keep changing accordingly. This means that social unconsciousness is not an entity (like in the case of the individual).  The unconscious of the conscious wishes is the frustration of not fulfilling them. in other terms, history continues telling about a social wish until a leader or a group of individuals come along and fulfill the wish. Then history stops to start from a different point or with a new wish.
I can talk concretely about this idea in regard to the history of Egypt, which I know reasonably well. In 1882 England invaded Egypt, and an Egyptian general gave the British a fight but lost. They occupied the country and it became a colony in the British empire. The history of Egypt at that point became a series of mythical attempts of conquering the occupiers and regaining independence. There were several revolutions and some ineffective trials to outsmart the British politically. In 1952 a group army officers managed to liberate the country. Egypt was the first Middle Eastern country to break away from the British empire. The history of liberating the country stopped then. But suddenly a new wish to liberate all other occupied colonies in the middle East and Africa became the new history of Egypt. And once again an Egyptian leader with that ambition appeared to become a mythical character in the area, because he expressed a wish that pertains to the whole area of the middle east. His name was Nasser. He is still after half a century of his death represents the old wish of liberating the middle because its total liberation is stil in the making and the wish is fought against by internal and external forces.  
History is the consciousness of nations and embodies their wishes and aspirations. Those aspirations that are conscious have their unconscious counterpart, which is not always easy to define. However, frustrated wishes get their definition and surface to social consciousness in an unusual way. A leader or a group of dedicated people emerge with a vison of change that is the social unconscious pronounced.  Leadership is the voice of the unconscious in a society. There are implicit dangers in the transformation from an individual or a group leadership to a social will. It happens more frequently than desired the a leader distorts the unconscious wish of his society, or expresses the wishes of a minority and run with it if the majority is looking for, high jacking an unconscious wish and changing midway, and other possibilities could be found in Modern Democracies. Leaders do not create history, they only pronounce it. Studying the history of a nation is done properly by putting its leaders in the context of its circumstances. Because misleading and being followed after changing the unconscious wish has a more encompassing meaning. People follow their leaders but they also affect other people around them in ways that could change the whole political scene. This need a separate section of this topic. As we know in individual psychoanalysis, the patient’s change cause changes around him.